Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

Posts

5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#1

JL

5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

JL

>When do you really need a 5 hp cabinet saw as opposed to a 3 hp? I've been sawing for many years on my old Sears table saw. It has a 13+ amp motor at 120 V (call it a 1 hp+ motor). I've managed to cut 8/4 oak, maple, cherry, etc. on it (though it did complain).

I have a chance to get either a 3 hp or 5 hp cabinet saw (if the LOML agrees). The 5 hp would cost maybe $1800 and the 3 hp would cost maybe $ 1250. The physical size would be the same, though the weights would be different. The depth of cut for a 10" is still going to be the same (3+") on both saws.

So should I try for the 5 hp, or go for the 3 hp? TIA.

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#2

EASY answer

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>If the 5-HP is $1800 and the 3HP is $1250 and everything else is equal..... the answer is easy.....

3HP and keep the $550 for something else. You can get a whole lot with $550.

The 5HP is 50% more money for something I can't see you needing.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#3

I agree...

Mark Harrison - Brisbane, Australia

>I have been ripping and preparing stock for a project using Australian hardwoods for the past week (holiday in the shop :-) on my PM2000 which is a 3HP saw. It hasn't complained and this stuff makes rock maple look like poplar!

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#4

Rick L

Re: 3 hp...

Rick L

>is all you need. For years only 3 hp was all that was available. % hp would be for 24 hr factory usage and the 5 hp was relatively new to the industry. Plus if you get a kick back you would be safer with a 3 hp.

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#5

Re: 3 hp...

Mark Harrison - Brisbane, Australia

>A kickback from a 3HP saw still hurts. DAMHIKT!

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#6

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

David Sparks

>I have a 3 hp Powermatic model 66. I've used it to cut 2" thick hard maple with no trouble. I think using a good blade is almost as important as the horsepower of your saw. In my case, if I need to cut anything really thick I'll use my bandsaw. The only thing I wish I had done differently in my saw purchase is I should have bought a 50" extension table instead of a 30" one.

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#7

Also Agree

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>My 3hp Uni has never balked at anything I have sent through it. The difference in cost would buy you a JessEm Master Slide for the saw and you would be set!

Tom

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#8

Here's what 5 HP will do for you:

Forrest Addy

>Here's what 5 HP will do for you: it lets you push to stock with about 50 lb to feed it through the saw not counting stock pinch from locked in stress. In free cutting materials that boils down to a feed rate of a fast walk in 14/4 free cutting materials like poplar and proportionately slower in harder lumber.

Most people can't push with 50 lb of force at a fast walk for more than a few minutes. Most people don't have thick lumber to rip in quantity. Unless you want to rip say 1000 linear feet of 8/4 lumber using a stock feeder set at 250 fet per minute for less than an hour a day, a 5 HP saw would be hood choice. The extra power will let the feeder bulldoze right through knots and pinches. It's most likely a waste in a home shop or a commercial cabinet or furniture shop.

A 5 HP would be a saw used in a production setting where the clock was ticking and you couldn't afford real production woodworking equipment like a gang ripsaw with a track feed.

It's probably not economical to purchase an option you use less than 0.1% of the time if it increases the purchase price by 20%.

Some years ago, I ripped 28/4 (that's 7" and thicker) red maple in quantity on my 1/1/2 HP saw without much difficulty. I ripped one side then flipped the material and ripped the other. Sometimes there was a little remaining I had to cut with a hand saw. Some of it was pretty wild and wanted to pinch but I wedged the kerf and got through it without much difficulty. That's the one time I wished I had 3 HP.

From that I have to conclude that 1 1/2 HP is plenty of cutting power capable of ripping without hesitation 95% of the material your saw will accept. 3 HP puts you into 99th percentile territory. 5 HP gives you only bragging rights.

So what's imporant to you?

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#9

Re: Here's what 5 HP will do for you:

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I agree with Forrest, the only other thing the additional HP will do is allow you to keep cutting when the blade becomes dull. This is definitely not an issue in a home or small shop as the cut quality also suffers. However if you are running the saw in a commercial ripping operation, it may have some payback to allow you to complete the work shift (or week) prior to changing / sharpening the blade. As the blade sharpening intervals are increased, the sharpening costs will go down slightly. None of this has any real effect on a small shop. I have a 3 hp Unisaw - never have wished I opted for a 5 HP. The cost differential would have been much smaller for me as I purchased new. (Think it was only $100 ~ $200 more for the 5 hp). The 5 HP also required larger wiring / circuit size which may be detrimental in many small shops.

