Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Another 3PH from 1PH question

Posts

Another 3PH from 1PH question

#1

Another 3PH from 1PH question

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi all,

I'm shopping now for a drive to run the 3HP 3PH Dewalt radial arm saw that I bought. I didn't have any luck with running it, even temporarily, from the 1.5HP VFD that I have on hand. The drive would kick out even under a small load.

The question I have is this: I'm also considering buying a 5HP 3PH tablesaw. What would be the least investment for a power supply to use to power both saws? Can you power two different tools off the same VFD? I know I could use a rotary convertor to power them both, but those blame things are expensive. I may well end up building my own, if that guy hasn't sold those 2 5HP 3PH motors yet. Rick C., another link to your convertor info would be appreciated. I overlooked bookmarking it the last time. Thanks.

Once again, any input would be appreciated.

Gary

Re: Another 3PH from 1PH question

#2

Re: Another 3PH from 1PH question

Kneale Brownson in sunny N. MI

>Rick Christopherson, who contributes here regularly, has plans for a static phase converter and the addition of a second motor to create a rotary phase converter HERE.

I have a 10-hp "pig" and a commercially made box similar to Rick's plans to run my three phase stuff, which includes a Unisaw, a 3-hp DC, a 16" jointer and an 18-inch planer with two motors. I bought the box second-hand from a shop that moved to where they had three-phase power available and the pig from a plant that had used it to run a bunch of fans for venting a warehouse they tore down. I think I paid $100 or so for each purchase. The pig just sits in a corner and hums and I have three legs of 120 running all around my barn.

Re: Another 3PH from 1PH question

#3

Re: Another 3PH from 1PH question

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>If you will use only one at a time buy the 5 HP drive. Then put proper fuses in after the drive in the lines going to the smaller motor.

Bill in WNC mountains

Re: Another 3PH from 1PH question

#4

Re: Another 3PH from 1PH question *LINK*

Rick Christopherson

>When needing to power two tools, the default answer is a rotary converter, as you already know. With a little bit of extra setup and switching, you can get a single VFD to drive more than one motor, but with motors of such a significant difference in power, you may have to dumb-down the VFD so it doesn't use some of the advanced features (not sure what or why, but just saying that off the top of my head--things like startup and shutdown ramping, etc.).

VFD's don't like to be disconnected from their loads, so you would want to have some safeguards in place to select which motor is connected before the VFD sends power outward. With a few extra relays (low power, logic), this could be done automatically so that pressing the start button on each respective tool would engage that tool's motor contactor before the VFD received a start signal, but didn't disengage until the VFD fully stopped. Relatively speaking, the logic circuitry would be fairly cheap, although the design would be a bit more complex.

The biggest cost you would incur is the cost of a large enough VFD to run your 5 hp tablesaw. This would have to be at least a 7 hp VFD to account for the single-phase input when the VFD is expecting 3-phase input at this large of HP rating. However, please consult your VFD supplier for proper derating of a large VFD on single-phase power.

If you decide to go this route, I can help figure out the control circuitry, but I don't want to do this if you decide that the rotary converter is the better approach.

P.S. Even though the link to my converter article was already provided, here it is again.


Building a Phase Converter

Re: Another 3PH from 1PH question

#5

Re: Another 3PH from 1PH question

Steve Jenkins, McKinney, TX.

>When I moved into my new shop in the country I had no 3 phase power but lots of 3 phase machines. I bought a rotary convertor and fed a 3 phase panel with it so I can add more machines if I want with little trouble. It is a good solution if you see more machines in your future. Steve

Re: Another 3PH from 1PH question

#6

Thanks, guys,

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Monday I won an e-bay auction for a used Automation Direct VFD Model #GS-2 23PO for $152.50. The drive lists for $289.00. It is supposed to be a 3HP drive using either 1PH or 3PH input.

Before I bid on it, I spent a lot of time on the Automation Direct website and couldn't find anywhere that mentioned derating the drive due to 1PH input. The way it looks, if I provide 27A, 220V 1PH input, I should get 10A 208V 3PH output. Hopefully I have a drive that will run the RAS. If not, the derating factor is supposed to be 30%. So I still have a 2HP drive if I need one. Maybe I need a 2HP motor for the lathe?

Thanks everyone for your help. If this doesn't do the job, then I'm putting together a rotary convertor to run things. I like the idea of using the convertor to power a circuit box to run the various tools from.

Thanks everyone.

Gary