Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Simple question

Posts

Simple question

#1

Simple question

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>What is the best woodworking periodical? Why?

My choice is "Woodwork" for its in-depth profiles, project features, technical articles, gallery of work, and some philosophy.

Clint

Re: Simple question

#2

Re: Simple question

Greg Haugen

>Sometimes a simple question has a complex answer. I'm not too sure if there is an "Ultimate" publication just like the "Ultimate" brand of tools or Pick-up Truck. I do think "Woodwork" is one of the finer options along with Fine Woodworking. I've been moderately impressed with Woodcraft's as well. As far as American Woodworker, WOOD, Woodworker's Journal, and Popular Woodworking it really comes down to individual issues in my view. No one publication from those really seperates itself enough. They all have started a "turning" section, etc. If one does something, they all do it. I may have a preference to one because a good friend is on their staff now, but that's it. The annual buyer's guides, and specialty issues (example WWJ's Routers and Tips) are invaluable in a woodworker's collection though.

See, complex answer to a simple question. Sorry about that.

Greg Haugen

Re: Simple question

#3

Even simpler question

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>If you could only subscribe to one, which would it be?

Clint

Re: Simple question

#4

Re: Simple question

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>Sometimes a simple question has simple answer.

The ultimate brand of tools is the brand I'm lusting for today.

The ultimate truck is the one I never should have traded in.

Popular Woodworking it currently my favorite woodworking magazine. I don't subscribe. I purchase it from time to time when I am in the Borg and waiting for SWMCEW (she who must shop else where) to come back with the car. The reason I like the magazine is that I feel that I am not being talked down to by the authors and editors (at the moment, tomorrows mileage may very). Some of the mags feel it's necessary to explain how a wood screw works and others leave out explanations of complex procedures with a 'you're never going to do this so why bother telling you how' kind of attitude. Now I know that this is very subjective and some days the ultimate mag is last weeks 'couldn't find a use for it in the outhouse mag'. So I pick and choose, I know that this is more expensive that just subscribing to one but it's a lot less expensive that subscribing to all of them.

and the simple answer is... Library!

Bill, who today is enjoying a simple blue sky

Re: Simple question

#5

I Do

Dustmaker Mike

>It is called Wood Central need I say more.

I buy hard copy mags when an artical looks like something I want to read other then that I Send my donations to WC, because I have gained more info here on WW then all the Mags combined.

Just my two bits remember Christmas is coming and Donations to WC are always Welcome

Re: Simple question

#6

LOL-AMEN!!

Greg Haugen

>

Re: Simple question

#7

A simple and accurate answer

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>The simple answer is that the folks at Popular Woodworking live and breathe wood. It is an inexpensive and simple magazine packed with a pile of information and inspiration. All magazines change over a period of time, but it looks like Popular Woodworking is on the right track and will stay there for a while.

Re: Simple question

#8

What is the best shoe size?

Michael Dresdner

>The one that fits you best. Ditto for woodworking magazines.