Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

Posts

lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

#1

lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

Jim

>For the past 5-6 years, I have been (very happily) using my 15.6 v. Panasonic drill/driver. For the first couple of years, I used it in a business, but since then just for home/woodworking. It finally quit on me, and needs to be replaced. Because I was happy with it, I didn't keep up with the advancements...namely the Lithium-Ion batteries.

The past couple of days I've been looking into the various options, and am leaning tword a purchase of either the Makita, or the Panasonic brands.

I was REALLY impressed with the compact Makita (especially the weight)...but the battery only has 1.5 amps...half that of the Panasonic. The other consideration is that when I got the Panasonic, I purchased the combo kit, so I'll be keeping the Pan. batteries and charger for the circular saw use. I have also read about a LOT of people being happy with the impact drivers...even for woodworking, and general home use.

Perhaps I should just buy a new 15.6 V drill...?

Are the lithium-ion batteries so much better it would be worth having two different sets of batteries/chargers?

If I go with Lithium-ion, which brand do YOU like?

Where are these two brands made?

What do you think about having an impact driver in addition to the drill/driver?

Any info, and ESPECIALLY EXPERIENCE would be welcome.

Thanks,

Jim

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

#2

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

Chad Pearson

>Jim,

I had the very same Panasonic combo that you have. The drills clutch finally gave out. The good news was that my wife was using it while I was sick and that is when it happened to break. No questions asked about having to get a new one. Like you I am still using the circular saw (I just had the batteries rebuilt).

I purchased the makita small lithium drill. I then purchased the impact driver off ebay (sans batteries so it was pretty cheap). I am very happy with the Makita combo. Battery life isn't much of an issue because the lithiums charge up so quickly (20 minutes or so). You can get a bigger battery but you pay for it in extra weight. The other nice thing about lithium is there is virtually no self discharge so batteries are typically ready for you even if they have been sitting for a couple months.

Because I was in a hurry to replace my Panasonic I went with the Makita drill at the Borg. I noticed in an advert that the new panasonic has gone with a brushless motor. Had I had a Panasonic dealer handy I would have considered it on that basis.

I don't think my Makita is any better or worse than my old Panasonic drill... but I like the lithium cells better. To be honest I don't think either drill is a bad choice. If the new Panasonic batteries are compatible with the old circular saw I would go that route just to save having two types of batteries. I am completely ignorant as to whether this would work or not although I expect not as the voltages are different and the manufacturer would likely want to make the charger idiot proof.

Kind of rambling...when what I could have said was that you aren't really going wrong whichever route you choose.

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

#3

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

Jim

>"I noticed in an advert that the new panasonic has gone with a brushless motor."

I guess I'm not up on this...what advantage is the brushless motor?

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

#4

Alternative

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Jim,

Have used both the Panasonic and the Makita drills and both do credible jobs and should be fine for hobbiest / homeowner use. If, however, you contemplate heavier use, you should consider the Hitachi impact with NiMH batteries. Contractor friend has one that I borrowed. The difference was amazing. It will make 3-1/2" No. 12 screws disappear without a stop. Was considering an impact driver and was about set on the DeWalt, but do believe I'll be "going green" when the time comes.

mm

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

#5

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

Chad Pearson

>Brushless motors are essentially just a different way of designing a motor. Rather than a brushed commuter to deliver power it uses three phase swithching power. The advantage of a brushless motor is mainly that you won't have any brushes wearing out that need replacing. Not a huge deal for most people. I play with electric RC aircraft and in that field a brushless motor can usually produce the same output at a lower power consumption. Really high efficiency isn't so important for hand tools.

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

#6

Re: Alternative

Miles

>I have the Makita combo - the small, older tech not the most recent ones. Work fine for me, are small and light (very handy) and the impact driver is a revelation for driving screws.

BUT - who makes screwdriver bits that can survive for long in an impact driver? All of mine have shattered eventually, especially if I don't get them perfectly set in the screw. Pozidrive, on hardened standard fast thread screws, up to 3" No10, into studs/chipboard, nothing really heavy. I had some Bosch ones that lasted OK, but no-one sells 'bits for impact drivers' as far as I, or the 20-years-selling-power-tools guy at a local hardware store, can find.

Any US sources of Pozi impact bits that are 'rated' for that purpose? Have you guys also had bits just shatter on you?

cheers

Miles

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

#7

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

Barry Irby

>I have had a Makita Drill for more than ten years I think. The batteries wore out, so I bought another that came in a combo with an Impact driver and the batteries were compatible. (12 volts) Those batteries wore out also. I have them rebuilt by Primecell (recommended here) as Nickel Metal Hydride. So now I have three tools and four batteries and two chargers. I am a little suspicious of some of the batteries, but its not an issue because I always have one or two sitting in the charger.

