Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

How would you cut this log?

Posts

How would you cut this log?

#1

Ellis Walentine

How would you cut this log?

Ellis Walentine

>Here is a pretty nice looking cherry log I just scored. It's about 30" in diameter and 8' long, with a three-way crotch at the top and burls all the way up. I'm concerned that it may be hollow though. I won't know until I do some poking around with a coring bit or a chainsaw.

My dilemma is this: I don't know whether to cut it up for lumber or for turning blanks. If the log is sound, I'm leaning toward making lumber out of it. My sawmill guy only has a 24" portable band mill, so he'd have to square it before he could cut lumber from it, and that would negate any nice natural-edged slabs that I might get out of it.

There's also a value aspect to this decision. How much would 150bf of cherry burl lumber be worth versus several dozen premium cherry burl turning blanks?

Tough decision, eh?

Ellis



Re: How would you cut this log?

#2

Dale Lenz

Re: How would you cut this log?

Dale Lenz

>After polking a rigid object up the cavity and noting the depth to guess-a-mate decay. Use a 2# mini sledge and pound on log listen to sound. Bottom line: your best guess and get another sawer with larger mill if you want to lumber the log. There is no wrong answer in your case, one way could be better but not wasted.

Enjoy,

Dale

Re: How would you cut this log?

#3

Wow!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>As my cousins in San Diego would say....knarly dude!

Looks like some promising goodies inside, Ellis.

Enjoy!

Jen

Re: How would you cut this log?

#4

Well........

Basil

>You could saw a thick slab (6" and 2 3")off of 3 sides and cut burls from them for turning. Then some 20" to 24" natural edge boards from the remaining cant. Book Mark the boards as they come off the sawmill so you can glue them together for natural double edge boards of ??" to appox. 48" width.

Basil

Re: How would you cut this log?

#5

Re: How would you cut this log?

Alan Bierbaum, near Denver, CO

>It looks like you might get some nice 5-6 ft table top material out of the lower part. That three way is kinda rough looking and might be better turning stock. I would find someone that could cut full width slabs though, if you decide on flat stock.

Re: How would you cut this log?

#6

Re: How would you cut this log?

Clay Foster

>I'd cut it in half lengthwise with a chainsaw and see what I had. I mill logs this size all the time free hand with a 24" bar on a Stihl 039. Sawing is pretty easy; most of the work is moving the log around. If it's solid, cut it into lumber. If the center is no good, you know you have turning blanks.

Big pretty boards are hard to get. Turning stock is abundant.

Re: How would you cut this log?

#7

my guess

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>Alan seems closest to the mark. The top and root flare both are turning stock no question. I'd chainsaw off the flared edges (5 or 6 blanks there) and cut the entire top off and see if the remainder looked good enough for boards. How long is the log now?

9 out ten cherry crotches are bark included; I have yet to see a useful threeway, so I think you should expect little from the top 3'.

Re: How would you cut this log?

#8

sorry

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>I just saw you mentioned the length of the log in your original post. You will not get any decent 8' boards because of the probably ruinous crotch area, but maybe 4-5' long and respectably wide panel pieces are the best you can do anyway.

Re: How would you cut this log?

#9

Re: How would you cut this log?

Rob Stokes in North Vancouver

>The crown of the log has obvious rot in it and I believe I can also see cleaves where the three branches meet. This evidence, coupled with the fact that area of the tree WILL be reaction wood tells me that it's probably best cut off - say a foot below the actual crotch, and that this piece should then be further dissected for turning blanks.

That leaves a 5' log that should then be put on the saw and squared. I'd be tempted to "barely" square it and see what you have, but I'm betting that you'll end up with four slabs of sap wood with straight cut edges. If you assume the log has to be taken to a cant of 24" square in order to get rid of the bark, and then cut these slabs at 2.5" thick, you'll have some nice figured sap wood for table tops/benches etc.

