Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Which Bandsaw

Posts

Which Bandsaw

#1

Which Bandsaw

Warren Chernoff

>thinking of upgrading my bandsaw. I currently have a Craftsman professional 14" that has served me well, but was wanting something with a bit more power. I'm looking at the Laguna 14SE, but someone suggested the Mini-Max or the Rikon. I can get a lot more bandsaw if I go with the Rikon. Cost is an issue as well as shipping to Canada. Any suggestions?. Would the 14" be much of an upgrade, or should I be looking at least at a 16".

Re: Which Bandsaw

#2

JL

Re: Which Bandsaw

JL

>You've got maybe a 1 hp motor on your Craftsman? You just want more power? Maybe a 2 hp motor?

I have a Rikon 18" with a 2 hp motor. I like it. I like the blade tensioning gauge (clearly visible on the front). I like the two speeds. I haven't done much resawing with it yet. Some have complained about getting bad castings and tables on the 14" so you definitely will have to inspect.

A friend of mine recently bought the Steel City 16" Industrial bandsaw and he likes it a lot. It has a 1.5 hp motor.

Re: Which Bandsaw

#3

Re: Which Bandsaw

les winter

>Hello Warren.

I have a Delta 14" with a 3/4hp motor. I replaced the motor drive pulley with a smaller, cast iron unit. Slows the blade a bit, runs smoother, and applies more force at the teeth. If your saw is otherwise ok, this may solve your problem. Pulleys are not expensive.

good luck

Les

Re: Which Bandsaw

#4

Re: Which Bandsaw

albertabob

>Waren:

You owe it to yourself to check this saw out.

http://busybeetools.ca/cgi-bin/picture10?NTITEM=CT103N

I bought one earlier this year and am very pleased with the fit and finish on it plus the new style steel casing and the tension quick release.

It is 220 volt but that is no really a big deal.

It's a lot of saw for $849.00

P.s. the resaw cap on this is 13-1/2 inches and I have used all of it without stalling.

Bob

Re: Which Bandsaw

#5

Re: Which Bandsaw here's the link *LINK*

albertabob

>Sorry folks. Seems every forum is diffent now.

I blew the link on my first post.

Bob


Craftex 18" bandsaw

Re: Which Bandsaw

#6

Re: Which Bandsaw

Larry Clinton

>I can't offer a lot of comparison data as the only bandsaws I have owned are the Crapsman and the MiniMax MM-16. However, I can state without reservation that the MM-16 is a Cadillac (or Rolls Royce) of bandsaws. I did do a lot of research and hands on inspection of several bandsaws, including the Rikon, Steel City, Delta, Jet, Grizzly and Laguna. The MM 16 is expensive, (around $2300 delivered), but nothing I looked at, including several 20" saws have the quality in the table top, trunnion and frame, motor power (4.8 hp) cutting capability (16" X 16"). Delivery was very fast and the saw arrived in perfect shape. My son and I un-crated the saw and had it set up and aligned in about 1 hour. Everything was pretty much dead on (and I measure using a good straight edge, machinist square, dial indicators etc. accurate to .0001"). The only (minor ) issue I have with the saw is the start / stop switch - It does work well , just don't care for the design. The saw includes a mobile base, pretty good dust collection feature, excellent foot brake & safety switches on both door. It runs with less noise or vibration than any saw I have seen. The fence is one of the best I viewed. It will run 1/4" to 1 1/4 wide blades (3 blades - I think Olson - are included in the price). I am very glad I spent the extra money on the saw and would do it again in a heartbeat. The sales person that sold me the saw has called me three times after the sale to make sure I had no problems. Their service appears to equal Lee Valley.

Re: Which Bandsaw

#7

Re: Which Bandsaw

McKay

>I run a school woodshop with a Rikon, 36" Yates/American, 2-Lagunas. I do not care for the Rikon. I love the Lagunas, and the Yates/American will put them all to shame. I looked at the Minimax at AWFS in July, and was impressed with the quality. Summary: stay away from the Rikon. Purchase price of Laguna or Mini would be worth the purchase. I personally have the 14" PM. I really like the features of this saw and could recommend the saw.

Re: Which Bandsaw

#8

Re: Which Bandsaw

Warren Chernoff

>thanks for the input. I'm really starting to lean toward the 14" Laguna just because of the price, although the MiniMax 16" intrigues me. Does anyone have specific experience with this one. I've heard that the 14" model is not made in the same factory as there other ones so am concerned that it may not meet the high quality of the bigger ones. Laguna also has free shipping up into Canada, which appeals to me. Also, there are 2 models of the Minimax 16, with big price difference. Anyone know what the main reason for this is? FYI, I've sent emails to Laguna, MiniMax and Rikon last week and still have yet to hear from anyone.

Re: Which Bandsaw

#9

Re: Which Bandsaw

Bob Sobieck

>I too have the MM16 - just love it!

You forgot to mention it really does pass the nickle test. With the saw off, you stand a nickle on edge on the table. Start the saw, the nickle still stands. I don't own anything else of this calibur quality - worth every penny - I find it replacing a lot of what my table saw did - and safer.

Bob in Green Bay

Re: Which Bandsaw

#10

Re: Which Bandsaw

Larry Clinton

>I have the MM 16, it is a far heavier saw than the E 16, (530 lb vs 320) has a more powerful motor (4.8 hp vs 2.5) more re-saw capacity (16" vs 12") & is not rated for the 1 1/4" wide blade (makes me think the column is not as rigid). My MM-16 is made by the same company in Italy as the large machines. Although the E-16 is stated as "made in Italy", I don't know if it is made in the same factory. The MM-16 was recently on sale (week or two ago), I think for around $2295. When I purchased mine it had gone off sale but I contacted them and they sold it to me for the lower price. I would call them and see if they will make you a deal. By the way, Ron Weaver did a comparative study on the MiniMax MM 16 VS the Laguna http://www.woodcentral.com/articles/reviews/articles_206.shtml It had some bearing on my purchase, although I didn't take wood to the Indianapolis woodworking show a few years ago, I did examine both saws closely, and watched the sawing demos. I came to the same conclusions Ron did. Another issue that concerned me with the Laguna were all the customer service complaints circulating on the web. I found no customer service problems with MiniMax but many complaints about Laguna. These issues may have been resolved - but I would search the web to make sure. I will say this, I have never, ever regretted spending the extra money to buy a better tool 2 months or more later, but have often later regretted compromising and buying a cheaper tool. It seems I never am really satisfied with a piece of equipment when I have made that compromise. For the last few years, I have purchased only what I determined from investigation was the best tool for my shop - even if it meant waiting and saving for a while. Obviously there are limits to that strategy, as I couldn't afford to purchase a $20,000 combination machine or the large industrial machines, but when the difference for the top quality vs a compromise was in hundreds - I opted for the best.