Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Question about shingles for the shop roof.

Posts

Question about shingles for the shop roof.

#1

Question about shingles for the shop roof.

Virgil

>Its time to re roof the workshop and the house attached to it.(I'm on topic now:-)...) I've found a contractor that personally I like better than anyone else that I've "interviewed". The only drawback is that I'm an Owens Corning fan and this company uses GAF roofing products. Anyone have experience with GAF timberline shingles? Thanks

Re: Question about shingles for the shop roof.

#2

Re: Question about shingles for the shop roof.

wayne

>Very good shingles have had them on my house for over 8 years and still look as good as new.

Re: Question about shingles for the shop roof.

#3

Re: Response to shingles for the shop roof.

Ray Carson, Lawrenceville NJ

>Morning Virgil,

GAF is a very good product. I've had GAF shingles on my house since 2000 and they look brand new. Very little pebbling into the gutters.

I'm a firm believer that "middle of the road" is always a safe choice.

No need to cheap out, and no need to buy the most expensive. Most manufacturers have their low end, middle, and high end products. Both GAF and Owens Corning offer different products, so pick which best suits your budget and taste.

I know a lot of roofers and GAF and Owens are two of their choices. Most I know use GAF products because of the slight cost savings.

Cost savings doesn't necessarily translate into cheap goods. Sometimes you pay for the name if you get my drift. I'm not bashing Owens in any way, or praising GAF over Owens....(Ray is rambling)..........I think you understand my point.

My two cents worth

Ray

Re: Question about shingles for the shop roof.

#4

Re: More important is the source

Kneale Brownson in sunny N. MI

>I'm told by the place I usually buy roofing (not a Borg) that some companies will cut a corner or two on a shingle sold in large, large quantities to a mass marketer. I've found that to be true regarding things like name-brand plumbing fixtures, so have no reason to doubt them regarding the shingles. I'm not sure what corners you can cut in shingle production--maybe a bit less tar, a tad fewer granules, thinner backing material???

Re: Question about shingles for the shop roof.

#5

Re: Haven't used their shingles but,...

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>I haven't used their shingles but, I sure did enjoy hearing Henry Fonda say, "GeeeYeahYeff" in commercials. ;^) The only improvement I can think of would be their hiring Jimmy Stewart as their spokesman. Listening to him would probably have spurred me to seek out their shingles.

Al

Re: Question about shingles for the shop roof.

#6

Re: Question about shingles for the shop roof.

Barry Irby

>As a Home Inspector and former builder, I have no information that would cause me not to use GAF. I too, would go for the middle of the road. I would buy a 30-35 year dimensional shingle. I would be sure to get either AR (Algae Resistant) or FR (Fungus Resistant) if I were in an area of the country that gets the sooty looking stains on the roofing.

I woudl not hesitate to do a nail over if I only had a single layer on the roof now.

Re: Question about shingles for the shop roof.

#7

Lee Gordon

Re: Question about shingles for the shop roof.

Lee Gordon

>Last year I had the roof on my house redone and also had the roof on my detached garage done but by a different contractor. Due to a "senior moment" on my part, I told the garage guy to use the brand I thought was going to be used on my house. But I had confused his estimate with that of a contractor I didn't use. The bottom line is my house has Owens Corning and my garage has GAF (or vice versa; I don't remember which) and they are virtually identical.