Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

Posts

Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

#1

Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

Greg Haugen

>I'm looking for opinions, or facts if you have them, on the cost effectiveness of palm sanders. I currently have a Bosch 5" (8 hole) Round Palm Sander. I'm debating about its cost effectiveness compared to a 1/4 sheet square palm sander. I've been a woodworker all of my life. I know "not all sandpaper is created equally." I've been using Norton 3X in sheet form and I'm highly impressed. When I went to get some disks for the sander I almost hit the floor when I saw a pack of 10 of Nort. 3X 5" disks was $10 roughly. Now I've been buying sleeves of 20 sheets of Nort. 3X for the same price. Now, doing basic math on a 1/4 sheet sander I'd get 80 "squares" out of those 20 sheets for the same $10. 10 compared to 80, no brainer.

Now with the difference in "paper" price established. The question is, Are the round sanders "superior" to the 1/4 sheet sanders? IF they are, is it enough to over look the previous cost comparison?? Yes, I know "the round sanders spin." Does that make that big of a difference?? The 1/4 sheet sanders move in every direction also. I've worked in shops on every end of the spectrum. We used what we had and didn't ask why. Well, I'm buying it now. And I'm asking Why???

Opinions?? Fact???

Thanks for the feedback, in advance.

Greg H.

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

#2

JL

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

JL

>I have a 1/2 sheet sander and a 5" ROS. I don't have a 1/4 sheet palm sander though. What do I like about my 5" - dust control. I really like all the dust going into the bag or into my shop vac. I usually buy in "bulk", which drives the cost down a little.

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

#3

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Gregg,

Comparisons, cost and otherwise, which you'll get will be subjective. It is true sheet paper which you can buy in bulk and cut down will give you the lowest cost per square inch, given identical paper. My own opinion is there is room for both sander formats. I have two 1/4 sheet orbiting sanders (a P+C 330 and an old Makita). I also use a 1/3 sheet Skil orbital. These are great in leveling out surfaces adjacent to a seam, so you don't create little hills and valleys. They get into corners too. I also own three random orbital sanders and use both H&L and psa discs. Granted, these are more expensive to operate, but they do a superior job because the randomized orbits don't leave dust tracks in the raw wood. Another advantage is ease of changeing to other grits. Methinks that despite the relatively higher cost of operation, the ROS more than pays for itself. I need all designs in my shop, and the best happens to be my own hand.

George

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

#4

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

Frank Orfanello

>Greg,

I have a 5" and a 6" Porter Cable ROS (one was a gift) that I love to use. I also have a Makita 1/4 sheet palm sander and I love that too. I tend to use the ROS for more agressive sanding and the 1/4 sheet for more finish sanding. While the foregoing is generally true I have used the ROS for finish sanding at times.

I don't know if this is helpful but its what I do.

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

#5

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

Barry Irby

>I have a half sheet and a quarter sheet sander. I have not used either one since I got my 5" ROS. To me the ROS is just night and day different. Much more effective and aggressive. Maybe its time to drag the old one out and try them again, but as I recall they were pitiful compared to sanding with the ROS.

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

#6

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>I have a 5" bosch ROS as well a makita 1/4 sheet sander. The makita has been out of service for more years than I can rember because the strips that hold the paper are worn out. My bosch has been out of service twice due to a worn out backing pad that would no longer hold the paper. each time I purchased a new pad so I could get it up and runing and I still have not purchased the parts to fix the makita.

Robin

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

#7

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

Kneale Brownson in sunny N. MI

>I love the PC 330s. I've worn out two. I use them with fine sandpaper for finishing all but the last handsanding. I use a PC ROS with 60 and 80 grits unless I'm sanding something that requires the belt sander.

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

#8

Dale Lenz

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

Dale Lenz

>If you shop around, and use the internet I believe you can beat a dollar a disk price. I purchase mine in far more than 10 at a time. Sorry, can't recall what I paid for them, but I'm thinking maybe fifty cents, maybe less.

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

#9

Ellis Walentine

Cost comparisons...

Ellis Walentine

>...between orbital and random-orbital sanders are tricky at best. Random orbit models generally a bit more expensive, and the disks are definitely more expensive than sheet sandpaper, because of the die cutting, hook/loop/PSA backing, etc., that go into manufacturing them.

The flip side is that random-orbit sanders are more aggressive (think time savings), it is easier to change (and interchange) paper, and the sanding action (combined oscillation and rotation) prevents the little orbital squiggles that are so hard to avoid with regular oscillating sanders. With a good-quality ROS, you can get a better surface in less time than you can with an equivalently sized orbital model; at least, that's my experience.

The other thing I like about random-orbit sanders is that the round disk allows you to sand curved and sculptural shapes.

My 2¢,

Ellis

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

#10

Re: Cost comparisons...

Lee Ohmart

>I agree with the time saved point. I had no idea how much time I was spending using a 1/4" palm sander until I picked up a RO. Now my time spent sanding is way down due both to the more agressive sanding and faster grit change. Now I reserve the 1/4" sanders to small jobs and situations where going slow is better. The prepared discs are more expensive but a short search on the internet for bulk asles ought to get the price down.

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

#11

Dale Lenz

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness..... *LINK*

Dale Lenz

>A quick search found 100 Mirka disk for less than 22 bucks plus shipping. So.. maybe less than 30 cents a piece.

Once, many moons ago, I just purchased my RO sander, living out in rural American no body had the RO sanding disk, they probably never heard of a RO sander at that time. Anyway, I took a worn out disk, hook & loop type and spray some of that spray glue that allows you to peal off thing after gluing. Cut out some disk from from regular sand paper sheets, worked well. I have not done that method in years but can be done in a pinch.

I always use my Makita finishing sander for rounding curves and such, have tried the RO a few times and it felt odd. Maybe I need to retry Ellis thoughts. We need to be able to accept change, : ' >.


Disk price

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

#12

Dale Lenz

Re: Disc, jeez

Dale Lenz

>

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

#13

Those are PSA, Good price but not H&L

Barry Irby

>I reread his post and I am not sure which he wanted. They seem to be limited on H&L.

Re: Palm Sanders?? Cost effectiveness.....

#14

Dale Lenz

Re: My mistake...

Dale Lenz

>but the H&L are there also as you noted. Google search will turn up plenty. Let your mouse do the walking, : ' >...Dale