>I have a Delta 14" bandsaw with a riser block. I tried to make the wheels coplanar. Bought the washers/shims form Iturra.
I took the blade off and used a straight edge vertically from wheel to wheel. Added a shim or two and got them Aligned. But, when I put the blade back on and adjusted the tension, they are no longer coplanar. Are they supposed to be aligned under tension?
>Think your error is setting things up without the blade in place. Every saw I've done has been under working tension with the biggest blade in place. This is because full tension on the large blade will effect the "planarity" the most. Duginske says (in his book) to check for coplanarity with proper tension on the blade.
After all, you want your blade tracking straight when under load which means that the wheels should be coplanar with the saw's frame under working tension. Getting them that way is more than spacing the two wheels the same distance from the cabinet wall. Doing your measuring under tension also eliminates any errors induced from the frame.
You did use a bubble stick on the drive wheel, right? If your bottom wheel isn't deadnuts plumb to start with, you'll have the devil of a time getting the saw tuned. Others may do otherwise, but when I tune a band saw, I start by plumbing the frame, then the lower wheel, then bring the top wheel coplanar with the bottom, and lastly setting the table and trunions for the blade to be 90* to the table at the stops.
BTW, make sure that your tires are clean and in good shape.
Am I correct in hearing you say that you are shimming the wheels under tension with say a 1/2"-3/4" blade on board?
What happens when you switch to a 1/4" blade?
If you are going to tell me nothing happens then it seems to rather defeat the task of loading the arbors to plane the wheels?
I am really confused now.
I had thought that the position on the arbors and the wheels relative to each other was the reason for shimming them.(The in or out position on the shaft)
Duginske says to put the largest blade you will use (mostly 1/2" on "consumer" saws he says) on the saw and bring it up to proper tension BEFORE measuring for coplanarity. While I haven't asked him, I have to assume that the bigger blade, being harder to tension, will induce any appreciable flex in the saw's frame.
Your question is good however, if you infer less frame stress from a smaller blade and thus infer less deflection in the frame and a resulting tracking issue with smaller blades, seems logical.
I can't answer your question except to say that from experience it dooesn't seem to be an issue on the saws I've tuned (JET and Delta 14, JET 18). I do, however, have to tweek the top wheel tilt adjustment to get a smaller blade to track on center. Duginske suggests checking and readjusting the planarity when you change blade sizes, but I'm not so much of a purest (or OCD case) to insist on perfect coplanar tracking every time I turn on the saw. Jeez, I'd spend more time tuning the damn saw than cutting wood in that case! |;-}}}
>Mark, I think you were exactly correct. I have Duginski's Book, or at least on of them, and I went back and looked at it again. I skipped the first step and went right to adding washers. Bing ADD Boy and Male, its hard enough to read the instructions, I really can't be expected to follow them all.
I checked my saw, and leveled Or plumbed it as you suggested and then with a 1/2" blade in place I checked the wheels with a straight edge. The top one was tilted. I straightened it up and they were coplanar. The blade still tracks well, but as Duginski seems to suggest, slightly in front of center. The blade being smaller at the teeth according to him. Thanks for divining that I had failed to set it up with the blade in place. Makes perfect sense.
What I really need is two bandsaws. This one has nearly driven me crazy and another one would end up with me being committed. NO! Wait! What I meant was that I need one tuned with a circle cutting blade for cutting bowl blanks and another one set up for resawing. Just about time I send 30 minutes or more getting it tweaked to resaw, I need to cut circles and then go right back to resawing. If it took this long to change the blade on my table saw I would have killed it by now.
I think setting it up for the wide blade makes sense. That's the one you will use for precise straight line cuts. You won't know the difference on a smaller blade if you are cutting circles or fret work.
>Knowledge from my beginning days of serious tool acquisition. My tablesaw's top isn't polished like a new PM 66 (anymore) nor do I spend (waste) hours tuning the machines to some metaphysical norm of perceived precision in the belief that my woodworking ability was defined by the hyperaccuracy of my tools.
Anybody here remember the "gnat's eyelashes" thread on The Pond?
Glad I was able to help, Barry, if only to remind you of what you already knew. |;-}}}
>I am absolutely convinced I am just a couple of thousandths away form greatness. NOT! I marvel at the search for ultra precision. I just got a Biesemeyer fence for my Rockwell/Delta Contractors TS. (one of the $80 ones at Lowes, I could not bring myself to put a $400 fence on a $350 saw). I "aligned" it with the table slot with my finger. Just clamped it in place beside the slot and felt the edge of the slot. One slight adjustment and I left it alone. That may be a sacrilege and a horror for those of you who have feeler gauges with magnetic bases or whatever, but it cuts great and doesn't burn cherry. Done.
OTOH, I have described my bandsaw as a Ouija brand saw with a Moses blade that wanders in the desert of woodworking waiting for guidance from some higher authority that myself. The saw exudes a certain amount of animosity when I enter the shop. Must have been communing with my lawn mower. I even bought it a Carter blade release so it relax when I am not there. The last thing I do when I leave the shop is look to see if Bozo Nose is down. The idea that I could put a fence on this thing and rip a board is amazing to me. I hear people who use them in lieu of a TS. Yeah, right! But I keep trying.
>Since I (or the MD) put 9 stiches in my thumb to close it after the TS opened it, I've done more "safety ripping" on the band saw than ever. It's not as precise nor as repeatable, but between the thinner blade and the jointer I can get an acceptable result with no further loss to the dust collector.
Barry,
A "T" square fence for your band is pretty easy to make from angle iron, some square tubing and a couple of knobs. Take the hints from you Bies.
>I have the same saw with riser The only thing i had to do to mine was tweek the top wheel tilt adjustment I do resaw and than use 1/4" bands My saw is probly 10yrs old now Time passes fast. change the tires and never had to change the wheel tilt at all I guess i got a good one All i done was change the pulley's to double cast iron to 6" and 1" on the motor Never a slow on resaw 11" oak ect Just dont over feed it Also check the wheel's for balance put a mark on the wheel and a mark on the fram so that you have a same mark spin the wheel and see where it stop's It may be heavy on one side You may have to drill off some with a drill bit tell it stop's different each time Meaning it is not heavy on 1 side del
I might add that the more resilient neoprene tires that I replaced on my Delta knock off were what finally gave me the option of running my blade at the crest of the top wheel.
In retrospect I think that the original durometer of the original tires may have been too low.
That allowed the band to sink into the surface and produce some blade skewing.
It's not a problem with my new 18" saw and it runs almost perfect with the fence.
>>...I've done more "safety ripping" on the band saw than ever.
That's one reason the bandsaw is my favorite.
However, the only blood I've lost (so far!) in woodworking has been to a bandsaw. This was almost 40 years ago on a huge bandsaw while working at Berea College. I'm glad I learned the lesson about steel blades and soft flesh on the bandsaw instead of TS or jointer or I'd likely be typing with one hand today. The thumb does still have the scar on the end as a reminder!