Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

Posts

The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#1

JL

The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

JL

>OK - there I was, all hot and heavy to buy a cabinet saw. So I did a bit more research. The cabinet saws in question are:

3 hp, light duty cabinet saw w/ 50" fence (35610). This one has a less beefy fence and a single belt. The trunion is less massive.

5 hp, heavy duty cabinet saw with 50" fence (35626). This one has an "industrial" fence, 3 belts and a "Massive one piece cast iron trunion assembly".

The 35610 is currently running $1149 with a $100 rebate. An attractive price to be sure. Do the single belt, less beefy fence and the less massive trunion make this a less attractive saw? The total weight is about 100 lbs less.

The 35626 is currently running $1649. A heftier price for a heftier saw. Ya'll convinced me that I don't really need the 5 hp.

My thinking is that I would prefer to have multiple belts, an industrial fence and a heftier saw. The equivalent 3 hp saw is currently costing about $50 more than the 5 hp - therefore I am leaning towards the 5 hp saw. There are no rebates on these.

So, do I need the multiple belts? Do they make that much of a difference? I figure that a beefier saw and fence would be nicer in terms of alignment and stability. Is my thinking correct?

TIA.


Steel City Cabinet Saws

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#2

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws?

Sawdust B Gone!

>JL,

Unless you have the provided for the power of a 5hp machine, then it is worth considering. Also, if you intend to sell the saw later, 3hp "may" sell more easily down the road.

As far as belts go, I have not seen the SC belts before and yes, I they are only a single belt (according to specifications). However, I would take a look at the belt design because some single belts are very wide. Regular narrower belts like those on the unisaw (that's why it's s triple belt design) can handle power transmission effectively of up to 1-1/2hp. If you need to transfer more power, either use multiple belts or use wider belts. I know motorcycles use single transmission drive belts are 2" sometimes 4" wide for less slippage.

So bottom line is check out the belts. It's the quality of the belt and pulley that counts, not just the quantity of belts.

my $0.02

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#3

Power to the blade

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>As explaind to me, the ability of a 1/2" v-belt to transmit hosrepower is limited to about 1 hp. Thus you need the 3 belts to get all the torque that your motor is supposed to be putting out.

I would be rather suspect of a 5hp machine that was selling for a $50 difference from a 3hp. I'd make sure that they weren't passing another single-belt cheapie along, and especially the type and quality of the motor and the internal works. There may be a bunch of cheap 5 hp motors around that have less usable torque and less life expectancy than a good 3 hp Baldor. The old sayings go here: "no free lunch" and "you get what you pay for, but only if you know what you're buying."

Sounds to me like you should do some more digging.

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#4

Apples and oranges

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>You know this changes everything. When we were looking at the 3HP and 5HP with the $550 difference, I thought they were the same saw with only the motor difference. That's why I (and others I think) said get the 3HP and save $550. But now we're talking about a 3HP saw with elss fence and less trunnions.... it's more than the HP difference.

And from what you're saying the 5HP is cheaper than the 3HP saw.... which seems to go along with what I've heard... that the 5HP saws didn't sell well or didn't move as fast so they're better deals on them.

So know I'm not sure what Id' recommend, other that I think you could still get the 3HP with the same fence and trunnions and at the 5HP saw (ie. the industrial, not the new Chinese cabinet saw) so the same $1200 price if you get a Redmond's reconditioned one. That' what I'd do. You'd get the 3HP and the older style heftier saw, and still save $500.

Good luck!

Happy Woodworking!

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#5

JL

Re: I've provided for the power...

JL

>I ran a 30 amp 220V circuit w/ 10 gauge wire to power the eventual cabinet saw. Power is not a problem.

As far as the pulleys, the castings on the "light duty" 3 hp saw are a bit lighter than the 5 hp or the "heavy duty" 3 hp. The single belt is a bit larger than the 3 belts.

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#6

JL

Re: Evidently they bought a bunch of..

JL

>5 hp are are now trying to "unload" them. As these are all import motors...

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#7

JL

Re: But I wanted a new one....

JL

>whine. :). He's got some reconditioned saws in the back. I'll check them out.

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#8

Ya... I hear you, just bought another motorbike

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I just bought another Honda trail bike, this time a 2001.

I sure would have liked to get a 2007 or 2008, but considering it was 1/5th the price, I'll enjoy the 2001.

Happy Woodworking!


img

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#9

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: I've provided for the power...

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Interesting. So far as I know, all the other brands of 3 hp (true) cabinet saws are using the three belt system. Delta, Jet Grixx/Shop Fox, etc. are all using three belts. They also appear to be using the same trunnion castings for three hp and five hp - no differences, except for the motor.

The Delta 'tilting arbor saw' OTOH, uses a single belt, and has the trunnions bolted to the underside of the table - like a contractors saw. It, too, only uses a single belt.

Could that be the difference?

