Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Does thickness of finish matter?

Posts

Does thickness of finish matter?

#1

Does thickness of finish matter?

Barry Irby

>I have just started to learn how to apply and rub out shellac. Got me to thinking, does the thickness of any finish really matter?

I know some finishes tend to sink into the wood and not so much above the surface and some sit mostly on top. I am not asking about varnish verses lacquer or whatever, I am asking about lacquer Vs. lacquer or shellac Vs. shellac.

Once you have a complete "film" with enough thickness to "function" does adding more contribute anything? Is a thicker finish more durable? Is it tougher? How about appearance? Does a thicker finish look better, have more "depth" or whatever?

Re: Does thickness of finish matter?

#2

Yes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Barry,

Since solvent finishes have 100% burn-in (dissolve and then re-fuse with prior layer), the thickness of the film "builds" with subseequent applications into a single layer. There is also a minimal amount of penetration into the wood fiber. Depending on the wood and how the finish is rubbed out, there will be a wide variance in the results achieved. The thickness of the film will effect how light is reflected and refracted inside the film layer adding or subtracting from what we call "depth" as opposed to "closeness" to the wood. For instance, some don't like oil poly finishes because the initial film is thick and can look "plasticy." Oil finishes (and most waterbornes) do not burn-in with prior layers. When they are cut back and rubbed out, care must be taken not to work through the top layer to avoid witness lines between the coats being exposed. This doesn't happen with shellac and lacquer because the finish has become a single layer.

Shellac, while durable, is easily attacked by alcohol and ammoniated compounds, and its resins are not as hard as those in lacquer. Both films need some thickness for durability on wear surfaces. Their great allure is that either surface can be repaired simply by recoating with the original finish. Also, too thin a film will allow water (spills & vapor) to penetrate under and weaken the film bond with the wood.

Lastly, shellac can be tinted with compatible dyes and used to shade various parts of a piece to even out the color of the wood. This is especially useful when working cherry. Obviously, the more that is applied, the more tint will result. 100% dewaxed shellac will produce a harder, less flexible film than regular shellac. Instrument makers actually add wax to their shellac finish to allow the film ro expand and contract with the wood's seasonal changes without cracking. It is, however, softer and less durable.

Note of caution. Many use shellac as a barrier coat under waterborne finishes to seal in stain and prevent grain-raise by topcoats. Issues have come up with shellac basecoats cracking and crazing under the waterbornes. If you'll be topcoating with a different finish, keep your shellac coat thin, make sure it's wax-free, and use only fresh product, preferably mixed from flakes as the undersealer.

mm

Re: Does thickness of finish matter?

#3

The simple answer

Michael Dresdner

>Comparing apples to apples, a thicker finish look thicker, as our eyes can see even subtle depth and will also be more durable. There is a point of diminishing returns, though, and some finishes are more prone to cracking if applied too thickly. There are also some coatings specifically designed for only a set thickness range, while others are not so limited.

Re: Does thickness of finish matter?

#4

Re: Yes

Dick Coers

>Not all solvent based finishes burn in. I only know of two, shellac and lacquer. Solvent based poly is the first that comes to mind, of solvent based finishes that does not burn in. You have to be careful with the recoat timing because the film can get so hard that it will not bond at all. You have to sand between coats to give the mechanical grip if you wait too long.

Some of the more exotic finishes, precatalyzed lacquer, conversion varnish, etc..... specify a maximum film thickness. These finishes can "cold check" if the film is too thick.

Re: Does thickness of finish matter?

#5

Solvent Poly?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Dick,

I know from precat, conversion and such, but I didn't think Barry was asking about those, and I was trying to distinguish the mechanically bonding finishes. You mention "solvent based poly [urethane]?" That's a new one on me. Brand name? What's the resin and the solvent?

Thanks.

mm

Re: Does thickness of finish matter?

#6

Re: Solvent Poly?

Dick Coers

>Mark,

I consider anything that uses a petroleum base as solvent based material. Until just the last few years, everybody had a solvent based polyurethane that used mineral spirits or naptha/mineral spirits solvent. Learned a little more doing some research.

Excerpt from http://members.aol.com/woodinfo1/varnish.htm

"The kind of polyurethane finish you are used to seeing in paint and woodfinishing supply stores is not pure polyurethane, but rather an alkyd varnish that has been modified by adding some polyurethane into it. That is why polyurethane should be classified as a varnish. Perhaps a better description would be modified varnish, but nevertheless, still varnish. It is applied and it cures in the same manner as other oil based varnishes."

Re: Does thickness of finish matter?

#7

Terminology!!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Hi Dick,

OK. Now I understand.

I regard solvent finishes as only a resin dissolved in a solvent. When the solvent evaporates, the film finish is left. Curing involves the final evaporation of the solvent. That defines only shellac and n/c lacquer (fer as I know).

I also agree with your blurb. The "poly" we love (or hate) is oil-based varnish, solvent thinned, which forms its film by polymerization of the oil base and alkyd resins. I understand that to be called a "reactive" finish because of the chemical reaction involved in the cure. That why they use mineral spirits because it's such a slow evaporater, it leaves time for the oxygen to reach into the film layer and start the curing process.

There are waterborne polyurethanes being sold, but that chemistry is way beyond my limited knowledge.

Peace

mm

Re: Does thickness of finish matter?

#8

Hi Michael

Bob Mitchell

>

Re: Does thickness of finish matter?

#9

Some finishes have a maximum thickness

Derek

>Hi Michael! Thanks for your help in the past!

I coated a table I made with catalyzed lacquer. I made it too thick at the suggestion of my wife, thinking it would be more durable. Unfortunately, I exceeded the maximum thickness spec of the manufacturer and it cracked all over the top. I had to remove and re-coat about 6 months later. What a pain!

Re: Does thickness of finish matter?

#10

Re: Hi Bob!

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>

Re: Does thickness of finish matter?

#11

Re: Hi Rob.

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>