Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Exhausting a DC Outside

Posts

Exhausting a DC Outside

#1

Exhausting a DC Outside

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Greetings all

I have an Oneida Gorilla cyclone. I am working on rebuilding my dust collection system, and I have the opportunity to exhaust the thing to the outside of the shop. This means less room taken up in the shop, no more having to empty a filter, etc. I am not concerned about any heat loss, since:

a) my shop is heated with radiant heat

b) the DC is used for short periods of time

c) I have plenty of natural insulation

Has anyone here done this? If so, did you buy or build any special fittings? I am concerned mainly about animals trying to make a nest in the ductwork or the cyclone. Noise is not an issue.

Thanks.

Bill

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#2

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

jeff

>Bill

No problem with exhausting outside.

I never had problems with bugs or animals.

I don't do it now, as I need to keep heat and air in the shop.

You don't really need anything special, but some 1/4 mesh on the duct output should keep mice out.

Jeff

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#3

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

albertabob

>Put a "blast gate" in the wall on the shop side.

Don't forget to open and close it.

Bob

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#4

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Jesse in New Mexico

>And you will need to provide for "make up" air to replace the exhausted air, though a small vent should probably do the trick.

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#5

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Jim Swank

>The make-up air source should have a furnace type filter as a minimum. In cold weather it should probably only be open with the DC running. Without a filtered make-up, you'll pull air and dust in through every crock nook and cranny. With it, the shop will stay a bit cleaner.

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#6

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Thanks for the responses guys. I already have mice in the shop, although I trap them from time to time (worthless cats!) But I do not need to grind them into mouseburger so a screen will be a good idea.

Makeup air? If you guys saw my shop, you would understand that there is no need for a special inlet for makeup air! I already have a multitude of very small inlets strategically placed all about the shop which should prove to be more than adequate.

Bill

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#7

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>My neighbor runs his Oneida this way. Exhaust is through a rectangular vent in the top plate, up under the roof overhang. Noise is pretty minimal, compared to the other machines he runs. If I'm in my front yard, and not runnning ANYTHING, I can hear it across the street, although it's not annoying. We get more street noise. And in California, almost all of the work is done with the garage door open.

He just redid everything in there, as he's assembling a large ShopBot outfit...

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#8

Ellis Walentine

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Ellis Walentine

>That's what we did, Bill. We had a "dust house" behind the barn that our blower blew everything into. It had an external door so we could back a pickup in and shovel the dust out. We never had rodent barriers, or rodents for that matter. If they wanted to come in, there were more direct ways.

Sounds like your shop is a lot like ours. No makeup air worries.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#9

Are you sure you don't want a return?

Brian in Sandusky, OH

>For all the work involved to vent outside, I would seriously consider routing the exaust back into the shop. It would only be a small extra step in the scope of the whole project.

A good DC will pull a lot of air. You will be losing a lot of heat.

You mentioned radiant heat. I think that his would be more reason to return the air. Radiant heat would take longer to return the heat to the shop, rather than a forced furnace, I would think.

Then again, I'm only surmising. My DC is all inside, and I have no experience with this...just thinking out loud. I'm no expert.

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#10

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Barry Irby

>Bill, I have a small shop, a one car garage in my basement. I put my DC out side in the small closet. It's not a cyclone, but one of those 1300 CFM two bag deals. My makeup air is the cat door.

Works well. Keeps the noise outside, the dust is outside, and it does not rob a lot of heat or AC. Most of the heat and AC are "stored" in the mass of the stuff like tools and timbers. Removing and replacing the air makes surprisingly little difference. (I have wondered what the air in my shop weighs and how many BTU's it takes to reheat or recool it after the DC shuts down. Not much.) The only time I notice the loss of heat or cool is if I run a machine a long time early in the day before either the heat or AC has a chance to Thermally "load" the solid surfaces. Later in the day, the recovery is quick.

The good thing about having the DC outside is that once it captures something, Its outside. Changing the bag is messy sometimes and that mess would be in the shop if the DC weren't outside. Also, the bag is closer to the compost pile and I don't have to roll it through the shop to get it out.

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#11

JL

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

JL

>I put mine inside my basement shop as I didn't want to have a very large return. You could just put the filtered portion of your Gorilla inside your shop, that way you wouldn't have to worry about a return.

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#12

I built the Y2k outhouse for my cyclone!

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>I started in Sept. of '99 and finished it in Jan. 2000 and it has worked well ever since. It's not as quiet as I would have liked it, but my neighbors, whose house is a whopping 14' away, don't complain as long as I don't run the blower past 9:30pm-10:00pm. Barb S. checked this out and she kind of liked it. I modeled it after the WoodCentral box I used to spend so much time in that I had the wine and beer concession. Uh, I let that lapse by the way....


img

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#13

Inside of cyclone outhouse

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>Here is a shot of the inside showing an early model Oneida cyclone mated to a Griz. 2hp dust collector blower. I had to make a plywood adaptor to get this to work. As you can see I just duct the exhaust into the shed and I have plenty of venting for it. I didn't duct straight outside due to concerns for my close neighbors. The inside of the shed gets dusty but it's manageble.

I use an air activated switch, from a pool supply, to remotely turn on and off the blower. I chose this method instead of a Lone Ranger remote setup because I didn't want to deal with replacing batteries all of the time, and my garage shop isn't that big that I can't walk to the wall mounted air button.


img

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

#14

Re: Exhausting a DC Outside

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Thanks everyone!

The filter is going, and the exhaust is going outside. One of the reasons for this is ease of maintenance, but the other is gaining just a little more room in the shop. I am not worried about makeup air, getting cold (or hot) or anything to do with the air. I have a radiant heater than can more than make up for any heat loss in the winter, and if it gets too hot in the summer, I retire to the pool! Eddie, I would love to do an exterior building like yours for the whole thing, and include the compressor as well, but no room is available for that. I already have a building with a moon on the door, but it is being used for its intended purposes! Besides, it is too far from the shop anyway. Noise and dust are non issues. If it were not for the shop being right up on the road, I would be able to sell the cyclone and put a huge squirrel cage in to blow shavings and all out into the field. Maybe for the next shop...

Bill