Jim D.

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#10

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Power to the blade

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

>Mark said: As explaind to me, the ability of a 1/2" v-belt to transmit hosrepower is limited to about 1 hp. Thus you need the 3 belts to get all the torque that your motor is supposed to be putting out.

What about all the pre-serpentine belt cars - with upwards of 300 hp - that used a single �" V-belt? My old Chevy 350 had two belts - one for the water pump and alternator, and a second one for the power steering and A/C. Advertised at 320 hp, and never threw a �" belt.

Jim D.

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#11

JL

Re: That seems to be the difference..

JL

>between the "light duty" and the "heavy duty" 3 hp saws.

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#12

Re: Power to the Pump

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The difference is/was, Jim, that you didn't need 350 horsepower to run the fan, the water pump and the generator; 1/2 to 3/4 was more than enough. But notice that when people started bolting on A/C units, double alternators, and power steering and brakes that those surpentine belts got wider and w-i-d-e-r until now you may have an 1-1/2" multivees or more needed to transmit the housepower demands of all those compressors and bolt-ons.

mm

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#13

First things first. What are you using the saw for

Forrest Addy

>First things first. What are you using the saw for? Do you need greater power and rigidity that justifies the higher price?

A beefy 5 HP saw is used for thick material and continuous cutting as with a stock feeder and thousands of linear feet of thick material have to dimensioned in a single set-up. I used to work part time at a teak shop where 6 and 8/4 rough teak had to be cut into blank material for boat joinery. We had a man feeding the saw full time for days running an old Delta Unisaw equipped with a stock feeder. The saw was equipped with a 1 1/2 HP wound rotor motor and a Disston thin kerf blade yet it ran all those miles of teak without a hitch.

A beefy fence is available on the after market if the one the on an otherwise satisfactory saw appears unsat. Dealers sometimes offer you a choice of fences and other accessories.

Extra sturdy trunions and cradle are nice but if its overkill for your purposes then you might be spending more money than you need to for the performance you desire. Don't get me wrong. Some materials cut in quantity require more HP. Unless you are running a commercial shop dimensioning hard thick materials, 5 HP is overkill.

Of course if you prefer to have the huskiest saw for no other reason than because you want it then go for it. There has never been a cost/benefit analysis that trumps simple lust for the coolest widget.

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#14

Re: That seems to be the difference..

Sawdust B Gone

>Then it's not a true cabinet saw of the trunions are bolted to the table. Probably more like a hybrid. Which is why it is less expensive than a true 3hp heavy castings.

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#15

I use just one

JRutter

>FWIW, I run a single belt on my Unisaw - less vibration and no problems with power. It gets used 1-3 hours per day ripping 4/4 and 5/4 hardwoods.

-JR

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#16

Rick L

Re: One is all you need...

Rick L

>apparently you are the only one who understands it. I've been using 9 hp sliders for years with up to 18" blades and nearly all of them had only one belt. How much more proof do you need?

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#17

Re: Martin belt spec

Brian in Brighton

>A "B" V-belt, which I think these are running, on a 4 inch sheave is rated for 2.6 Hp at 1750 rpm. Bump that sheave to 4.2 Diameter and it can handle 3.18 Hp.

So a single belt could, by the numbers, work fine. I would look at why all the other manufacturers use 3 belts for their 3Hp and up cabinet saws. Go with the flow, unless the belt is a larger size yet. I have not figured out why they don't change to a toothed timing belt, unless the dust leads to skipping. Is the motor weight creating tension on these saws, or is there a tension device to keep the belt tight. The numbers quoted above are for a properly tensioned belt.

Brian in Brighton

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#18

Re: Multiple devices on single belt also

Brian in Brighton

>Notice that most newer cars also have several devices on the accessory belt also. The belt needs to be designed to transmit as much power as the device will draw. So a 1/2 Hp pump, 1Hp compressor and 3/4Hp alternator will only need a belt that can transmit a total of 2.25Hp. The serpentine belts are mini-vee to allow them to be used on both sides of the belt. A std vee-belt is a one direction bend belt to transmit power.

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#19

Just one point

Dan Donaldson

>An alternator uses more than 3/4 horsepower. Depending on the rating, it can be anywhere from 1.5 to 2 or more horses.

When I was a kid, I got the bright idea to make a battery charger out of some parts that I had around. I took a 1 horse motor, an alternator, a regulator, a battery and mounted them on a board with the motor driving the alternator and all of the regulator and alternator circuits wired in. I turned on the motor and everything spun up just fine. Then I hooked in the battery and I'll bet that motor didn't even turn a full revolution before it stalled out. That 1 horse motor was not even close to what was needed to spin a loaded alternator.

Re: The importance of multiple belts on cab. saws? *LINK*

#20

Sorry, I didn't wash off those numbers after..

Brian in Brighton

>I pulled them out. :-)

Brian in Brighton