Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

OT-New TV ?

Posts

OT-New TV ?

#1

OT-New TV ?

Don Orr

>As you all probably know the Feds are making us change TV formats to digital in 2009. I would like some input on what the pros/cons are for Plasma vs. LCD vs. any other type TVs. What features are really nice vs. fluff, etc. I'm not looking for huge home theater things, just a decent TV for my cave. I will need to get something new in the near future and would appreciate the usual sage wisdom and advice that I so often see here.

Thanks in advance, Don

Re: OT-New TV ?

#2

Re: OT-New TV ?

John McGaw

>If you go to google and search for "plasma vs lcd" (without the qoutes, of course) you should find plenty of material to ponder.

I just bought a Sharp Aquos 42" LCD a few weeks ago and am quite happy with it. Of course, knowing I've been living the past decade with a 21" Walmart-special CRT TV you might doubt my decision making. But I was a television broadcast technician/engineer for a long time and I still can tell a good picture from a bad one. And the Sharp _was_ at a deep sale price at the time and the picture _is_ gorgeous to behold.

Both TV types have positives and negatives. But it seems likely that if your viewing conditions are more-or-less good you could do fine with either one. Of course, if you are actually happy with your present TV and want to save money it still seems likely that cheap/free digital converter boxes should be available by the time the changeover actually occurs.

Re: OT-New TV ?

#3

I have a Sharp ...

Mike Farinella

>Aquos (LCD) as well (46") and the picture is great. The only thing I don't like is the remote - too sloooooow! This TV has 2 built-in tuners as well so you don't need a "converter box".

In my research, I read that LCD will be the dominant technology in the future as plasma has it's limitations.

Good luck

Re: OT-New TV ?

#4

The government

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Last I heard, there will be converters available, either inexpensively, or supplied for free by the gov't (who will be using the profits generated by reusing and selling the airway frequencies that will be freed up now to fund these converters for the millions of people who will need them and can't afford a new TV) that will receive the digital signal and convert it to what your TV needs.

But if you, like me WANT and EXCUSE to buy a new large thin TV, then "the converters probably won't work, won't be available, and the darn gov't is forcing you to buy a new big wonderful TV" ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT-New TV ?

#5

Re: OT-New TV ?

Tom

>Synatax Olevia is a good name, although not heard of too often. Very good value, in terms of cost. I've got two Olevia lcd's, both are wonderful and problem free.

Re: OT-New TV ?

#6

Re: OT-New TV ?

NickB

>We just bought a Samsung 42" plasma, which looks great. From what I've been able to gleen from reading, and please excuse the generalizations, plasma tend to be cheaper at a given size (but 42" is pretty much the smallest plasma), have better contrast recovery times (no ghosting in fast moving scenes/sports), but have issues with glare and burn-in and do produce a fair amount of heat when they are on. LCDs are not subject to burn-in, have less in terms of glare issues, but may have issues with restricted viewing angles (if you get too far off 90 deg. the picture quality drops) and ghosting.

That said, the manufacturers seem to have addressed the weaknesses of each of the technologies, and I didn't see much of an issue with glare in the plasmas I looked at (and most have some sort of burn-in prevention and removal technology built into the set now), and the LCDs didn't seem to have much of an issue with viewing angle (there weren't any sports on when I was looking, so I can't say anything about ghosting, but the general word I've heard is that the LCD manufacturers have been improving the response time for the LCDs, so ghosting is much reduced). The difference in contrast ratios was noticeable to me, though (I thought the plasma looked better when I was comparing sets), and it didn't hurt that the plasma was cheaper than the comparable LCD.

Take home: pretty much any flat panel will look much better than your old tube set. Go to a store, preferably with your own DVD, and look at the sets and decide what you like best.

Hope this helps,

Nick

Re: OT-New TV ?

#7

Re: OT-New TV ?

Glenn Clabo - RI

>I suggest that you go look at as many of them as you can and decide. I'm a Plasma fan because I can see the LCD delay (pixalation is getting better but I still can it) in fast moving pictures..ie sports...in screens above 40 inches. I also like the blacks in the Plasma tv's and the not so big a deal because who knows what a few years will bring...the half life of Plasma is longer...20 years vs 13-15 at 6 hours a day. The LCD can be fixed...but is costly.

Re: OT-New TV ?

#8

Re: I have a Sharp ...

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>Have they fixed the banding problem with the Sharp Aquos? Was happening in a number of 42"-50", but not all.

Seems the best reviews are coming in on the Sony XBR LCD most expensive), Sharp Aquos LCD, and Samsung LCD. Aquos had best contrast ratio (blacks look blackest) of the bunch but also had the banding problem which was mainly visible with single color backgrounds). Samsung has an input for computer so you can easily view pics or WoodCentral on your TV. The other big attribute to look at is response time- better response time, less motion residual/blur.

Re: OT-New TV ?

#9

Plasma here too!

Eddie Pacheco: San Jose, Ca.

>We have the 42" Panasonic in our bedroom and it is, so far, working out well. We pretty much went the Plasma route because of the reasons that Nick states. Our set does generate a bit of heat and it has a heavier gage power cord to it. It also has a cooling fan for what may be the graphics chip or processor. We're happy with it and now it's looking like 42" is becoming the new "small screen".

