Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Lucky to have 3 "Borgs" near me.

Posts

Lucky to have 3 "Borgs" near me.

#1

Lucky to have 3 "Borgs" near me.

Mike Circo

>A little store and a lesson for all.

So doing my first authentic Mission finish, no shortcuts. Dye-shellac-gel stain-topcoat looks great, but time consuming. I tested for weeks to get just the right concentration of the dye. Then, thanks to a closing of a Sears Hardware near me, I had 6 different colors of Minwax gel stains to test with. (20 cents each for a pint can)

Finally I got the right meld of dye and gel. The chestnut color gel stain was just the one I needed so off to Lowes to get a quart. But...

None on the shelf! What a pain. So I grab a color chart from the rack and look it over. Oh No! Chestnut is not listed, only 4 colors none of which are even close to my required color. How could Minwax do this to me. Wait.... what is that? On the back of the brochure is the Lowes logo. Could this possibly be a custom set just for Lowes??

So I drive the 4 miles over to Menards and BINGO, 8 colors on the rack including my needed Chestnut. And their brochure has no special corporate logo and included all the colors.

I guess Lowes doesn't want to be bothered with stocking ALL the colors so made the decision to pick what THEY liked not what the customer may want. Sheesh what a pain. 50,000 Square feet of space and they can't be bothered to spare a few inches of shelf for four additional colors.

Thank goodness for Menards.

Re: Lucky to have 3 "Borgs" near me.

#2

Re: Lucky to have 3 "Borgs" near me.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Be sure to pick up a few disposable power tools at Menards when you go. ;-)

Tom

Re: Lucky to have 3 "Borgs" near me.

#3

Steven Antonucci

Only three?

steve antonucci

>I have 2 Lowes, 3 HD, 2 Sears HW, and 4 WalMarts... to go with a Cosco, a BJ's, and a Sam's Club. Mind you, this is within a 15 mile radius of my house...

Steven

Re: Lucky to have 3 "Borgs" near me.

#4

Tripple The Aggrevation

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>

Re: Lucky to have 3 "Borgs" near me.

#5

Re: Lucky to have 3 "Borgs" near me.

Steve Schoene

>If the market demographics can support three borg stores, surely there are a couple of real paint/finish stores with more choices than Minwax.

Re: Lucky to have 3 "Borgs" near me.

#6

And you live in NYC???

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>

Re: Lucky to have 3 "Borgs" near me.

#7

Yea, but the people who own Mimwax also own most o

Don Henthorn

>of the others.

Re: Lucky to have 3 "Borgs" near me.

#8

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Minwax is owned by...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...none other than Sherwin-Williams. Borgs continue to carry their stains because the Minwax name is well known.

Jason

Re: Lucky to have 3 "Borgs" near me.

#9

Actually more than three...

Mike Circo

>The three are like beads on a string on one road near my home. There are two additional HomeDepots 15 minutes away and even a second Menards and two Sears stores for a total of 8 big box places.

THEN add in the Ace, True Value, and 5 paint stores and it gets hairy.

I've been in the Sherwin Williams and don't see Minwax products there, only their own brand. Not that there is anything wrong with S/W products, I just am confused by the comment that they own Minwax.

Anyway... Thanks to a wealth of shopping options, I got what I needed.

Re: Lucky to have 3 "Borgs" near me.

#10

Re: The SW guys told me about

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>all of the brands they own and don't sell in their stores.

Retailing is very different than manufacturing and distributing...

Re: Lucky to have 3 "Borgs" near me.

#11

Re: The SW guys told me about

Larry Clinton

>Many of the conglomerates buy a company (or group of companies) and don't even touch them - if they are making a good profit, they may slim down the corporate management (who probably don't know what they were making anyhow), and let it be. I was employed at Mallory Controls when the company went through several ownership changes. - First P. R. Mallory, then Dart (later Dart / Kraft), then Emhart, then Black and Decker, finally Emerson Electric. (all within a 10 Yr. or so period). Actually part of the reason this occurred was that Duracell Battery was part of our corporation and Dart wanted it to compete with Union Carbide. Actually very little changed during most of this time, except for capital expenditure money availability.

Re: Lucky to have 3 "Borgs" near me.

#12

Re: The SW guys told me about

Steve Schoene

>S&W hasn't kept it's brands in totally separate subsidiaries (which would have had to be reported on its SEC filings. But, besides the Sherwin Williams name, it's brand names are substantial, including MinWax, but also Dutch Boy, Pratt & Lambert, Krylon, Thompson's Waterseal, Purdy, Martin Seymour, Bestt, Liebco, among others. They also manufacture private label brands.

But just because one company manufacturers an item, it doesn't mean all the products are very similar. Nor can you say much about a private label brand by knowing who made it. In either case it's all about the specifications not the maker. There are lots of market niches in the coatings industry and a lot of brands are needed to cover them broadly.