Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

Posts

3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

#1

3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

Pete in Holland, MI

>Guys -

Have a project coming up that one of those 3-1/4" electric planers would be a great asset.

Yup, I know you get what you pay for, but I don't plan on putting many miles on this thing, thus am considering one of the cheap knock-offs.

What experiences have you had with this tool ?

Thanks !

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

#2

Got me the Bosch

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I hate Bosch tools. Love my PC,DeWalt,Milwaukee and Makitas, but.....

Well, I needed one for about a dozen interior doors.

The Bosch was highly rated and was at HD for $99 next to teh DeWalt at $149. THe DeWalt looked tougher, the Bosch looked more precise.

I couldn't bring myself to spending $50 just because I hate my previuos Bosch tools, so I bought figuring I'd return it within 39 days if I didn't like it.

Turns out I like it.

Guess I needed to buy a half dozen Bosch tools before I got one I liked. I still feel it's a little more fragile that my other tools, but it's okay.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

#3

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

Kneale Brownson in sunny N. MI

>I bought a Makita after watching a builder friend put nice bevels on deck railing lumber with his. Don't use it often, but he used to use it almost daily and I never heard him complain about it failing him.

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

#4

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I bought a Black & Decker in the case, with all the attachments and a set of new blades. YEAH, I know B&D is Crapsman quality - But I paid $4.00 at an auction. Just couldn't pass it up. Looked like it had never been used. I have used it a few times while trimming out the inside of windows at my son's house. Didn't try to do finish work with it, just got close then used my refurbished Stanley. Actually seems to work pretty good though.

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

#5

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

Nick Tuzzolino

>Check with Amazon.com..Because I had seldom use for it, I bought a Makita refurbished one for way less than new.

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

#6

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

Neal in San Jose

>I bought the Mikita about 25 years ago, when they were pretty much the only game in town. I was a contractor for 13 of those years, and did many house-full's of doors, kitchen cabinets, counter tops, etc. The Makita has never given me any problems except getting it and all the accessories back in the case. It only fits ONE way, and you'd better better pay attention when you take it out, because it will take you the rest of the afternoon to figure out how to get it back in. DAMHIKT

I'm not sure the one I have is identical to the current issue, but one feature I really like is that there are both HSS blades and carbide blades available. I keep carbide blades in it for general use, but when I need to, I switch to a new set of the HSS blades, which are sharper than carbide can be made, go slow and light on the last pass, and get a pretty nice surface finish.

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

#7

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Pete,

When you need one, they are grand. I refurbished an old P+C which was trash-picked by #3 son. As it happened, all it needed was a drive belt and a replacement fence. For $20, it wasn't a bad tool, but I've only used it twice, myself.. The newer ones have longer beds and are ergonomically superior. My #3 son Ken has a Bosch which he likes very much, and has used it in fine tuning the fit of lid and carcase of my wife's cedar chest. The lid had warped about 1/8 inch at opposite corners, and Ken cut the carcase top to his scribe line. A perfect mating. I could have done it with a hand plane and about three hours of effort. Seeing him do that changed my mind about the usefulness of electric planes.

George

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

#8

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

Jim Dillon

>Pete,

I have a 25+ years old Craftsman that is still going strong, but from reviews I've read, the Makita and Bosch are very nice and I would lean in their direction if I were buying today. Don't use it much, but when I need it, it is wonderful. My most recent use was putting an angled drip edge on a window sill. Worked great.

Jim

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

#9

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

NickB

>Definitely the Bosch if you are doing trim carpentry. I have one that I bought specifically for hanging doors (I don't do enough doors to justify the PC that is made especially for door trimming). I can't say I've used it for anything else, though. I seem to recall reading a review in JLC a year or two back on planers for door trimming, and the upshot was to get the PC if you hang a lot of doors, or the Bosch if you do just a few.

BTW, the Bosch has a "feature" that I found really annoying-it's a little spring loaded foot that is supposed to allow you to put the tool down before the blade stops spinning. It doesn't take the blade that long to spin down, and it greatly increases the pressure needed to make a cut. Happily it only takes a couple of minutes to remove it.

Hope this helps,

Nick

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

#10

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

Barry Irby

>I have a Makita that is the longer bed model I have had for twenty five years or more and I would highly recommend it.

PS. Mine does NOT have the little cover that covers the blades as they spin down. Guess what? It is my habit to let it hang by my side as I admire and consider the last cut. The cord tends to float over and brush against the Spinning cutter. I have trimmed the insulation off of it. I guess the cord has a death wish. No real damage so far, but enough to make me more careful.

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

#11

Thanx for your help guys !

Pete in Holland, MI

>

Re: 3-1/4" Electric planer wisdom sought

#12

Buy the cheapest...

Mark Harrison - Brisbane, Australia

>This is not a precision tool and if you only have very little use for it then buying an expensive one wont make any difference.

Also have a look in second hand shops and pawn shops.

I personally have a Hitachi which has re-sharpenable blades which I bought second hand off a colleague. It had scarcely been used and it hasn't seen that much use from me either. Nor will it.