Re: OT-New TV ?

#10

Re: so what's a guy to do....

mike hamilton

>if he only wants to replace a small (13"), 25 year old Trinitron that just tossed in the towel with another small tv that doesn't need an upgrade in 2009? It looks like I will be getting an LCD set in the 19-20 inch range. Any experiences to share? The store with the biggest variety in the area pretty much limited me to Samsung, Sharp and Toshiba.

Thanks,

Mike Hamilton

Plainfield, IN

Re: OT-New TV ?

#11

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Sammy LCD here...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Last fall, after carefully researching the pros and cons online between plasma and LCD, I went to Best Buy all set to buy a then-on-sale plasma. I walked out with a 40" Samsung LCD. I looked at the pictures side-by-side for about an hour. The negatives that online folks pointed out about plasmas stood out like a sore thumb to me. I could overlook the shortcomings of the LCD. Plus, the plasmas' glass screens (oxymoron?) all would have shown bad glare in the room I was placing the TV. The LCD has a matte screen that does not glare to near that degree. My close friend swears by his Sony rear-projection CRT and claims he can see the "screen-door" effect on my LCD. I can't, and think the LCD picture is brighter and the colors much richer. I can't stand the plasma picture at all (too much red push among other things).

Here's a place where the debates abound:

www.avsforum.com

Jason

Re: OT-New TV ?

#12

Re:Get a LCD

Brian in Brighton

>I have neither, but a lot of people at the high altitudes here in Colorado have had plasma failures from slow leakage in 3-5 years. The TV nuts I know all say....Go LCD.

Brian in Brighton

Re: OT-New TV ?

#13

The best answer is to turn the thing off

Don Henthorn

>and try living for a change.

Re: OT-New TV ?

#14

Re: The best answer is to turn the thing off

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Don, that might be the best advice I've every heard when it comes to buying a new TV. When mine poops out I hope I remember this. It will save me lots of mullah!

Thank you,

Jen :)

Re: OT-New TV ?

#15

Re: The best answer is to turn the thing off

Dan Donaldson

>I have a TV that my wife and daughter watch movies on, but no TV service. Don't miss it at all ;-)

Re: OT-New TV ?

#16

Re: OT-New TV ?

Don Orr

>Thanks everyone for all the feedback. Obviously not a simple subject. I don't watch a lot of TV, I actually spend a fair amount of time in the shop or with my wife, but I would like something pleasing that will last and won't break the bank. I knew about the converters, but Mark G. got where I am coming from ;>).

This is why WC is my favorite website!!!

Thanks again, Don.

Re: OT-New TV ?

#17

Honda over Sony

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>A couple of good dirt bikes for a father and son will bring alot more enjoyment that a large TV. Of course, I'd like BOTH, but only can have one, and Honda won over Sony ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT-New TV ?

#19

Or

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Be descriminating about what you watch in order to remain informed about issues that effect all of us, both individually and as a society. Knowledge and current information are the only true basis for individual power; cutting yourself off from them weakens your ability to make informed choices, and may expose you to unnecessary risk. If people would just stop tuning into the mind-numbing drivel that is so prevelent, maybe "they'd" stop making more of it. Unfortunately, like Bat Boy, stupidity sells well

There is much worthwhile on TV. It just takes a bit of effort to find it.

Of course, that's just my opinion. YMMV

mm

Re: OT-New TV ?

#20

Re: The best answer is to turn the thing off

mike hamilton

>Most of my watching is news or PBS - mostly stuff I can get on the radio during drive time. But the 'tube' (soon that word will be another show of age) is necessary for watching St. Roy and my woodturning DVDs.

So far, Sharp and Samsung LCDs have been mentioned (though mostly about bigger sets). I will give them a closer look.

Regards,

Mike

Re: OT-New TV ?

#21

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

One man's mind-numbing drivel...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>is another man's entertainment!

Just a corollary to "One man's trash..."

;^)

Believe it or not, I went and got cable just to be able to watch some decent TV, instead of being restricted to mainly the local CBS affiliate and its (ugh) network offerings. I just wish I didn't have to pay for all the channel I don't let my family watch.

HD, Sunday afternoon, beer and the Colts...

Jason

Re: OT-New TV ?

#22

Whoa, Now THAT's TV

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You get beer on your cable? FAR OUT!!!

[does that take a special box?]

Man-o-Man! Is that "quality braodcasting" or what?!!!!!

mm

Re: OT-New TV ?

#23

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

No, but...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I have heard that in Germany, you can get beer piped into your house as a metered service. Now THAT'S what I call "convenience".

Re: OT-New TV ?

#24

Re: No, but...

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>when I was there 35+ years ago, they had delivery service, like the milkman used to do in US neighborhoods 45 years ago...

Cases of 24's on the doorstep. Not for me.

Re: OT-New TV ?

#25

What you say is absolutely true, Mark,

Don Henthorn

>but I can't stand wasting the time trying to find the good stuff. It seems they are always changing the schedule trying to get you involved in the crap. It is easier to find some dependable sources on the web and get away from all the slime and ads which are usually also loaded with slime.