Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Powering 3PH from 1PH question, Forrest or anyone.

Posts

Powering 3PH from 1PH question, Forrest or anyone.

#1

Powering 3PH from 1PH question, Forrest or anyone.

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi all,

I got my big radial arm saw today. It's a Dewalt 14" 3HP, 3PH. Now I have to make it run from single phase power. I have Rick C's plans for static and rotary convertors. I'm also getting ready to hunt up Surplus Center and see what it might cost for a VFD for the 3HP motor.

However, I have a VFD on the 2HP motor on my lathe. I vaguely remember Forrest talking about using a lower rated drive to operate a bigger motor. Something about tweaking the parameters on the drive.

Since I need to use this saw yesterday, I'm wondering whether I could just hook up the VFD that I have on hand, make some necessary adjustments to the programming, and use it to get usable power from the motor?

I'm headed to Search and the Archives next to see what I can find, but I wanted to post this as early as possible since I would like to be using this saw by Tuesday.

Thanks,

Gary

Re: Powering 3PH from 1PH question, Forrest or anyone.

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Depends on startup amp draw

Jim in Burlington On

>Depends on the amp draw at startup of the saw. If you overcurrent the VFD it will simply trip of blow a fuse first. I'd give it a try.

Re: Powering 3PH from 1PH question, Forrest or anyone.

#3

Re: Powering 3PH from 1PH question, Forrest or any

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>If the maximum amp load rating of the VFD is more than the FLA (full load amps) of the motor it should work. This will require programming of the actual trip current of the VFD for the new motor.

Bill in WNC mountains

Re: Powering 3PH from 1PH question, Forrest or anyone.

#4

Re: Powering 3PH from 1PH question, Forrest or any

Rick Christopherson

>In a pinch, you can probably get your 2-hp VFD to run a 3-hp motor by programming the VFD to limit the startup current. However, just be careful that you didn't already de-rate the VFD if it was rated for 3-phase input and you are giving it single-phase power. This is typical with VFD's in the 2-3 hp range, and an absolute above this range.

That being said, there is also a possibility that your 3 hp RAS is only 1-1/2 hp actual. I don't remember if you said DeWalt or Delta, but I do know that DeWalt 3hp RAS's are overrated, and actually only draw 1-1/2 to 2 hp. In any case, it is really a moot point. The VFD will protect itself, so if the VFD doesn't like the size of the motor, it will just shut down.

===================

If your RAS is truely a 3-hp motor, then I do not recommend using an undersized VFD as a permanent driver for the saw. You can do this as a temporary fix, but running it permanently is risking frying the VFD outputs. There is a difference between "getting something to work" and making it "work long-term".

====================

Oh, by the way, be careful about using the VFD's braking function with a blade this large. The momentum of the blade will loosen the arbor nut and the blade will loosen and freewheel if the braking function is set too high.

Re: Powering 3PH from 1PH question, Forrest or anyone.

#5

Re: Powering 3PH from 1PH question, Forrest or any

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Thanks guys,

I need to start taking the lathe apart anyway so that I can move it down to the store. I'll pull the VFD first and see what it actually is.

By the way, the motor on the RAS is rated for 8 Amps at 208/220V and 4 amps at 440V, so 1660 Watts. What is the conversion number for HP?

I just need to use it for about a day cutting primarily 2" and 3" turning blanks. I might cut a 4" piece or two. Hopefully I can do it without damaging the VFD. I don't see any other way to have a controller available that soon.

Thanks much for the guidance,

Gary

Re: Powering 3PH from 1PH question, Forrest or anyone.

#6

Never heard of "up-rating" an AFD..... *LINK*

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>I think you may have misunderstood Forrest or whoever gave you that advice. I've never heard of using a smaller rated AFD to power a larger rated 3-phase motor. In fact, it's generally accepted to be just the opposite. You need to derate an AFD from 25-50% when powering it from single phase, depending on the load severity.

The link below will take you to the manual for a Series 11 Baldor AFD, 1-5 HP range. Scroll down to page 6 to see the derating table for use on single phase input. Warning - this is a 4.5 meg pdf file.

I may be wrong, but I don't think you want to use a smaller AFD than your motor. If there's an acceptable reason to do so, I'd like to hear the details.


Baldor Series 11 AFD Manual

Re: Powering 3PH from 1PH question, Forrest or anyone.

#7

Three phase is a litle trickier than single

Forrest Addy

>Three phase is a litle trickier than single to calculate wattage from motor name plate data. If the motor is three phase and rated 8 full load Amps at 230 Volts you first have to multiply the current by a conversion factor of 1.78 (square root of 3) before you calculate watts (14.24 x 230 = 3300 Watts roughly.

Calculated Watts doesn't give you much as a guide for induction motor HP. You sure can't figure using 746 Watts per HP because that conversion presumes 100% conversion efficiency.

Induction motor HP is a measure of mechanical power (a function of shaft torque and RPM); Watts is a measure of electrical input. In between is the motor's efficiency and a something called "power factor."

Power factor is not a "loss" pe se. It's a term for the electical behavior of an induction motor's where the motor's induction displaces the sine wave of the Amps from that of the Volts by so many degrees. Thus induction motors draw more apparent Amps that their DC counterparts but as soon as the power factor is cranked in they're about equivalent in converions performance. The power factor of a fully loaded induction motor is about 80 (convention multiples the cosine of angular displacement of the Volts and current by 100.)

The best way to determine the HP of a mystery motor is to compare it to ratings of comparable motors in a motor catalog. 8 full load Amps at 230 Volts three phase is right in the ball park for a 3 HP 1750 RPM motor according to my Granger catalog. Don't try to read too much in these comparisons. Suffice it to say your RAS motor most likely an honest 3 HP.

Re: Powering 3PH from 1PH question, Forrest or anyone.

#8

It's not reccommended but it is a useful expedient

Forrest Addy

>It's not reccommended but it is a useful expedient. It works if the VFD parameters are tweaked to optimise motor performance. Naturally you won't get 3 HP performance from a 3 HP motor connected to a 2 HP VFD. However, you can make the motor run and you can draw useful mechanical power from it to the limitations of the VFD.

It's a shade tree technique, not something any reputable manufacturer or EE would reccommend. I know EE's who scoff in outrage at the suggestion of home brew rotary phase converters yet lots of home shops run three phase equipment on single phase.

Re: Powering 3PH from 1PH question, Forrest or anyone.

#9

Re: It's not reccommended but it is a useful exped

Dan Donaldson

>Interesting comment about the EE's scoffing at some of the home brew stuff. I am a EE and in another life, I used to spend a lot of time in the assembly plant. A lot of the engineers would go there and think that they were the best thing that ever happened to the plant for fixing problems. Dumb!! The first thing that I usually did was go to the area where the techs were doing the repairs, look at the scrap pile of parts they were replacing and talk to them about what they were seeing. After a couple of months of production, they would know more about the weaknesses of the design than the engineer that designed it would ever know. They might not know the deep theory behind what they were finding, but they sure knew how to fix it and what things were problematic.