Not sure the Nimh batteries are a big improvement over the Ni Cads. They are supposed to hold more energy, but they bleed down over time. This could be an advantage to the Lion batteries. The fast charge could be good too.

If you get an impact driver, I would lean toward lower voltage. 12 or 14.4. No real advantage in a home shop to the bigger batteries. The smaller ones are much lighter and more handy and have plenty of power for most jobs. Rarely do I have to reach for my drill that has a tail (cord) because my 12 volt battery drills won't do the job. And the little impact driver will drive screws all day long where even the corded drill won't. I see the smaller size and lighter weight as a real feature, not a handicap.

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

#8

Re: Alternative *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Try McFeely's. They've held up much better for me than the tool rack stuff.

mm


McFeelys

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

#9

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

Larry Clinton

>I haven't purchased anything with the Lithium-ion batteries as I have read several articles that indicated they still have some problems and aren't really a good "value" item. That said I recently had to replace my Dewalt 12V drill due to battery failure. I opted for the Ridgid due to the "lifetime" warranty on the tool and batteries. I purchased the 12V drill with extra batteries as I like a light portable drill. I have tailed drills I can use if really high power or extended operation is needed. I think the only place I have needed to use the tailed drill in the last year is when I am did a lot of pocket holes with my Kreg Jig. I also purchased the Ridgid 14.4 volt impact driver. Note the impact driver is NOT designed for doing any drilling, it is only good for setting screws and small bolts. We did use the impact driver sever times - once when setting self drilling 1/4" screws into the side of a semi trailer to attach siding (converted it to a storage building), I have also used it for normal shop screw driving. It does an excellent job for what it is designed for, with no "cam out" of the screws and will set screws a normal drill will not. I do like the ergonomics and power of the Ridgid tools. Some issues with the Ridgid warranty: First I purchased these tools early this year and sent in all the paperwork for the extended service agreement, they have not registered them and returned the service agreement card. Also the only batteries that have the lifetime replacement agreement are those purchased as a part of the tool or tool kit. The extra batteries I purchased only are warrantied for 3 years. However since I have discarded 2 tools that were otherwise in top shape and purchased new ones only due to battery failure, I think the lifetime service agreement probably will be useful. I actually purchased these in my son's name and registered them to him as I am old enough (66) that lifetime warranties are beginning to be rather moot.

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

#10

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers *LINK*

Chad Pearson

>I screwed up some of the terminology on my response above. Here is more than you ever wanted to know about the design of a brushed motor. Wikipedia also has a brushless motor description as well. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brushless_DC_electric_motor

The end result is the the same ... a brushless motor is usually more efficient than a brushed one (although a cheap brushless motor might not be as good as a high quality brushed motor).


Brushed motors

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

#11

Re: Just upgraded to the 14.4 Panasonic *LINK*

Peter Gregory

>I had a 8 year old Dewalt 18V, a new Dewalt 18V cordeless drill (long story involving moving across country and wanting upgraded batteries), have a number of plug in drills, but haven't tried much else. Asked my finish carpenter buddies what to get, they told me that Panasonic is the best, but pricey.

My thoughts are that a drill and driver set is the way to go, regardless of make. I have been using them extensively for the last month and have yet to have a problem with lack of power. I did drive 5" lag bolts, into studs, to hold my lumber rack the other day, had to put on ear protection because the driver was so loud.

The 14.4 Pansonic drill seems to be as powerful and last as long per charge as my new 18V Dewalt drill. It is no comparison between the Pansonic and the old Dewalt. The price of the 18V Dewalt and the 14.4 Pansonic are about the same, if you don't find a sale. The difference is weight is a huge advantage.

I don't know if the Panasonic is better than the other makers. We do know that Panasonic makes the batteries for everyone else and keeps the highest power batteries for their own products. We also know that Panasonic is winning the magazine reviews right now.

I'm very happy with mine, so far. But talking to new owners about tools isn't very scientific.


http://www.amazon.com/Panasonic-EYC140B11-14-4-Vol

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

#12

Lee Gordon

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

Lee Gordon

>I like the Milwaukee V-28. I believe they have now come out with 18 volt lithium-ion batteries that are direct relplacements for 18 volt NiMH batteries for existing tools.

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

#13

I Have the Makita Li 18v Combo

Garrett in Victoria

>I also have a 10 year old Makita 12v that's still going strong, a Makita 14.4v that just died, and a new Ridgid 18v nicad. The Li battery life is terrific, the charge holds for months, and the 18v Makita power is unbelievable. However, the drill is big and heavy but so is the Ridgid which doesn't come close for power.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: lithium-ion drills...and impact drivers

#14

purchase decision...

Jim

>Ok, I went with the Panasonic Li-Ion combo kit. It arrived last night, and I have very high hopes for it...

I'll let you know more later, after much more use than it has seen so far...

Jim