Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Finish Failure

Posts

Finish Failure

#1

Finish Failure

Steve Bellner

>Hello all,

Back in January, I completed a cedar-lined oak blanket chest for a neighbor. Because of conflicting travel schedules, the chest has sat in my shop with the lid closed for seven months. I opened it last month, and discovered the finish on the inside pieces of oak had become tacky - very tacky. The cedar is aromatic, and is installed on the sides and bottom of the interior. The top and top rail are red oak, and I used the following finish schedule: transtint dye followed by 1# shellac and several coats of Minwax wipe-on poly. The poly has completely softened and has become tacky.

I am going to have to scrape off the defective areas, and refinish. What would be a good finish that could survive in the presence of aromatic cedar vapors for month at a time?

Re: Finish Failure

#2

Re: Finish Failure

Dan Donaldson

>I would either just use the shellac, or better yet, nothing for the inside. Poly has a problem setting up with some woods that have a lot of aromatics or oils. On rosewoods, it tends to never harden, not sure about cedar. On the blanket chests that I have done, I don't put any interior finish at all.

Re: Finish Failure

#3

Re: Finish Failure

R. Lance in GR, Michigan

>A few months ago I posed a question about this very possibility after reading an article in Wood magazine (possibly March,'07). The article suggested that aromatic cedar gives off a substance similar to turpentine that would soften oil based finishes which you don't want to use on the insides of any case or box that will enclose clothes or cloth anyway due to odor issues. The article recommended no finish on the inside of a blanket chest. But shellac is alcohol based and doesn't have disagreeable odor problems. The article was silent about shellac...so maybe someone knows about this or an experiment with shellac and terpentine/ aromatic cedar is in order. Best of luck. Please post you're findings.

Re: Finish Failure

#4

What I did

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Steve,

I built a cedar chest for my wife and fortunately had been aware of applying oil based poly to the interior. I felt strongly that the solid maple top should have finish applied to inside and outside surfaces to achieve/maintain equilibrium. I have always favored oil based poly as a finish and applied that only to the chest's exterior. The inside top was sealed/finished with a water based poly, a couple coats. No sticky surface. I pinned cedar to the finished inside top so the entire space is cedar lined. No problems at all with stability of the top, or any stickiness of the finish. The only odor is of cedar. Shop Shot 746

George

Re: Finish Failure

#5

When I refinished my Mother's

Don henthorn

>old cedar chest It had never been finished on the inside. I figured that if it had done that well for about 90 years I would just stick with the program. I sanded it to restore the color and odor and that is the way it will stay for the next 90 years, I hope.