Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

First Project: Advice welcome :)

Posts

First Project: Advice welcome :)

#1

First Project: Advice welcome :)

A.W. Ford, of Newberg, OR

>This is my first project since high school shop class 20 years ago. Any and all input, praise, condescension, smirks or laughs are more than welcome :)

I decided to start with a basic stool for the workshop. I really wanted to understand how to visualize the end product from start to finish so not using any pre-made plans and tried to think through all the joints and am half-way comfortable with what I have but question a few of the techniques needed to do this the right way.

The drawing below should make the my verbal mumbling a little more clear. First the legs are 30 inch oak 2x2s mitered at 10 degrees on the ends to give them the right slope. Each side will have 2 1"x1/2" oak crossbars joined at approximately 6 and 18 inches from the bottom, with adjacent sides offset by about an inch and a half to prevent the leg from being too weak where the joint cuts from both sides of the leg would meet. (Would this be called a rabbet joint?)

The legs are attached to a 10"x10"x1/2" plywood seat support from above with wood screws. The seat support is then attached to the 12"x12"x1" oak seat from below with wood screws. Like I said, pretty basic.

Now for my questions:

- For the point where I have make the joint cuts for the crossbars to inset into the legs, is there a recommended technique for accounting for the 10 degree angle needed make the joint fit snug?

- Should I try to do this with a router, or by hand with chisels?

- Is using the seat support an acceptable way to go about attaching the legs to the seat so that no screws are visible from the oak surfaces, or a better way to go about this?

- I would like to make indents into the top surface of the seat to add a little extra comfort. I was thinking I'd rough out the basic variety of depths with a router at 1/32" increments then chisel/sand it into the smooth, rolling contour. Good idea, bad, laughable?

- Lastly, do the legs need a third crossbar near the top to help prevent wobble?

Thank you all in advance. Its kinda fun being the dumb new guy for a change :)


img

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#2

Small Suggestion

Craig in Silverdale

>Perhaps you could put a lazy susan (from the borg)between the ply and the oak seat. That way you could swivel around a bit.

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#3

Re: Small Suggestion

A.W. Ford, of Newberg, OR

>Great suggestion, thanks. I had wanted to make it a swivel seat but wasnt sure how to go about it. BTW, what's the borg?

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#4

basically.....

Nat Robison

>It refers to the big home improvement stores........... Home Depot, Lowes, Menards, etc.

I'm sure some Trekkies will weigh in as well.

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#5

Re: basically.....

A.W. Ford, of Newberg, OR

>Gotcha, as in "you will be assimilated, resistance is futile"... Sad that everything is following the Wal-Mart model: can't find a decent non-franchise bookstore, music store, hardware store, or department store anymore in most towns I've lived in.

Wouldn't it be great to live in a private "nostalgic" American town with a "No Franchises Allowed" sign at the city limits? I'd pay the extra prices for the quality of life it would add...

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#6

Re: Any good at trig?

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>10� is too large an angle. Using it will have the legs nearly touching each other under the seat. 5� or even 4� would make a sturdier stool. 10� gives about 10.4" difference in the distance between the legs at the top versus the bottom. 5� gives approximately 5.2" difference.

I would also use �" material for the rungs, rather than �". You'd likely have to cut down stock to get to �" so why not stop at �" and have more substantial rungs?

No third crossmember at the top needed; the seat support will do the job.

Al

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#7

Re: Round the rungs

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>One more thing: I'd round the rungs. At least the tops. Leaving them with square corners will make them wear very quickly from foot traffic.

Al

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#8

Rounded trig

A.W. Ford, of Newberg, OR

>Thanks, Al, both very good suggestions. I was really wondering about that angle and only went with 10 degrees initially because it looked "right" in the drawing program I was using. Math is a serious weak point of mine, and yet another area of learning I'm boning back up on again.

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#9

JL

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

JL

>If you are going to make a swivel seat or not, make the thickness of your seat blank thicker. That way you can carve or rout your "cheek supports" or indentations deeper. I typically carve my seats to a depth of about 3/4" in the chairs that I make. This gives a lot of room. You would need a thickness of about 6/4 (or a fat 5/4) for the seat blank (though you could go thicker).

