OT: Crack in CI Stack pipe
Ben Ragusa, S. Jersey
>I need some advice with a plumbing problem. The vertical, cast iron stack in my 70 year old house has a crack just below a tee that goes to the second floor bathroom. In my opinion it was caused by floor framing that comes very close to, or may even rest on the tee fiting. The cast iron appears to be solid, not worn thin. I opened up the wall and had a plumber repair it two years ago with what looks like epoxy. It dried to a porcelain-like finish. He was exactly correct in that it would only last a couple of years, as it's leaking again. I'm wondering if the entire stack must be replaced, just the section from the crack upwards to the roof, or maybe even just the cracked section. Replacing the entire thing would seem to be a big job; basement, LR, and BR walls would need to opened up and repaired, not to mention the opening in the slate roof (simply finding someone to do that work is challenging in itself). The advice I've read here is always very thoughtful, and I respect and appreciate your comments. Any ideas?



