Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

DC - how far can I run?

Posts

DC - how far can I run?

#1

DC - how far can I run?

Terry Alexander

>I have the Penn 1 1/2 HP dust collection. I got it free from a recently divorced woman who's husband ran off and left everything. I had to dismantle it and take it down from the wall.

Anyway.....at my farm I have 2 buildings - 5 feet apart. One is 30' x 40' and the other is 24' x 24'. I have all my woodworking tools in the 30x40. For noise reasons, I was wondering if I could setup the DC in the 24x24 building, run the 6" piping I got up about 9', then through 1 building wall into the other building wall. From there, I would be coming into the center of the 40' wall where almost all of my machines are. I would only be running a single machine at a time as I am the sole woodworker. I have some blast gates. Having said/typed all of that, I am thinking absolute longest lineal run I would have would be 5' up + 5' building to building + 20' to the farthest machine and maybe an additonal 10' away from the wall. So...40' or so.

Sigh...........in the opinion of this knowledgable board, is this doable?

As always....thanks in advance.

Terry Alexander

Re: DC - how far can I run?

#2

JL

Re: DC - how far can I run?

JL

>If it is the DC I think it is, it has maybe 1250 cfm. I had a similar unit. I had maybe 25' of maximum run, but I was running it through a "trash can" separator. It worked okay at with the end tool. If you have good "tight" joints and smooth piping, it may not be that bad.

That being said, I wouldn't have a high demand tool (jointer, planer, table saw) as the end tool.

Re: DC - how far can I run?

#3

Re: DC - how far can I run?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Terry,

My run just completed (see "Can't Such Enough" below) is 50 foot with two ninety degree turns which translates to about 65 feet of duct. My chop saw and table saw are at the very end and after the 2nd turn respectively. Performance through the 6" duct is spectacular, but I doubt it would work much at all through a 4" line of that length.

Have you considered just putting your collector outside on an exterior wall? A simple shed roof to keep precip off the bag would be enough.

mm

Re: DC - how far can I run?

#4

Re: DC - how far can I run?

Ron Hildreth, Alta, Iowa

>Mark,

I once heard a HVAC guy tell me that one 90 degree elbow is equivalent to adding eight foot of straight pipe in air flow resistance. Any truth to that? Wouldn't the diameter of the pipe have something to do with it?

Ron in Iowa

Re: DC - how far can I run?

#5

Re: DC - how far can I run?

Dan Donaldson

>The diameter would not matter as it is stated. That would be an additional 8 feet of whatever diameter you are using. If it is a small pipe, then it would add more resistance, but the same as 8 feet of smaller pipe. Clear as mud ? ;-)

Re: DC - how far can I run?

#6

Too True

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Ron,

When running ductwork for HVAC, you always figure 8' in lineal measurement for every 90* bend. That presumes that the bend is the proper radius which is usually 2 times the diameter of the duct. Put in a sharper bend and the factor goes up fast although I don't have the table of values handy.

This is why I made up all the bends in my system with a pair of 45* bends. In 6" round duct, a double 45 gives me a minimum radius of 16" through the 90*; more if I space the bends apart. While plumbers often use "street" fittings with one bemd having a male end to make a more compact bend, that's a no-no in dust collection where you need the bends as gentle as you can get. The result is that at the ports in the chopsaw hood which is at the very end of my system I'm pulling 465 FPM as measured with a velometer. Can't tell you what it's pulling at the table saw or other drops closer to the blower because the meter immediately pegs at those ports so it's well above 500 FPM.

mm

Re: DC - how far can I run?

#7

I believe they were called Run DMC

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Hi Terry, It's not "DC Run", but "Run DMC"

Also seems a bit odd to be asking a question about wanting to "run" considering you mentioned "a recently divorced woman who's husband ran off and left everything"

Never-the-less, I would think the DC should be able to handle it. What you're talking about is the kind of lengths that might be found in a workshop anyways. The fact they are in different buildings doesn't seem to be adding too much length to the system. IF you main shopw was 5' longer, your whole system might be the same length even if the DC was in the same room.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: DC - how far can I run?

#8

Re: Why not build the DC into a closet?

Peter Gregory

>If you are worried about noise, but have the room, why not build a closet around your DC? Put some acoustic tile on the walls and ceiling, then fish the pipe through the wall?

Personally, I don't worry about DC noise, if the DC is on, I'm about to run a machine and my earmuffs are on.

I agree with the crowd, big pipe works better.