Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

OT: Crack in CI Stack pipe

Posts

OT: Crack in CI Stack pipe

#1

OT: Crack in CI Stack pipe

Ben Ragusa, S. Jersey

>I need some advice with a plumbing problem. The vertical, cast iron stack in my 70 year old house has a crack just below a tee that goes to the second floor bathroom. In my opinion it was caused by floor framing that comes very close to, or may even rest on the tee fiting. The cast iron appears to be solid, not worn thin. I opened up the wall and had a plumber repair it two years ago with what looks like epoxy. It dried to a porcelain-like finish. He was exactly correct in that it would only last a couple of years, as it's leaking again. I'm wondering if the entire stack must be replaced, just the section from the crack upwards to the roof, or maybe even just the cracked section. Replacing the entire thing would seem to be a big job; basement, LR, and BR walls would need to opened up and repaired, not to mention the opening in the slate roof (simply finding someone to do that work is challenging in itself). The advice I've read here is always very thoughtful, and I respect and appreciate your comments. Any ideas?

Re: OT: Crack in CI Stack pipe

#2

Re: OT: Crack in CI Stack pipe

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Although it is not an easy job, I have replaced defective fittings in a cast iron pipe run. A qualified plumber will have a chain cutter that will cut the cast fitting, or he may use a sawsall. He can pry out the Oakum (and probably lead from that era) from the joints and install a new fitting with oakum and the new replacement for lead. My only concern is if the floor is setting on the fitting. You may have to relieve the beam setting on the fitting and brace the floor so it isn't exerting pressure on the joint. Note: I was a licensed contractor plumber in Indiana and worked at it as a second job.

Re: OT: Crack in CI Stack pipe

#3

Re: OT: Crack in CI Stack pipe

Joseph Mulherin

>Ben, I am a retired plumber. Here is what I would suggest: cut the stack above and below the tee...about 6"below and 4" above. Go to the plumbing supply and buy another tee to replace it. Get the no-hub tee; but some bandseals...rubber w/metal straps around them. but some pieces of 4" ABS from HD; fabricate it all together

and reinstall the tee. That will eliminate the problem for as long as we live.....

Re: OT: Crack in CI Stack pipe

#4

Re: Fernco is your friend

Kneale Brownson in sunny N. MI

>You can rent the chain cutter for cast iron or use a Sawzall with metal cutting blade or even, tiresomely, a hacksaw to cut out the damaged tee. Get an appropriate Schedule 40 Tee, some pipe to fit where you've removed the cast iron and buy some Fernco Neoprene adapters that are sized for the cast and the plastic and put it all together with the rubber pieces providing the sealing. That stuff will outlast you.

Re: OT: Crack in CI Stack pipe

#5

Re: Fernco is your friend

Geoff in Madison

>I used the rubber adapters and Schedule 40 PVC pipe and fittings when I removed a section of vent CI pipe to put in a basement sink. Plumbing shop here (awesome do-it-yourself shop run by a licensed master plumber) said to skip the chain pipe cutter as the old CI could shatter rather than break cleanly. He recommended the Sawzall route with a metal cutting blade. The new sections and adapters went in easily.

One additional point is to make that the upper CI pipe section is secured to the framing somewhere. You wouldn't want to leave that section dangling from your slate roof!

Re: OT: Crack in CI Stack pipe

#6

Re: OT: Thanks to all

Ben Ragusa, S. Jersey

>Thanks to all of you for your comments. The general opinion then seems to be that it can be sectioned, and that it should last a good long time. I'm encouraged by that. Not sure if I'm up to attempting this myself, so I have called a plumber, although he has not returned my call yet. But armed with your advice, I think I'll take another look at it and see if I think I can get through it step by step.

Re: OT: Crack in CI Stack pipe

#7

Re: Fernco is your friend

Ben Ragusa, S. Jersey

>Thanks, Geoff. I was concerned about leaving the upper section dangling. My thought was to use one of those metal bars that clamp around the pipe and rests on the framing to support it. It could easily be installed in the attic and I assume would be enough to carry the weight of the old pipe. Is that what you were thinking of too?