>Since I only have dreaded dial-up here in VA with no obvious relief any time soon, I've been looking into Satellite Internet. From what I've been able to find out, this system doesn't look too reliable. Does anyone have any input on this subject?
We've had Hughenet since early Feb. and have had no problems to speak of so far. A couple of times, I've had to unplug the modem and the router and let everything reset, but that's been about it. The reputation for being weather sensitive is undeserved. You might loose service momentarily if there is a huge thunderstorm between you and the satellite, but I'm not online continuously anyway.
Like you, we are in a rural area where we will never see cable or other high-speed access, so the only choices are Hughesnet and dial-up. There's no comparison between satellite and dial-up in my opinion, though there is a perceptible delay when you initially access a particular site. Something about opening up switches on the satellite and on the ground.
Besides, I think it's pretty cool to be able to own your own transmitter that can bounce a signal into outer space and back for only a few hundred dollars. Talk about the wonders of modern technology. I can remember when transistor radios were a big deal.
When we moved from the city to the farm in '04 I had to give up cable modem. Dialup in this area was worse than normal so I had a Direcway (now Hughes) system installed. While the internet connection is slow relative to cable, it was far faster than modem and worked out fine for my needs. It was faster than ISDN (which I also used for many years) and much cheaper than T1 (which I never personally had). I can say this about satellite internet based on my experience:
- It was extremely reliable. I lost connection occasionally during hard thunderstorm and a couple of rare times when snow accumulated on the dish. There were a couple of outages when the system was being worked on but the downtime was short. My cable connection has been out (due to recent fiber optic system upgrades) more than the satellite ever was.
- It was much faster than dialup and much slower than cable modem. I think I averaged 700-800K downstream and 50-75K upstream. Satellite is a shared bandwidth system so access speed varies with the number of users.
- The way the data packets must be compressed and accumulated before being transmitted to and from the satellite can severely limit the throughput to a secure (https) web site. It works, but some can be dreadfully slow, possibly worse than dialup.
- Our techs could not get VPN to work on my system or on others they tried, probably due to the encription issue mentioned above. When I absoulutely needed VPN, I dropped back to dialup.
- It is very important to get the satellite configured and aligned properly. Perhaps this is the reason for negative reliability reports. The guy who installed mine didn't like the specific satellite the main office had assigned so he switched it to another. Perhaps some are less reliable or busier. He did say the final signal strength on my installation was one of the best he had seen. Note that your location needs a clear path to the geosynchronus staellites in the southern sky, similar to that required for satellite TV.
Since I worked at home at a computer-related job, I relied on the satellite connection to get my work done. I ran it through a switch and to my network of up to six computers. However, if I did need to send a few hundred megabytes to the Lab, I admit to using the automobile and CD connection at times.
I worked this way for almost three years before retiring. Ironically, just after retiring the cable company had upgraded their service to this area and I was able to get blindingly fast cable modem again. Oh well!
Note that it is expensive. Since they have (had?) no competition in areas where cable and DSL are unavailable, there were no deals. I do not know what if anything has changed concerning competition, reliablity or service.
Also, you have to buy the equipment: satellite dish, modem, and wiring. I think it was about $600 at the time. However, you might be able to find a good deal in used equipment on ebay or elsewhere. (Mine is available cheap, BTW!)
>Satellite Internet is not perfect but it is a lot better than dial-up. I have had Hughes Net for the last year here in the mountains of Arizona. The reliability problems due to weather have not been severe. I lost service last winter one day because of snow on the dish. Lost service during this summer a couple of times due to rain storms. Once Hughes had to send someone out because the original installer had used an inferior connector at the dish.
You might want to look into two other possibilities rather than HughesNet. One is WildBlue which is a newer satellite internet service that is ten dollars a month cheaper than Hughes. It was just too new last year for me to consider it. It also has the problem of not being able to sign up customers in all parts of the country. The second potential option is service with one of the cellular phone companies. Verizon has a program that I am familiar with. It won't work at my location but works a mile from me.
I have no regrets switching from dial-up to Hughes Net. In this little community of 150 full time residents I probable know a dozen people with HughesNet, two or three with WildBlue and two with cellular high speed.
>My setup is very much like yours and I would concur with everything you've said, with one exception: my upload speeds are in the 80-110 Kbps range. I've had a lot worse luck with reliability, though, averaging at least one outage every day and almost always when it rains or snows. I think some of the problem may have to do with one suspect router in my network, but I've not been able to positively isolate that as the culprit.
I've signed the local Verizon petition to get DSL out here to our neighborhood. Meanwhile, the satellite is definitely a huge improvement over dialup. I keep my dialup account, too, for those rainy days when I can't get online with the satellite.
>It is possible you might have other providers that aren't being heavily advertised. We have DSL about 2 miles from us and have been told "we want everyone to have access by the end of the year" for at least two years now. There are also two non-phone company wireless services. Unfortunately they are both line of site and we can't get a signal because we are low and have trees interfering. You might be able to find such companies in your area using a Google search. The cable company has not interest in every providing service and the new type of service being tested over the power lines is going to areas that already have cable and DSL.
As a result we went with Hughes Net. The difference between our old dial up and the satellite is amazing. I just did a speed check and got 1696 kbps down (about 200 kbps faster than normal) and 287 up (about 400 kpps slower than normal).
1. From time to time I will have problem accessing secure sites. This will last from a couple of hours to a couple days.
2. I try to watch the weather radar when we have bigs storms moving through but will loose the signal and have to revert back to dial-up.
3. About once a week or two I'll have to unplug and let things re-boot.
4. It is expensive. About $83 a month for the faster service. I forget the original install price but there was a $100 rebate promptly sent after 3 months of service.
I'm glad we have this service but will probably change if anything else become available.
>I hear a few fellows from work talking about how good their Internet service is through their cellular phone company. I wonder if this is a better alternative to satellite service cost and speed-wise? I'd think if you get good cell service and signal there in York, perhaps this type of service would be something to look into too.
One thing I do know - here in the Richmond, VA area, even though Verizon Wireless has a good network and connects about anywhere, their wireless Internet service is not that good. Folks tell me Sprint has a much faster service and they're happy with it so far.
>I'm in the category of "less-than-stellar-service." While the downloads beat dial-up by a mile, uploads and general web surfing are often agonizingly slow, even slower than dial-up at times. The service doesn't often go out altogether, but it will go out for over an hour during times of rain. I have the fastest category of HughesNet service and if/when I get other options, I will surely switch (however, dial-up will not be one of those options).
>>...but it will go out for over an hour during times of rain.
If it goes out for more than a few minutes during heavy thunderstorms, either your area experiences mega storms or you possibly have a bad connection somewhere that is not water tight. Or someone drove a tack through the cable insulation. And/or perhaps the satellite alignment is off a touch.