Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

15 inch planer choice

Posts

15 inch planer choice

#1

15 inch planer choice

Guy

>Hello, getting ready to pull the pin and pick up a 15 inch planer. I have narrowed the choice down to the Jet and Grizzly. I assume they are about the same but I can look at and check out the Jet locally, the Griz will be a blind buy. I'm not brand loyal, just want a reliable tool that I just have to buy once (note: This replaces my lunchbox Delta that my wife fried the other week). Any opinions on these or planers in general would be appreciated. We do this for a hobby and it will be mainly used for dimensioning rough lumber to be smooth finished with a Performax sander. Thanks in advance, Guy

Re: 15 inch planer choice

#2

JL

Re: To throw another one into the mix...

JL

>A friend of mine recently bought the Shop Fox W1723 3 HP 15" Planer. He is very happy with it.

Re: 15 inch planer choice

#3

Re: To throw another one into the mix...

Ray Newman

>I have a Sunhill:

http://www.sunhillmachinery.com/Planers%20CT382A.htm

So far it has been a very reliable machine.

Depending upon where you live, shipping costs may just be the decidng factor??

Re: 15 inch planer choice

#4

Re: 15 inch planer choice

Larry Clinton

>Guy, unless things have changed all the stationary 15" (and most other stationary planers) except the Woodmaster (US made) are made in the same (GeeTee) factory in Asia. I know when I bought my 20", it was apparent the Grizzly, Jet, Delta, Powermatic, Yorkcraft and Bridgeport were all cast in the same molds. Not saying some may not have more stringent quality requirements, I'm not sure. I bought a Yorkcraft - installed the Byrd head and am very pleased with it. I don't think you will find much difference in most - The in-feed and out-feed tables do vary, some have rollers, others cast iron extensions. IMHO, I would buy one with the cast iron extensions. I would stay away from the Delta, I looked at one at the Indianapolis WW show, it had the roller table extension. You could move the end of the extension up and down a 1/4" with very little force. I'm sure it would have a hugh problem with snipe. I have had very good results buying grizzly equipment, I had a 6" jointer, replaced it with an 8", and have their 3 HP cyclone dust collector. Did have a motor (capacitor / start switch) problem with the dust collector, and Grizzly gave me satisfactory service -providing all the parts pretty promptly. I personally would look at the price (including shipping) and the reputation of the company selling the unit to make my decision. You might also consider looking into converting the planer to a Byrd head when purchasing or in the future as the planned surface finish is much better - especially on knarley or hard to plane woods.

Re: 15 inch planer choice

#5

I Have the Grizzly G0453

Mike Fitterling

>I have the Grizzly G0453 and have already run countless board feet of lumber through it, mainly hard maple, black walnut, and jatoba. It has been an excellent machine. I originally bought it with the straight knives, but got a deal on a Byrd head and installed that about halfway through its use so far. No complaints with the machine, either with the straight knives or the Byrd, although obviously, the Byrd does a much better job at figured wood with better chip dollection and much less noise. Even with the staight knives the noise was much much better than the old Dewalt 733 I used to use. The built in mobility is very nice on this machine and I always store it in a corner and roll it out for use.

Good luck, whatever you decide.

Mike