Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Accident Video-What can we learn? *LINK*

Posts

Accident Video-What can we learn? *LINK*

#1

Accident Video-What can we learn? *LINK*

Brian in Brighton

>This is a link to a video on you tube of a guy who video taped himself making something for his girl. He cuts his left thumb off. No kidding folks, it really is cut off on his table saw. Do NOT watch this if you have a weak stomach. I think this is a great video of what not to do and would make a one of a kind safety video. The guy seems to be experienced and has a nice saw and shop, but makes a lot of mistakes.

I watched this with this thought in mind and I would like people to start a list of one item each and let's see how many items we can come up with.

So, what did he do wrong?

I'll start the list:

1: His blade has no guard.


Guy cuts off his thumb

Re: Accident Video-What can we learn? *LINK*

#2

It's a hoax! Not real.

Bri in Mtl

>

Re: Accident Video-What can we learn? *LINK*

#3

Re: It's a hoax! Not real.

Brian in Brighton

>Really? I have a NON-you tube version that shows a lot more. Would you like to see it? It sure looks real to me. I can send you a wmv file if you want, but can't figure out if I can post it.

Brian in Brighton

Even if it is fake, it is a pretty good one and has a lot to learn, which is the point of the post.

Re: Accident Video-What can we learn? *LINK*

#4

Re: It's a hoax! Not real.

Bri in Mtl

>I've seen the other versions. In 1 freeze framed image you can see his own thumb. Quite definite that it's fake.

Watch how his fingers never move. They stay clinched together to keep his real thumb pressed up under his hand. Plus, the end of it is glued to the board. It never even falls over.

There's some other errors also.

Sorry -I fell for it the 1st time too.

Re: Accident Video-What can we learn? *LINK*

#5

Not sure about that one...

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>...but there are lots of fakes on the internet, fakes of all sorts of things.

In fact, if you search, some of the fakes on YouTube have related videos explaining how they were faked. There's one of a guy that solves a Rubiks cube with his feet. And another video that shows how he filmed it and then reversed the video, making it look like's he's solving it.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Accident Video-What can we learn? *LINK*

#6

Solving Rubic's cube with feet.

Basil

>One should start by putting on a pair of Combat boots.

....and Rubic's revenge should only be attempted with a 20 lb. sledge hammer.

25 years ago it took me about a week to figure out Rubic's cube and about half a day maybe on Rubic's Revenge.

Re: Accident Video-What can we learn? *LINK*

#7

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The TV commercial...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>Somehow the Rubik's Cube solution by foot ended up in a TV commercial for something or other. I could tell immediately that it was faked and done in reverse. There was one small glitch in the editing that caused a few non-contiguous frames...

Jason

Re: Accident Video-What can we learn? *LINK*

#8

Re: It's a hoax! Not real.

Brian in Brighton

>I went thru the larger format, wider shot, video and I think this is real, or really really good. Just when he is laying the board onto the table his thumb tip cocks backward like it should and a rubber one would not. In the video he also comes back and grabs the thumb from the board and it does not move the board a bit. Can you snap a pic of the section that you see his thumb tucked and e-mail it to me?

bflefevre@comcast.net I will then e-mail you the longer, larger video.

brian in brighton

Re: Accident Video-What can we learn? *LINK*

#9

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Two reasons why it's fake

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>1. As you see him lining up for the cut, his thumb is at a very unnatural angle--his hand is at a high angle to the board, but the thumb is flat on the board (like his real thumb is tucked under his hand).

2. After the thumb is cut off, you see it jump--but the tip stays firmly planted on the board like it was glued.

No way it's real.

Jason

Re: Accident Video-What can we learn? *LINK*

#10

Re: It's a hoax! Not real. *LINK*

Bri in Mtl

>I can only freezeframe it but can't capture the frame.

I'm confident it's fake.

But if you want to help the "poor" guy out you can check this other video out.

Notice he won't show the whole hand and as someone pointed out he's looking at maybe a moni9tor to make sure he doesn't overexpose his injury.

LOL


response

Re: Accident Video-What can we learn? *LINK*

#11

Wait a sec!!

Bri in Mtl

>The 2nd video he holds up his injured RIGHT hand.

The 1st video he cut off his thumb on his LEFT hand!

LMAO..

Re: Accident Video-What can we learn? *LINK*

#12

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Re: Wait a sec!!

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>You're right...and you get a clear view of his left hand in the second video--that thumb looks pretty good.

Jason

Re: Accident Video-What can we learn? *LINK*

#13

Well done fake, the second video proves it.

Brian in Brighton

>Let's see the actual wound.

Brian in Brighton