This will leave you a can that's 19" square. I think you'll find the pith is petty much useless in that log and if so, you'll lose 8 or 10" out of the middle. This means that if you mill the top of the cant at 4/4" (rough mill to an inch and an eight) and then flip it to do the same to the bottom, you'll get 8 pieces that are 5' long, 4/4" thk and 19" wide. The remaining piece wil yield an additional 8 pieces of 5' long x 4/4" thk x 10" wide.

You'll notice this saw pattern will produce flat-sawn stock. I think this will give you the best chance at maximizing your figuring. If you choose to 1/4 saw it you'll get similar yield, but obviously won't get the 19" wide 4/4 pieces.

Rob

Re: How would you cut this log?

#10

Exactly what I had in mind Clay

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>

Re: How would you cut this log?

#11

through and through

Robin Corell, in Atascadero CA

>I'll begin by saying that I have never milled cherry. that said I have done a fair bit of milling with a chain saw and used a woodmizer a few times and even played with a swing blade once. I still tend to like to mill everything through and through. Don't know if that is a term used on the other coast but out here it refers to slicing the log as it sits on the mill without turning it. Some people don't like this method as they feel you don't have the option of cutting for grade. My opinion is that a log has a set # of defects and you can't eliminate them by how you cut, just arange which boards thay are in. I never know what I will make out of a board till I pick it up to use once it is cured. I don't do natural edge work but I do like to have the boards in as big a pieces as possible to give me the greatest number of possibilities. to that end I tend to mill everything 2 1/4" thick through and through and stack in flitches.

Now back to your log. It looks like there is a slight wind check at the base end that is running perpendicular to the ground. If this is true then it should also be close to the pith as well. I would mill the log parallel to the wind check and would measure the slabs so that the wind check is boxed in one slab. This will allow you to cut the bad parts out and have some nice quarter sawn narrow slabs. This will also take you through the two bigest limbs and possibly get best crotch figure. I would also take a thick cap

and possibley take a slab or two off of it depending on the figure and the burl and how it lookd to you for turning blanks. same with the other side.

Also of concern is that in the picture it looks like the log has a mild twist to it, it could be the angle of the camera. I am not familiar with chery so I don't know how big of a concern this would be. For me if it were cypress I would walk away from it but if it were claro walnut it wouldn't make one bit of diference.

In my experiance the extra kerf of a chainsaw mill is not as big a deal as the bandmill sales pitches make it to be. The reason I say that is because a chainsaw mill is much more acurate in its constant thickness. with the way a portable bandmill blade can dive through a log the thiner kerf is eaten up by a planer by the time the boards are back to parallel.

take good pics for us.

Robin

Re: How would you cut this log?

#12

Re: How would you cut this log?

Barry Irby

>I have cut and milled a little cherry, probably less than you have. My little bit of experience is that the rot that comes from the top down is much worse than that that comes form the bottom up. My assumption is that it soaks down through the tree more than it rises. So, I am thinking that rooted area extends at least half way down the log and that stain (?) on the bottom of the log may be the other end of it. If that dark spot Ont he butt end appears to be wet and semirotted, I would assume the two are connected. If so, I would plan my cutting around that.

I would probably start by cutting the three way crotch off and seeing if the rot went that far. Or probe it. I just cut a cherry tree that rotted from the top down and there was not much left. I made some bowls out of wood that was stained by the rot and did not find them attractive. Good luck. I hope yours is better than mine.

Let us know.

Re: How would you cut this log?

#13

Re: Best projects I have ever made

Peter Gregory

>The finest projects I have ever completed were from cherry that was a little rotten and messed up. You can't use it all, but the pieces you can use have character and color that can't be beat.

The world is full of turning blanks from yard trees, aka - firewood.

I'm thinking quarter sawn myself.

Re: How would you cut this log?

#14

Re: How would you cut this log?

Rich Glisson

>It makes a nice poison ivy planter as it is!