>I am needing to build a shelf above a television in an alcove. The shelf will need to be 24"x52". Would it be possible to use mdf as the shelf with a solid front edge band? Obviously the shelf would be supported around the edges. I was thinking I would rout a tongue and groove for the edge band. Thanks for the help!
>IMHO the MDF would sag badly at 54" long. MDF doesn't have a lot of rigidity. If I were doing it, I would use either solid wood (my preference) or Plywood with a 3/4" edge board attached to the front at least an 1 1/4 deep. Other more expert woodworkers may have better answers / options.
I agree with Larry on the need for a wider edge on your MDF shelf. Such a wider edge (rather than an edge only as wide as the MDF) can increase the stiffness of the MDF a lot. Would your design allow you to put a wider edge on the back edge as well? If so, then maybe you can get by with a slightly narrower front edge. I would consider cutting a rabbet along the edge of the hardwood to cover up the unsightly edge of the MDF and to provide support from underneath. Somewhere I remember reading an article on bookshelf stiffness and ways to increase their stiffness. If I find it, I will post it. Good luck.
>I concur that MDF would be a poor choice for shelf material across a two-foot by four-foot plus span unless you're able to put a cross-framework beneath it for support. If you're going to attach something like a 1X2 to the walls of the alcove and run a 1X3 across the front, maybe a series of intermediate 1X2s from back to front would add sufficient support. Even plywood or solid wood across those spans would need some support if the shelf is going to carry much.
>You didn't mention what you're planning to store up there on that shelf, but it matters. There are several important factors that govern shelf engineering: span, depth, support system, load, distribution of that load and shelf materials, to name the big ones.
If this is likely to be a light-duty application, e.g., just a VCR and a DVD player and a cable box, you don't need to over-engineer the shelf. A simple piece of 3/4" plywood, supported on ledgers on the back and sides and a drop edge on the front (it doesn't matter much if you tongue and groove it or just glue it on) will handle most light loads.
If you plan to store heavy books, or your curling stone collection or something heavy up there, consider a torsion box. They are easy to make and extremely stiff -- essentially a bunch of ribs glued between two sheets of thin plywood. You can even leave pockets at the edges of your torsion box and thereby hide the support structure entirely.
I wouldn't use MDF, as it will want to sag in every possible direction unless, as someone noted, you provide a well-engineered support structure -- ribs and stiffeners appropriately sized -- to support it.
>...Zack. The March/April issue of FWW #190 pg 38-43 contains an article on building bookshelves. Within the article is reference to using the Sagulator software to calculate the bookshelf deflection under a given load (per foot). While I didn't see any input for edging, the FWW article contains a chart of different wood species and the deflection. Interestingly, they list 3/4 inch MDF with and without a 2-inch red oak edging. For a 42 inch MDF shelf, 11 inches wide, the shelf weight limit (a deflection of over 0.02 in/foot) is 7 pounds/foot. This assumes no fastening of the shelf at the ends. This link contains a link to the Sagulator. Hope this helps.