Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross posted

Posts

Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross posted

#1

Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross posted

Brian In Dawson Creek

>Variation from the one posted last week � still might have some more changes to make.

Brian






Re: Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross posted

#2

Re: Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross po

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Pretty box Brian,

Nice craftsmanship and great proportions: good contrast. It compares very favorably with last week's edition, but the beer doesn't. Coor's Lite makes me thirsty for beer.:<)

George

Re: Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross posted

#3

You can critique the box � not the beer (grin)

Brian In Dawson Creek

>

Re: Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross posted

#4

Re: Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross po

Barry Irby

>I like your boxes. Really nice. I do have a couple of suggestions you might try.

The legs appear to be about 3/4" thick. Try a little thinner. They look a bit heavy to me.

Or try thinning them down to create and ankle and foot. This would be much more difficult than just making them thinner.

Try lifting the arc under the box a bit, again to make the legs a little lighter looking. Or put a cut-out in the top of the legs under the box to make it appear to be a brace or angle bracket.

Re: Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross posted

#5

Re: Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross po

Brian In Dawson Creek

>Thank you very much for the suggestions I truly appreciate the comments, but could you explain ankle and foot.

Brian

Re: Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross posted

#6

Re: Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross po

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>Where is Dawson Creek? NC?

Nice box by the way!!!

Re: Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross posted

#7

Found ans. on SMC you're in BC

Alan in Little Washington (NC)

>

Re: Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross posted

#8

Re: Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross po

Barry Irby

>Please accept my suggestions not as criticism, but just as ideas thrown out and worth exactly what you paid for them.

I see your legs and being heavy and two dimensional as in made from flat stock. I am suggesting making them more three dimensional. Bear in mind that this will most probably increase the time and effort a lot.

The foot and ankle idea was to taper them thinner from just below the box to about a 1/2 or 3/4" above the table, where they would flair back out to the size they are now. Sort of like your calf, ankle and foot, only prettier. Think of a cabriole leg.

Another idea is to taper them down thinner both ways, leaving the bottom about 1/4 or 3/8" square so the box will appear to be standing on tip toes.

A question, Are you making the sides of the box out of thick stock and bandsawing the exterior and then cutting matching rabbits in the box and lid? If so, why not make the box of slightly thinner stock and saw the lid off and line the box with 1/4" or thinner material. Let the liner project above the box enough to create the lip for the lid to set over. This might be easier than the other way and leave you with neatly aligned grain.

Re: Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross posted

#9

Re: Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross po

Brian In Dawson Creek

>Thanks for the reply and I value your post as needed constructive criticism. I plan on making more boxes like this but not until I get this leg design sorted out. To answer you question � I am making the box out of thick stock (15/16) and band sawing the exterior. But the lips on the top and bottom are made by cutting between two opposing router cuts that form a perfect lip � top and bottom as shown in the diagram below.

Thanks again for your input.

Brian

Thanks for the reply and I value your post as needed constructive criticism. I plan on making more boxes like this but not until I get this leg design sorted out. To answer you question � I am making the box out of thick stock (15/16) and band sawing the exterior. But the lips on the top and bottom are made by cutting between two opposing router cuts that form a perfect lip � top and bottom as shown in the diagram below.

Thanks again for your input.

Brian


Re: Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross posted

#10

Re: Walnut & Maple box (prototype #2) PIC cross po

Barry Irby

>That's Cool! Neat idea on how to create a perfect fitting lid. I'll have to give it some thought.

The only disadvantage I see over what I suggested is that you "lose" 3/8" of stock and that might throw the grain alignment off more than if you did it the way I was talking about. Your method requires routing of grooves and the setup involved in that, but my suggestion requires making completely separate parts for the liner. You can play with the liner though and make it of contrasting material or cover it with felt or flocking.

You could sort of "go the other way" and make a manly man box and make it a humidor.