Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

What kind of finish for Walnut tables

Posts

What kind of finish for Walnut tables

#1

What kind of finish for Walnut tables

Mike F

>I made these nesting tables out of Walnut and put some Watco danish oil on them. I'm not super happy with the way they look so far. The wood isn't a very uniform color. I also think I need something more on them to protect the wood. Please keep in mind that this project has LOTS of surfaces.

There are a few spots with a white cloudy fog. What did I do incorrectly and how do I fix it?

I've heard of people putting amber shelac on Walnut. What would that do? Will that work over the Watco Danish oil. I didn't fill in the pores of the wood with anything. I assume that is what the shelac does.

Can I use another stain over the Watco Danish oil?

Should I put polyurethane on this?

(I'll ask about a finish for the bowls another day.)


img

Re: What kind of finish for Walnut tables

#2

Have you thought about...

David Yoho

>Have you thought about trying one of the Watco Danish oils in a walnut color? It may help even out the color of the wood to your liking. Later, should you decide you need more protection from your finish, you can always apply something like polyurethane or Waterlox. The key is to give the Watco enough time to dry before applying anything else.

David

Re: What kind of finish for Walnut tables

#3

Re: Walnut Finish

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Mike,

Walnut being an open-grain wood, many prefer a softer sheen finish to hold more light on the surface. Gloss on open pores tends to sparkle in a way some don't like; same for oak. If you wish to go with a smooth or "piano" finish, consider filling the pores with a grain filler (not shellac) which you can tint to match your wood's color. I use Crystalac, and it does very well. The attached pic is an example of a filled-pore finish on walnut. The top coat is gloss polyurethane.

You can also use some dye stain to even out the wood tone if your Watco hasn't sealed the surface too well.

When everything is dry, you can top with shellac (less durable), lacquer (more durable), oil poly, or go with one of the great waterbornes like General Finishes, Fuhr or Enduro in several sheens (very durable). If you go the waterborne route, you should apply 1 or 2 thin coats of freshly mixed 100% dewaxed shellac as a sealer over the oil. You can also add some dye to the shellac to further blend your wood color, but keep the shellac coat(s) thin because waterborne finishes don't like thick shellac substrate layers.

Hope this helps


img

Re: What kind of finish for Walnut tables

#4

Tables look good Mike. Nice job!

Ray Carson, Lawrenceville NJ

>

Re: What kind of finish for Walnut tables

#5

I used dark Walnut colored Watco Danish oil

Mike F

>and it did blend the colors a far bit, just not as much as I would like.

Re: What kind of finish for Walnut tables

#6

Re: What kind of finish for Walnut tables

eliot d

>One of my early projects was a walnut headboard. (I lifted and expanded upon a design of Thomas Moser.) The finish I used was a true French polish. Lots of work, but it still looks great after something like 15 years.

Re: What kind of finish for Walnut tables

#7

How did you apply the Danish oil?

Kelby

>Mark, I really like your tables.

Danish oil is like C.S. Lewis novels. Read them when you are in middle school, and they're accessible and fun to read. Read them when you're in college, and you're suprised at the depth that you missed before.

Danish oil is nice because any beginner can slop some on, wipe it off, and have a decent enough finish. But if you are willing to put in some extra effort, it can be an incredible finish.

Here's a good method. First, do what everyone does --- slop some on, let it sit a bit, then wipe the excess off. Let it cure for a day or two.

Second, slop some more on, but this time, while it's still wet, grab a sanding block and some 320 grit sandpaper. Sand everywhere, making a slurry with the oil and dust. The block should be working the slurry into the pores, filling them somewhat. After a while, wipe the excess off, trying not to pull the slurry out of the pores in the process. Let it sit a day or two, then rinse and repeat.

I like to repeat the process four or five times. By the time it's done, the pores should be relatively filled, and there should be a faint but natural and beautiful lustre to the wood.

As for your cloudy white spots, it sounds like you may have some glue on your wood. Sand or scrape that section of the table well, apply some more oil, and see what happens.

One final point --- Watco is OK, but it's just as easy (and cheaper) to mix up some very good Danish oil. Mix equal parts linseed oil, oil-based varnish, and mineral spirits. Or, if you want to go all-out, replace the linseed oil with tung oil.

Good luck with the finishing, and please post pics when you're done!

Re: What kind of finish for Walnut tables

#8

Re: How did you apply the Danish oil?

Mike F

>Thanks for the info.

I think i'll try that wet sanding thing to fill in the pores.

The cloudy spots might be glue related. Sanding them down and putting more oil on should fix the problem no matter what. I wasn't sure if sanding it after I had put oil on the wood would cause problems.

I still have the issue where the wood doesn't quite match color wise. Will more dark walnut Watco oil help blend the colors, or is this as close as it is going to get?

Re: What kind of finish for Walnut tables

#9

Re: Walnut Finish

Mike F

>The dye stain idea interests me. How do I know how well the wood is sealed with the Watco? I put it on rather heavy and let it soak in well. It has been curing for a couple of weeks now.

Are there things that just won't stick over this oil?

Re: What kind of finish for Walnut tables

#10

Re: How did you apply the Danish oil?

Kelby

>The Dark Walnut Watco should even out the color a bit.

The good news is that if you don't like the way it affects the walnut, you can sand it out easily enough.

Re: What kind of finish for Walnut tables

#11

Re: Walnut Finish

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>A light sanding with 180 or 220 (tops) should allow some penetration. through just one coat of Watco. You can use SiC waterproof paper and the stain as a lubricant. Support the paper with either your hand or a block (preferably rubber), and wipe off often to check your progress. I would start in those "whitish" areas you mentioned. That reaction usually denotes some water vapor trapped under the film, but it normally occurs with shellac or lacquer. If you can post a macro close-up pic of the areas it might help.

Good luck. Nice tables and worth the extra effort.

MM

Re: What kind of finish for Walnut tables

#12

shellac on Walnut.

Malcolm Timbers

>You want to put several coats of shellac on walnut to prevent it from bleaching out in UV light. The only finish that I know of that will block most of the UV rays is shellac. Antique furniture is not bleached out because they used shellac in those days.