Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Fuming white oak

Posts

Fuming white oak

#1

Fuming white oak

Barry Rubenstein

>I am making a box with white oak and test fumed some scrap. I like the results and want to fume the finished box but have some questions. If I fume the pieces bfore gluing, will the fumed pieces glue properly ? After fuming, is it ok to apply Danish Oil ?

Thanks

Re: Fuming white oak

#2

Re: Fuming white oak

Stephen Shepherd in the State of Deseret

>If you use hide glue you will not have any problems, as far as modern glues, well why would you use those? If you get the test piece wet with water that is what it will look like when you oil it.

Put some oil on the test piece to check the color.

Avoid the fumes.

Stephen

Re: Fuming white oak

#3

Re: Fuming white oak

Barry Rubenstein

>I am using yellow glue and use it for most projects so thanks for your help, I think.

Any help from anyone who uses modern (yellow) glue ?

Re: Fuming white oak

#4

Re: Fuming white oak

John Veerkamp

>Since fuming is not a finish but a chemical reaction , it will not affect how glue preforms, no matter what type. Oil finish will work fine, but as Stephen says, test it for color and appearance on a scrap piece first, always good advice for any project.

John

Re: Fuming white oak

#5

JL

Re: Fuming white oak

JL

>I've fumed a piece or two. They glued up fine w/ Titebond. I just waited for all of the ammonia stink to go away (and a little longer).

Re: Fuming white oak

#6

general glue advise- when in doubt, test

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>It is very simple to test whether glue will work for any application on wood. Testing should always be done when there is any doubt. Glue two pieces of wood (about 3/4 x 1 x 6") together with a lap joint, leaving the ends overhanging. Let cure a day or two depending on moisture content of the wood.. Clamp one overhanging end of the assembly in a vise and bash the other such that the two glued pieces separate. One should get substantial wood failure to be declared a successful joint.

The same is true for finishes. Always test what you don't have experience with.

Left behind ammonia will affect both the glue and the finish, but it should be easy to be rid of it by letting the piece air out till the smell goes away.

As far as why anyone would use anything but hide glue, well, one only has to understand that the volume usage of aliphatic adhesives (yellow glue) is orders of magnitude higher than hide glue. One can believe that furniture factories and most professionals have failed to discover hide glue, or that there are compelling advantages for aliphatic resin adhesives for most woodworking applications.

Re: Fuming white oak

#7

Ellis Walentine

Yes and yes, but....

Ellis Walentine

>...I have never fumed individual parts before gluing. I just make the piece, scrape/sand it to the surface I want, and pop it into the fuming tent overnight. If you glue up after fuming, you run some risk of sanding or planing through the fumed cell layer when you clean up the glue and reestablish the surface.

I have not had trouble with finishes adhering over fumed wood.

Ellis

Re: Fuming white oak

#8

Re: Fuming white oak

Dave Winters

>I have fumed Q-sawn White Oak pieces before using Titebond, no problem, but haven't always liked the result. I like the color, but I like having the rays be a lighter color than the rest, and with fuming, they are usually darker. I have sanded back after fuming and this helps.. but stain or dye gives more predictable results.

Anybody have similar experience?

-Dave

Re: Fuming white oak

#9

Rick L

Re: Fuming will penetrate oil finishes

Rick L

>Fuming doesn't affect the gluing of wood. We've fumed wood that had oil finishes and the fuming will penetrate the oil with no problem.

Re: Fuming white oak

#10

Re: Fuming white oak

Lee Ohmart

>I have fumed wood and then glued it up later with no problems. I did it this way because others had warned that the wood might not take on a consistent color due to several variables. I had read somewhere that the producers of Mission ans Arts & Crafts furniture would use this method to color wood as a start and then apply various other substances to achieve the final color they were looking for. I haven't tried this myself but I could see how judicious application of a red dye could warm up a fumed oak.

Re: Fuming white oak

#11

Re: Fuming white oak

Craig Daymon

>If you do decide to fume and then glue up the pieces, be sure to let the pieces air out about a week between the fuming and the gluing. That way the glue will not be effected by any residual ammonia fumes.

I've fumed several small objects using household ammonia with good success. One key factor is to use an air-tight container. I use a 40 gallon Igloo (brand) cooler. I usually give the piece a good 16 hours (one day, plus or minus a few hours) before taking it out. That's much longer than is necessary with the stronger stuff, but MUCH safer. I fumed an American Chestnut bowl that is a very deep chocolate brown now using this process.

-Craig

Re: Fuming white oak

#12

Yes, yes, and some clarification

Michael Dresdner

>Yes you can glue after fuming with any glue you want. Ammonia fumes do not stick around in wood as they are very volatile, and even if they did, they would have no effect on modern wood glues, all of which contain either ammonia or one of its close cousins, such as triethanolamine. Without amines in the glue to raise the pH, waterbased glues would separate into water and a glob of resin. The same is true of waterbased coatings.

By the same reasoning, you can finish fumed wood with any finish you want, but Ellis' warning was right. Fuming is a chemical reaction, but it is only skin deep and it is very easy to sand through the color. The only finish sensitive to amines is shellac, and then it would have to be liquid, not fumes.