Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Opinions on Doug Fir please

Posts

Opinions on Doug Fir please

#1

Opinions on Doug Fir please

Steve Yakoban

>We are going to change all of our hollow core interior doors to 3 panel shaker doors with simple square sticking. The lumber yard I want to use can offer either doug fir or maple. The maple is double the cost and out of our budget. Besides, the doors are to be painted white so aesthetically the maple gains nothing. However, I'm concerned with the doug fir being a soft wood and damaging easily. Is that something I should worry about or will it be fine? I figure the square sticking means that those square corners are most vulnerable to damage. Are there different doug fir species and is that even relevant?

All opinions are welcome...

Thanks guys!

Re: Opinions on Doug Fir please

#2

Doug fir is stout stuff and makes a great door

Forrest Addy

>Doug fir is stout stuff and makes a great panel door. It's far more weather resistant than maple and as a painted door interior or exterior it would be my material of choice. Careful prep is required for a painted door or the grain will telegraph through.

Re: Opinions on Doug Fir please

#3

Re: Opinions on Doug Fir please

Jesse in New Mexico

>All our doors, interior and exterior are Doug Fir. I'm very happy with them - very stable, very attractive. It would be a shame to paint them, though.

Re: Opinions on Doug Fir please

#4

Re: Painted doors

Dave Mount

>Just my opinion, but if these doors are to be painted, I see no reason to use either maple or fir. There are lots of engineered materials that will make a more stable door than any solid wood door, and if it is to be painted, what's the difference? It seems to me a shame to put high quality solid wood doors under paint.

If maple and fir are all your lumberyard offers, you need to do more shopping around. A decent yard should be able to get all kinds of door styles and materials. And if it is quality you are concerned about (i.e., that many engineered doors found in home centers are also inexpensively made), do more shopping -- there are some very high end doors (ball bearing hinges, etc.) made from engineered material for painted apps. You can also get doors that have factory pigment finishes on them that are way more durable that what you can apply at home on an unfinished door.

Bottom line, for less money you can get the same heft, greater stability, and a better finish in a door made from an engineered material.

My $0.02,

Dave

Re: Opinions on Doug Fir please

#5

Re: Painted doors

Steve Yakoban

>Most of the yards here in NJ buy from the same distributor so this was an unusual exception. Can you suggest any brand of engineered door or source for me to find/research them?

Re: Opinions on Doug Fir please

#6

Ellis Walentine

Paint grade

Ellis Walentine

>I live in PA and around here we tend to use poplar for paint-grade millwork. It is cheap, plentiful, easy to work, harder than softwoods and it has a nice mild grain that sands up nicely and takes paint well, without problems such as telegraphing grain and pitch, both of which are potential problems with painted Douglas fir. So my vote would be for poplar if you plan to paint.

Douglas fir is a handsome wood, mainly if quartersawn or riftsawn. Its bold, straight grain can be used as a design element in all sorts of furniture and casework. It does tend to be somewhat brittle, though, so edges would want to be eased to prevent breakage in the event of impact. Despite the fact that the Shakers didn't have access to Douglas fir and tended to prefer close-grain, diffuse-porous woods like white pine, cherry and maple -- in keeping with their preference for simplicity -- Doug fir would make very nice doors, but it isn't worth it if you intend to paint. Also, make sure you get kiln dried lumber if you plan to use Doug fir, as otherwise you could have some issues with pitch bleeding out of the wood and wrecking your paint job.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Opinions on Doug Fir please

#7

Poplar frames; MDF panels

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: Opinions on Doug Fir please

#8

Re: Painted doors *LINK*

Dave Mount

>Googling will get you a long way. An example of what turned up is linked below (caveat -- I've no experience with this particular brand, they are just supplying something like what you are asking about).

I'd also go to a specialty window and door supplier if there's one in your area. That's a good way to get a feel for the broader range of what's available, and to see examples. Buying doors without seeing a sample is dicey. I've seen great looking MDF doors, and I've seen others that don't look so good.

Good luck,

Dave


Wausau paint grade flat panel doors