Have a pommel area between the legs and a continuous area at the back. Have a continuous sweep from the back bowl up to the front. If this isn't clear, email me and I'll send you some pictures.

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#10

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

Jim Dillon

>A.W.,

Sorry to catch your post so late but had a long day on other things. Somewhere in the back of my memory, ShopNotes had a nice plan for a shop stool that I always wanted to make but never did - but may still as my back gets sorer after a long day on concrete garage floors. I will look for it tomorrow morning and would only be too happy to copy it and send it to you if you are interested.

Jim

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#11

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

A.W. Ford, of Newberg, OR

>Thanks, JL. Any recommendations on specific techniques and or/tools for doing the seat contour? I was initially thinking about roughing it with a router and then smoothing that out with planes and or chisel work, but am totally flying by the seat of my pants...

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#12

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

A.W. Ford, of Newberg, OR

>Yes, very interested, more for a guideline on things I may not have considered (I'm sure there are plenty of those ) :)

Thanks

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#13

Changed Plans Somewhat

A.W. Ford, of Newberg, OR

>So I started in on this yesterday and found that I had to change plans somewhat, some based on advice and others on necessity once I realized some of what I'd overlooked:

* changed the degree of angle for the legs from 10 degrees to 5 degrees, per Al's excellent advice. It definitely helped both stability and aesthetics.

* rotated the legs 45 degrees so they now face from the center of the seat outward to the corners. My original plan didn't account for the 5 degree slant of the legs which would have left the sides disproportionate. This fix caused a new problem:

* My original thought was to place the crossbars between adjacent legs, but by rotating them 45 degrees that caused the crossbar joints to be cut in right at the 90 degree angle on the sides of the legs. Time to improvise: I switched the crossbars to run between opposite legs, dato'd out the crossbars so they could overlap each other like a box joint (gee I sure wish I knew all the right terminology for all these cuts and joints), so now I can route out the cuts where the crossbars fit in the legs on the flat surface of the leg. It also reduces the number of joints to be cut into each leg by half.

I screwed up and the nice oak I got for the seat is even thinner than I had thought (only 3/4"), so am rethinking the seat. First I guess I can glue up two of them to double thickness and maybe be more workable for the contouring as per JL's recommendation. Next, I'm considering tossing out the plywood seat support and going with mortise and tenon for attaching the legs to the seat. That scares me some, however, since the mortise (is that right?) will have to be cut at the 5 degree angle to accommodate the slant of the leg. I have no idea how to accomplish that, LOL.

At any rate if all goes well tonight will be spent getting reacquainted with the router and making lots of practice cuts so I get the crossbars into the legs correctly.

Many many thanks to all of you for the help and encouragement.

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#14

JL

Re: Neander or Normite?

JL

>If you are a Neander, you can take an adze and rough it out by chopping and then smooth it with a scorp and inshave. Followed by sanding.

If you are a Normite, you can take an angle grinder (oh boy, a new tool!) and use the tungsten carbide grinding wheels or the Lancelot (chain saw teeth on a circular arbor) to rough carve out the seat. Follow this with a very coarse sandpaper (24-36 grit). You can also just use the very coarse sandpaper. Where a dust mask and eye protection. Then you take your 5" ROS and sand it more.

I've done both. The angle grinder is faster, but maybe that's because I don't have enough practice the other way.

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#15

Shop Notes Stool

Jim Dillon

>A.W.,

Sorry for the delay, but our phone line was out for a day. Heck, you probably have the stool built by now 8-). Anyway, I did find the Shop Notes stool (Issue #28, Vol. 5, 1996 pgs 8-11) and have attached a pic of the stool. Their approach uses a drill press and router for construction. I scanned the article and didn't see much that would help you given your different construction approach.

Jim


img

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#16

Re: Neander or Normite?

A.W. Ford

>Hehe, guess I'm too new to know if I'm a Neander or Normite... which one has the coolest secret handshake? :)

Either technique sounds interesting. Sounds like time to dig into the scrap heap of doug fir from the mill and try both, if for no other reason than the experience. Thanks for the great advice.