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#10

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

Jesse in New Mexico

>Ditto. I routinely cu 12/4 on my 3 HP unisaw with no problem. I'm a fool for tools, but never really felt the need for 5 HP...

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#11

I have to Agree....

Barry Irby

>I would not give the 5 hp a minute's thought. I have a 2 hp contractor's saw that I have been using for 36 years. I fairly routinely resaw pieces from both sides and then cut out what's left on the band saw. This is with a single belt driving it. A Unisaw with 3 hp and a double or triple (?) belt will deliver even more power to the blade. Anymore power would be wasted. Most of it is wasted now. Save the bucks and get a really excellent blade or two. (I would tell you how much I like my Forrest WW2, but I won't mention it, to save all the grief.)

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#12

Re: EASY answer

Chuck Kettler Greenwood IN

>It is easy. If you can imagine having kickback with a 1.5 HP, imagine what a 5 HP will give you. In 13 years of woodworking I have had on kickback. Tossed a piece of poplar through a piece of schedule 40 PVC pipe and 1/2" drywall. Thankfully Bill Tindall always taught me to stand to the side when at the saw so I was just an excited spectator. Go for the 3 HP and enjoy.

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#13

JL

Thanks all...

JL

>now for the "tough" part. "Sweetie, I really need a 3 hp cabinet saw. It will make my sawing so much easier." Can anyone think of some really good excuses... I'm mean reasons :).

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#14

Rookie.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>“Sweety, it's time for me to get a cabinet saw. I'd like a 5HP saw, but if I get a 3HP saw I can save several hundred dollars.”

Always use the word “sale/save” in a conversation with a woman and it'll make the project 82% easier to sell.

Another thing that helps is to mention how much you paid for your (woefully inadequate) Sears saw and divide that by the number of years you've had it and mention that you've been able to do a lot of work/get a lot of enjoyment out of it for only $22.57 per year. It doesn't owe you a thing.

Also include that you'll get a lot of life out of the new saw and that the annual vigarish will eventually get to where the Sears saw was (when you're 105) and it keeps you out of the taverns.

Rod

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#15

My easy answer was easy

M. McNamee

>The 5HP model was $100 cheaper than the 3HP model! The 5HP had been in stock too long and they needed to get rid of it. But that 5HP motor is 220v only.

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#16

Is the 5 hp cost prohibitive ?

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>If not then go for it.

If it is, I see no advantage to buying a 5 over a 3.....unless you are in a "pro" atmosphere.

A 3 hp will be plenty IMHO.

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#17

Just tell her like it is!

Joe Pack

>Say, "Sweetheart, I'm buying a new table saw because I WANT one, I DESERVE one, and I'm going to HAVE one! Got that???" Say it loudly, and say it like you are the BOSS!!!

Then go inside, get on your knees and beg like most of the rest of us do.

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#18

Re: My easy answer was easy

Sawdust B Gone!

>FWIW,

The 3hp model is also 220V only!

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#19

Policitally incorrect gov't answer

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I know we're not supposed to talk politics here, but forgive me.......

Take look at you last income tax return. Look at how much money you gave to the government last year.

Now think about how much you like the government. Better yet, think about how much you like the IRS. Now look at the amount of money you gave them last year.

Now look at the cost of a good tablesaw.

Now look at yourself in the mirror.

How much did you give the IRS last year? How much? How much did you give them last year?

Look at yourself again. Think about the governnment. Think about politicians. Think about the IRS.

Look at yourself again.

Now, tell me: who do you like better?

And who's getting the larger portion of your money?

Again, how much did you give the IRS last year?

Quickly look at yourself and think or the IRS.

Now go and spend some money on the one you like more.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: 5 hp versus 3 hp cabinet saw?

#20

Here's one...

HC Sakman

>"This saw will take my woodworking to a new level, honey."

How's that sound?

Chico...