Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

Posts

OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#1

OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

John E in SC

>I'm getting ready to run electricity to an outbuilding, and will be installing a 100 amp subpanel in the building. I'm only running 2 wires (hot, neutral, with ground) to the building since there will not be any 240 volt appliances in the building. My question is how to wire the subpanel box? There are 2 lugs that need a hot wire to feed all the breakers. (1 hot wire only feeds every other breaker to allow for 240 volts.) Is acceptable to run a pigtail from one hot lug to the other? If so, how would you do this? I'm running #6 wire if it matters. Thanks.

John

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#2

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA

>You did not mention the distance panel to panel. Never-the-less, you are better off running 240vac (which on a sub panel will require 4 wires so you can isolate the ground and neutral buses). Even if you do not intend to use 240 (and you will be prepared if you ever do need it) running it allows you to balance the loads between the two feed lines so as not to overload any one bus at the main panel.

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#3

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

John E in SC

>Distance is about 100 feet. Sorry, but I really don't want to run 4 wires. The cost difference over that length is substantial, and I'm not going to be running anything that would overload the main panel. All I'm wiring is 4 outlets that will be seldom used, and overhead lights.

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#4

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>I will second Gil on 220 power considerations.

If you are positive that you will never need it, then fine...obviously you know what your plans are better than I.

But as soon as you need a planer, bandsaw, tablesaw, jointer, etc with decent power, you will need 220.

Not only that, but some old used tools that normally would be wired for 110 today may be wired 220. It's nice to have it, and it's more efficient on energy.

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#5

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

John E in SC

>I'd agree 100% if this were my shop, but my shop is in the basement. This is just a garage for the boat and outdoor lawn equipment. I just want to have lights and a few outlets for things like a battery charger.

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#6

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

Dan Donaldson

>If it is only for a few outlets that won't be used much, why are you putting 100 amp out there? You could probably run 220 50 amp for close to the same money, especially if you use a smaller sub panel rather than a big one.

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#7

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

John E in SC

>100 amp subpanel was only $17.87 - a pretty minor expense compared with the $350+ the 6/2 wiring will cost (copper has gotten freakin expensive). I don't remember the price of 6/3 wiring off the top of my head, but again, it was a substantial difference, and I don't need it.

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#8

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA

>At 100 feet, 120vac, #6 wire will take 30 amps. Are you using conduit, and three individual wires? Running ONE more #6 hot wire and you now have 240 and 60 amps.

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#9

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

Rick Christopherson

>Given that this is just a garage where you need lights and a couple of outlets, you can keep your costs down and keep this simple. Contrary to the information in another posting, your #6 wire will support 60 amps, not 30 amps, so you need a 60 amp breaker in your main load center. You might have a hard time finding a single-pole breaker of this size, so you could use a 2-pole breaker with no load on the second pole. (There may be other options, but I want to keep this simple.)

You said you were only carrying two conductors out to the outbuilding, so this assumes that there are no other electrical paths to the outbuilding, and you can have an isolated grounding system. If you have anything metallic running between the two buildings, then you must carry the same ground wire from the house to the subpanel. Regardless, you need a ground rod at the outbuilding. If this is an isolated system with no ground path back to the main load center, then the ground and neutral in the outbuilding need to be bonded. If there is a ground path back to the main load center, then the ground and neutral need to remain isolated at the outbuilding.

Here is a thought for you. If your cost estimates included running a ground wire, yet the buildings are otherwise isolated, then for the same cost, you could run both hot wires without a ground. Even if you didn�t need the 240 volts, this would allow you to down-size the wire while maintaining the same system capacity. It would be a lot cheaper running #10 wire than #6 wire.

Finally, to answer the question you originally posed, yes, you could jumper the hot lugs in the subpanel, but frankly, there is no point. If you only need a couple of circuits, then it doesn�t matter that you skip every other breaker location.

Now to really be devil�s advocate, if all you need is a couple of outlets and lights, then you could get by with a single 20-amp circuit and #12 wire (I would recommend using #10 because this is right on the threshold of 100 feet).

Given all of the above information, my initial impression of this situation is that you haven�t fully thought this out, and you could be doing this better. You are setting this up as though you need more power, yet you are crippling the system. On the other hand, if you don�t need a lot of power, then there are several issues which are costing you more money.

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#10

Let me clarify...

John E

>I think I need to clarify further, but I do appreciate everyone's attempt to help. One thing I didn't mention is that I'm also installing a 30 amp RV plug in the building. It will not often be used, but it will on occasion. Otherwise, the building contains 3 overhead lights (2 8ft fluorescent strips and an outside spotlight), and 4 regular outlets, which will not likely be used often. I'm running #6 to limit the voltage drop, mainly to protect the camper when it is used. I remeasured the distance last night, and it's actually closer to 150 ft. I am running 2 wires (hot, neutral) WITH ground, (which will not be tied to the neutral at the subpanel, but independently grounded with a separate grounding rod) I installed a 30 amp breaker in the main panel (yes, I know I could have used a larger breaker, but my thought was I won't likely exceed the 30 amps since the camper plug will only be used to run the lights and rarely the AC for short times while loading.) There will be another 30 amp breaker in the subpanel going to the RV plug, and 2 -20 amp breakers for the 2 circuits - 1 for lights, 1 for receptacles. I ran 12/2 wire in the building, and 10/2 to the RV plug. No, I'm not a professional electrician, but have done a lot of homework on this. I have a friend who is an electrical engineer, and 1 who is a commercial electrician, who both agreed what I'm doing is OK. Perhaps in retrospect, I should have planned for 2 hots, but I just didn't see the need to spend the extra money.

