Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Time for a bigger bandsaw - which one?

Posts

Time for a bigger bandsaw - which one?

#1

Time for a bigger bandsaw - which one?

Kris Lasure

>I've outgrown my current 14" bandsaw for resaw work and would like to have one with at least 16" resaw capacity. I don't want to add a riser block to the Delta as I'm going to keep it around with a 1/4" blade for scroll type work.

I'm between either the Mini Max MM16 or Laguna LT16. Anyone out there have either of these and could offer any opinions?

Thanks

kl

Re: Time for a bigger bandsaw - which one?

#2

Couple of questions...

doug f, san clemente, ca

>1. What kind of budget are you thinking about? The more information, the better your responses will be.

2. Do you really want a 16" resaw capacity? That's a pretty hefty saw unless you're in this professionally.

Let us know.

Doug

Re: Time for a bigger bandsaw - which one?

#3

Re: Time for a bigger bandsaw - which one?

Ted Wong

>If the 16" Laguna is anything like the 14" Laguna it should be a pretty good saw. Fine Woodworking gave it high marks in a recent review. And the ceramic guides are supposedly a nice feature.

Re: Time for a bigger bandsaw - which one?

#4

Re: My choice - MM-16

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have the MM 16. I went through the same kind of deliberations you are going through now. I went to the tool show at Indy, looked at the saw's there - Delta 20" (very weak trunnion - easy to wobble table), Jet (ok saw, less capacity, not MM quality), Laguna (not impressed with the ridigity - high priced, less capacity, small motor, from reports, customer support poor), Grizzly ( decent saw -similar to Jet ). Steel City, (nothing in the 16" resaw range otherwise decent saw), Powematic (priced fairly high - had to look at 20" to approach re-saw capacity of MM 16 otherwise nice saw). I researched the web sites, looked at everyone's opinions. After narrowing it down to the MM16 or Laguna, I did more research. The Laguna, doesn't have the capacity of the MiniMax until you get into a bigger saw - and dollars. Also I found a lot of discussion about the lack of customer support for the Laguna. As a retired manufacturing / quality engineer, I had looked at the construction of the MM-16 and was quite impressed. The trunnion is excellent, table is flat, motor is more powerful than any I have seen on the market in a saw this size (4.8 hp.), full 16" re-saw capacity, the adjustments are easy to get at and use, euro style guides which are a breeze to adjust. mobile base is included, frame is extremely well designed etc. The MM-16 is on sale right now for $2295 + shipping. The sale's rep has called me and emailed me several times after I purchased the machine to see if I had any problems - I haven't but it is sure nice to see they don't forget their customers after the sale. I purchased a couple of the Woodslicer blades from Highland hardware (1/2 & 3/4). I have re-sawn white oak - about 8-10" - saw doesn't even sound like I loaded it. tracking is excellent. The only thing I didn't like is the On / Off switch design, although it has worked fine, I just don't like the design. It would be easy to change if I desire - after the warranty is expired. I have no affiliation with Mini Max, just a very satisfied customer. By the way the MM16 will run 1/4" blades so may want to eliminate the Delta for space.

Re: Time for a bigger bandsaw - which one?

#5

Re: Time for a bigger bandsaw - which one?

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>The Laguna LT16 has a resaw capacity of 12"...not 16". Those numbers can fool you. Check that with any saw you look at. I had an LT16 and while it is a step up from the Delta 14" type saws I was disappointed by some of the light duty construction. The trunions were just sheet steel and I found the blade guide post to wobble a lot. I upgraded the saw to the Laguna HD16. It is an ACM saw (the actual maker) and is much more substantial. Cast iron trunnions, heavier duty table and a much better guide post. Also extra horsepower which really helps for resaw.

Just 2 cents

Tom

Re: Time for a bigger bandsaw - which one?

#6

Re: Time for a bigger bandsaw - which one?

Kris Lasure

>Thanks for the replies so far. Yeah, 16" may sound like a bit much, but I have some nice wide boards that could use some resawing and I'm always running across timbers that can be cut up into nice lumber and veneer. I'll definitely use the larger capacity. Heck, I'd even like to upgrade my DJ-20 to a wider jointer, but that's for another year.

The two saws I mentioned are well within my budget and as Larry did, I plan on hitting the Indy show in January to hopefully make my final decision. Just waiting for that bonus check at the end of the year!

I'm kinda like Tim "The Tool Man" Taylor when it comes to power tools...more power!!

Re: Time for a bigger bandsaw - which one?

#7

Re: Time for a bigger bandsaw - which one?

doug f, san clemente, ca

>Kris - sounds like you're going in the right direction. Look at several saws if you can and get a hands-on demonstration of the resaw capabilities if possible. It's amazing how two bandsaws that LOOK identical can FEEL much different.

One that I think you would find interesting is the Agazzani (Eagle Tools, Los Angeles.) I have the 18" and love it and the outstanding customer service that Jesse Barragan provides. Tons of power, 12+" of resaw capacity, built like a brick &%$#house. Certainly in the same class as the MiniMax and Laguna, if not a cut above. The 24" has your required resaw capacity for a bit more money.

Have fun at the show.

Doug

Re: Time for a bigger bandsaw - which one?

#8

Re: My choice - MM-16

Bob Sobieck

>Ditto, I got the MM16 3 years ago. It's the highest quality power tool I own and wish it would have been my first. I avoid the table saw, this thing is a joy.

Only one minor problem I had - my fault I detensioned the blade one day and accidentially started it in this state. The plastic blade gaurd got ruined but that's it.

I like to resaw and have no regrets.

I am sort of intrigued by the cool blocks, thinking I could really do a thin blade.

Bob

Re: Time for a bigger bandsaw - which one?

#9

Ellis Walentine

More recent Laguna models...

Ellis Walentine

>... have the same resaw capacity as their nominal size. Earlier ones didn't. I don't know if this pertains to both light and heavy duty saws.

Ellis

Re: Time for a bigger bandsaw - which one?

#10

Go bigger?

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>If I was going to REPLACE my 14" bandsaw with something larger, I'd probably go with a 16" or 18".

But if I was going to keep my 14" like you said you were, and get a SEcOND bandsaw, then I think I'd go for soemthing even bigger, like a 20" or more.

Just seems that if you're going to have one you'd want a medium size, but if you going to have two, one small and one large seems to make more sense thatn one small and one medium.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Time for a bigger bandsaw - which one?

#11

Re: More recent Laguna models...

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>That figures! They always improve things AFTER I buy them!! D'oh!! ;-)

Tom