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#17

Re: Shop Notes Stool *LINK*

A.W. Ford of Newberg, OR

>Thanks for the research, Jim. You're right, quite a bit different from my approach though it looks like it would be a fun one to try someday.

Not finished yet, but making decent headway on it. The legs and crossbars are done and attached to the seat support. Glued the two planks for the seat, cut, and rough sanded it. Seat still needs edge routed. Still debating on if I'm going to tackle putting the contours in it - that part intimidates me most. First picture below. I apologize for the poor quality - only have a $10 camera :) I've got a few larger, more detail pics and commentary on my screw-ups so far on my blog at http://pappysplace.info/?p=4


img

Pappy's Place (my blog)

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#18

Re: Shop Notes Stool

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>You're making good progress. With the modifications to your original plan you've (nearly) duplicated the oak stools made by the furniture shop of the Des Moines (Iowa) Public School System. Those stools were everywhere at one time. I said "nearly" because the school stools, rather than having your seat support, had a second set of cross bars at the top. The seat was attached with wood screws through the cross bars and into the bottom of the seat.

One item I noted on your web page: You mention the seat expanding/contracting while the seat support won't. The holes through which you attach the seat to the seat support should be elongated in the direction of the seat's crossgrain and the screws set snug, not tight. Also, you putting a washer under the screw head will help. Doing this will allow the seat to move without restriction and possible splitting.

Al

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#19

Mortise and Tenon joints

A.W. Ford of Newberg, OR

>Thanks, Al. I was wondering if there was anything I can do to account for that. I finally bought some chisels yesterday. If the son-in-law brings over my load of scrap wood today I may still try to make a test seat with mortise and tenon joints and throw out the seat support altogether if I do a half-way ok job of it.

Question, on the mortise and tenon, the seat is 1 1/2 inches thick. How deep should they be cut?

BTW, I've been on four or five woodworking forums so far and WoodCentral rocks them all. You guys and gals are great :)

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#20

Re: Changed Plans Somewhat

Barry Irby

>AW,

What you are experiencing is the "Steep part of the learning curve". Some it has to do with the comment about whether you are a Neander or Nordite. Go to The Hand Tools Forum if you want to check out what the Neanders (Neanderthals) are up to. The purists over there believe in doing everything with had tools. Normites on the other had are followers of Norm Abrams of New Yankee Workshop and believe in using hand tools only when there is no other way.

You may also be experiencing the "if the only tool you have is a hammer, all your problems start to look like nails" phenomenon. There are many ways to solve most wood working problems and the more complete your shop is and the the broader your skill set, the more options you have. A problem you could save with a bit and brace, can be solved with a router and a few jigs, or a drill press, or a multi router or,...?

You mentioned the seat for your stool. Windsor chairs were made out of three or four different types of wood (in each chair). Had a friend who called the makers of today's antiques "the Old People". They were wiser than we are an often more skillful. Because they did not have powerful modern machines, the old people may have had better knowledge of the wood and how to take advantage of the characteristics of it. The legs of Windsor chairs were written maple or some other hard wood because it turned nicely and took good detail and was strong. The bows or bent pieces were often hickory that was hand split (rived) so that it would bend well and not split and be strong and light and flexible. The seats were often white pine or poplar, because they were easier to saw out in big blanks, soft to carve, and light. Almost all of these chair were made of mismatched wood. The wood was matched to its function, not to the chair. They were Windsor chairs, not maple or oak chairs.

So you may want to chose a big hunk of pine to practice your seat carving on.

I made a seat and did most of the carving with a radial arm saw. finished roughing it out with a ROS.

Re: First Project: Advice welcome :)

#21

Re: Mortise and Tenon joints

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Depth of mortise for leg/seat joint: Frankly, I've lost track of whether or not your going to profile the seat top. Either wa y though, I'd make the mortices 1" sqaure and to a depth that leaves at least 3/8" of wood undisturbed above the mortise. In other words, if the seat is 1 1/2" thick, cut the moritse 1 1/8" deep at most.

It's best to cut the mortise first, then cut the tenon to fit. Easier to trim a bit more for a tenon that's too large than to try to fill in gaps from a mortise that's too big.

Al