PS - I have since been told by other sources that it's OK to run a jumper from one hot lug to the other.

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#11

Re: How many CB's can go into the panel?

Brian in Brighton

>I would consider cutting off any excess cb positions in the panel. Someone in the future mught decide to add a couple more cb's and up the main to a 100 amp without realizing that the wiring is not able to handle it from the main to the sub and fry the whole works or cause a fire.

Sounds like you studied it OK, I just usually call the feed wires a 3 wire feed. Sound like that is what you have. black/white/ground.

I agree that it is still an unbalanced load on the main panel, you should put the 30A cb on the load side that has the least amount of high amp cb's on it. In other words, put it on the leg that does not have the AC/Dryer/etc on it.

Brian in Brighton

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#12

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>John, I see no problem with your wiring. One thing I might do - up to you, is to run the wire in a conduit underground. Cheap plastic will work if the wire is rated direct burial. I would use oversize pipe, and run a stout nylon cord through with the wire. That way, if in the future you want to add the extra wire, it would be a simple task to pull in a single direct burial rated wire through the pipe. Adding one number 6 wire will double the 120V loading capability and add 220V capability. (Your next camper may have a 220V air conditioner or you may want to put a 220 air compressor or welder in the shed) - who knows what the future may bring?

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#13

Re: How many CB's can go into the panel?

Dan Manturi

>it is not the number of CBs in the panel so much as it is total draw on the Panel. Look at a fully loaded 200 amp panel and you probably have 400 amps worth of breakers or more.

The issue I have with the plan here is that i believe #6 wire is good for 50 amps. I also think that, while copper is wicked expensive, running 2 wire is really a false economy unless you are TOTALLY SURE you will not be using 220 in the future.

Oh well, good luck.

Dan

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#14

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

John E

>Running conduit with a nylon line makes good sense - I'll probably take you up on that idea. I was considering conduit anyway because part of the run is down a slight hill that sees some erosion, and adding a nylon chord would be very easy and cheap. Then I could always add an extra #6 wire down the road if needed. Thanks for the idea.

John

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#15

Re: How many CB's can go into the panel?

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> …you should put the 30A cb on the load side that has the least amount of high amp cb's on it. In other words, put it on the leg that does not have the AC/Dryer/etc on it.

I'm sure after you've thought about this for a moment, you'll realize that the AC, the Dryer, and probably the other etcs you're thinking about (the “high amp cb's”) are all 240V devices, and those will present equal loads on the two buses. However, your point is valid insofar as trying to balance the new CB with the 120V loads on the main panel.

Rod

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#16

Correct amps 30 to 60, my error.

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA

>

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#17

Are you running a ground wire or not?

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>John, it seems that everyone, including myself, is not really sure if you're running a ground wire from the house to the out-building or not. You keep saying you're running just two wires, but you also say "with a ground". In my feeble mind, that's three wires. If you are indeed running three wires (including the ground), you don't bond the neutral and ground bus at the subpanel. You can drive another ground rod and connect to the ground bus at the out-building or not - it's your choice. Code doesn't limit the number of ground electrodes you may have.

If you are truly running only two wires and intend to have the ground for the out-building as a separate isolated ground as Rick described, then you (1) must bond the ground and neutral bus at the subpanel and connect to the isolated ground rod at the out-building and (2) must NOT have any galvanic connection between the house and the out-building. This means no phone line, no water line, no ground wire or metallic conduit of any kind.

I think you've already gotten the answer on the dual lugs at the subpanel. No need to jumper, just put the circuit breakers in every other slot connected to the one lug that is connected to the house.

Good luck.

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#18

Re: Are you running a ground wire or not?

John E

>Yes, I am running a ground wire. Didn't mean to confuse anybody, but the way the wire is sold is by gauge / number of conductors WITH GROUND. For example, the wire I am using is called 6/2, which means #6 gauge, 2 conductors (black and white, or hot and neutral, whichever you prefer) and a bare copper ground, all in 1 sheath. 2 hot wires is sold as 6/3 with ground (which actually contains 4 wires). I know that's confusing, but I didn't come up with the system :) Maybe that's just the way it's done around here, but I think it's pretty standard.

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#19

RV Plug Caution

Rick Christopherson

>You didn't describe what RV plug you were going to use, but some of them are designed to be connected to 240 volts even if nothing in the RV requires it. From your questions regarding jumpering the two legs of the panel, I am guessing that this RV plug is in fact a 4-wire plug, and you were planning on running it from two separate circuits.

This would be a major no-no and would damage the cord and possibly some of the wiring in the RV. Running a shared neutral is OK when the hots are coming from opposing phases, but when both legs come from the same phase, then you are no longer canceling out the neutral current, but instead doubling it.

This may be a moot point, especially if you only have 30 amps total in the panel, but just make sure you are aware of it.

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#20

Re: RV Plug Caution

John E

>No, RV plugs (at least the 30 amp ones, I'm not sure about the 50 amp ones on larger motor homes) are made for 120v. The are designated specifically as "RV receptacles", and have just 3 connections - 1 each for hot, neutral, and ground. They are shaped differently that normal 240 receptacles, so you shouldn't be able to plug anything else in.

Re: OT- wiring subpanel in outbuilding

#21

Re: More thoughts on the cb's

Brian in Brighton

>I guess I missed the point. Make the panel UNABLE to accept anymore cb's. This will make anyone adding to the panel to at least take a close look at the wiring and realize they can't add to it without changing the primary feed.

Rod got me again. Basically, try to balace the amperage of the breakers coming from the main panel so that one leg does not have twice the typical draw than the other leg.

Brian in Brighton