>Not sure where to look for information on this issue, so I figured there's folks far smarter than I in here that may know the answer. So here's my issue: I've found photos of a piece of studio furniture that was designed in the '60s and is still sold today(at least in Europe). I'd like to replicate it(with a few "tweaks") for myself and perhaps to sell on the craft show circuit. Is there any legalities I should be aware of? Thank you all in advance for sharing your knowledge!
>This question has come up many times over the years, both online and in print publications. Usually it involves people wanting to make and sell copies of designs that have been published in print. When I was a magazine editor, I asked our corporate legal eagles about the legal implications of knocking off published projects for personal gain. Essentially, the answer was that we (nor the author) couldn't do much about it, as the implication of providing exact measurements and instructions was that we specifically intended for readers to make the piece. The fuzzy part is that we hoped that people would make the piece for their own personal use or as a gift -- not for sale -- but we couldn't stop someone from doing that if they had no moral qualms about it.
The moral dilemma is further complicated by questions of whether a designer/author was making this piece commercially, in which case a knockoff offered for sale would be in direct competition with the originator. The upshot of that is that the originator should have kept the design to him/herself if they didn't want people to compete.
In the matter of a piece of studio furniture that has not been detailed in a how-to article, you are running a more significant risk if you decide to make it for sale, especially if that piece is still in production. If you don't mind being confrontational about it, you may still have the legal high ground, but not necessarily. A truly viable production piece may well be protected by one or more design patents. These are admittedly weak, though, and changing even a slight detail of the appearance or construction may be adequate defense if the manufacturer comes after you. If you don't think your commercial efforts would constitute significant competition for the vested owner of the design -- or even if you do -- you might want to send them a formal request for permission to reproduce their designs.
Another bit of fuzz here is the question of just when a design becomes part of the public domain. Is it at the instant it is shown publicly, or at some time in the future? Cabinetmakers have been reproducing important period pieces for hundreds of years as a stock in trade.
Other than a design or mechanical patent, I don't think that there is any protection for a furniture design. The simple fact that someone created it first doesn't constitute a copyright, as it does with written words. This is a perennial issue with the people at the top of the woodturning community, such as John Jordan and David Ellsworth and others, who decry the "plagiarism" of a generation of turners who are capitalizing on design styles and motifs that went before. But aside from righteous indignation and a sense of moral rectitude, I'm not sure there's much they can do about it.
I'll be interested to hear what our lawyer visitors have to say. Am I right about this? Are there other concerns? What about copyright?
>I think the answer lies in how extensive the "tweaks" to the design are. Also if the materials, internal framing and other methods of construction aren't identical, I'm not sure there is much reason to worry.
>If it is under copyright protection, then it is protected for a period of time under the Berne convention - but I have no idea for how long. For books and music it is for the life of the author plus a certain amount of time. For photographs and the like it is less (25 years or so). I don't know about other "works of art" such as furniture.
>Offhand, I'd say that the mere fact that you would be working from photos of the piece and not from detailed dimensioned plans would pretty much guarantee that whatever you might make would not be a duplicate even without your "tweaks". You will not know the dimensions, internal structure, joinery, etc so the possibility of making anything approaching a copy is pretty much nil even if you really wanted to.
Being an attorney, I can tell you, with all due respect to Ellis and the other responders, not to rely upon the opinions of anyone here. I can say that even though I am precluded from giving legal opinions or advice on this or any other internet forum, on top of which I wouldn't know my ankle from my elbow about this area of the law.
The field of intellectual property (copyrights, patents, etc.) is a body of the statutes and court decisions that is enique unto itself and may change somewhat from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. If you're going to use someone else's design for a commercial venture, consult an attorney in your area who knows the law that will apply to your situation, get the opinion in writing, and figure the cost into your pricing of whatever item you make and sell.
>I just want to toss this out. In my opinion patents and copyrights and trade marks protect primarily through intimidation. Real protection is only available to those rights-holders who have sufficiently deep pockets to mount a sustained defense of the right.
Here's a real-world anecdote that may have some resonance here.
A friend of mine designed and patented a woodworking gizmo, then began manufacturing and selling it. At some point, a power-tool manufacturer�Big Company�started selling a gizmo very much like his, infringing, he felt, on his patent. So he talked to an executive of the company, a fellow he knew. My friend told me this guy simply said, "I'm really sorry. The lawyers looked at it and said, 'Walk on him.'" In other words, this company was daring him to take them to court to defend his patent. And its bet was that he didn't have sufficiently deep pockets to follow through to the bitter end.
And he didn't.
On the other hand--the cleaner hand--why not try to contact the designer of the piece and sound him or her out on what you'd like to do? Perhaps you could get the designer's approval, even their help in getting the piece dimensioned and constructed correctly. Person might say no, might want a royalty, might not care one way or the other. You never know.
>Thank you all for some "chewy" food for thought! Mark and Bill, that's the stuff I really needed to hear outside my own head. I'm a part-time lurker at best, but I sure do appreciate a forum such as this!
>I ran into this issue constantly licensing, building and selling internationally original puzzle designs.
The cold fact is this - all the legal protection in the world only gives you the right to seek legal redress against plagiarism. It doesn't stop anyone.
Another cold fact is the patent database is viewed as a resource for free designs. File a design and every company in the world gets to take a shot at you.
Finally, when you do get ripped off (all good designs get ripped off) the best approach is to use the threat of legal action to convert the offender into a licensee. If they don't convert then you can make the design worthless the way Stewart Coffin did for the Hexstix puzzle - he published the design in every publication possible and gave everyone in the world full rights to manufacture and sell it royalty free. Hundreds of knockoffs immediately hit the market and the big toy company stopped making it.
I found that asking a designer for permission got me the rights very, very cheaply. It also got me the goodwill of the world's puzzle community and I became the recommended seller for the designs. The rip-offs were harshly criticized in public and the companies were blacklisted.
My advice - go ask. I think you'll be pleasantly surprised.
>Can't really answer the question, but all the major companies now use a tactic called "benchmarking". This is just a fancy word for taking the competition's manufactured part and examining it closely so you can copy it (with those minor changes the Patent attorneys say make it legal). The "benchmarking" is part of every consulting program I have seen used in manufacturing. When I designed a machine that did a process, tested or automated assembly it was never patented. These were considered "Proprietary", no photo's were allowed to be taken and in some cases, the machines were covered before non-employees were allowed to tour the plant. This is done as any machine "patented" can be copied and it is almost impossible to prevent. I agree with Steve, it would be best to ask and I consider it the ethical thing to do. In most cases, knowing the product would be almost impossible to protect they will grant you the rights without large expense.