Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

Posts

OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#1

OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

Joe Pack

>Having gone through a minor case of identiy theft, I was pleased to learn that there may be a partial "cure" in place in most states, and pending in many others. I have even been told by my US congressman that he, and others, have introduced bipartisan legislation to this effect.

In 39 states and the D. of C., residents have the right to "freeze" their credit reports, denying any company or person access to their credit reports and, thereby, all but eliminating the possibility that someone can open a fraudulent account in their name. (Ohio is NOT one of the 39, but they are in the process. I have written over 20 e-mails to my state representatives and senators encouraging their support.)

The laws differ slightly from state to state, but, essentially, you may instruct each of the three major credit bureaus to "freeze" your accounts, denying access to ANY person or organization, effectively preventing anyone, including you (more later), from opening a credit account. Most states allow the credit bureaus to charge a fee of $10 to place a freeze, and an additional $10 to lift a freeze. And you would have to do this with all three agencies. Most states also require that the service is free to victims of identity theft. Some states (Indiana is one) specify that NO fee can be charged under any circumstances. Freezes have to be imposed within a very few days, and have to be lifted by the bureaus within anywhere from 15 minutes to 1 day, depending on the state law.

The down side is that you cannot apply for and receive "instant" credit at a department store. You may not qualify for the free toaster for opening an instant checking account. You may not receive all those "0% interest" offers anymore. Seriously, there would be a small hassle if you wanted to open a new account...you would first have to contact all three credit bureaus to have the freeze temporarily lifted, and you would have to pay to do this each time you needed a new account.

Another potential down side is that prospective employers sometimes do a credit check on applicants. If you have a freeze in place, you would need to find out if prospective employers do such a check, and to make arrangements for the freeze to be lifted for this employer.

The up side is that NOBODY can open an account in your name...EVER...with a freeze in place. You are protected. Period. Knowing the gut-wrenching feeling a friend of mine went through after numerous accounts (hundreds of thousands of dollars!) were opened in her name, I like that idea. I will do this with Sally and my accounts the instant Ohio passes the law mandating that credit bureaus permit me to do this. I don't think I will need any new credit for a looong time, so, even if I have to pay a fee, I will feel better knowing I won't have to fight for two years to clear up fraudulent accounts.

Not surprisingly, the biggest lobby against these laws have been the credit agencies and retailers, particularly those who make a fortune getting you to sign up for instant credit. (10% off if you open a Value City account today!!) It is almost comical to read their arguments against "freeze" legislation in various states. And, in a couple of states, they have been successful! (A car dealer group in Utah argued that "...most of our customers want to sign up for credit and drive their car home that day...they won't buy if they have to wait.") The truth is that, in most states, a credit freeze must be lifted in as little as 15 minutes, and can be done by phone or internet. How many "impulse" sales would be lost if the customer actually had to wait a few minutes? Too many for retailers to support this kind of legislation.

Enough. I have probably blabbed on too long already. If you want to see what the laws are in your state, you can check it out at this link:

http://www.consumersunion.org/campaigns/learn_more/003484indiv.html

Joe


http://www.consumersunion.org/campaigns/learn_more/003484indiv.html

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#2

Great info. - thanks

Jerry Draper

>

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#3

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Looks good, but I have a (potentially stupid) question: if your identity is stolen, how does that protect you? And how do the credit agencies know it is you and not somebody else who is requesting the lifting a freeze?

Obviously I don't understand the concept too well :-)

DC

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#4

Same question!

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>The exact same question crossed my mind.

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#5

Can't remember all details

Derek

>Where I am, you must send a copy of the letter they sent you in the first place to turn it off. Also, there is a pass code, as I recall, that you give them.

We did it and I have the info saved in a safe place.

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#6

PIN or Password required

Joe Pack

>When you register for an account freeze you are issued a PIN or password that would be known only to you. When you request a temporary or permanent lift of the freeze, you must supply that number. It would work much the same as an ID or PIN or Password necessary if you have a financial account or do on-line banking. When I contact Bank of America, I have to provide several levels of information that only I would know.

No account activity can take place without the password and/or related confidential information.

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#7

Conspiracy theory

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Ay, you mean that special PIN that the bank sends to you in that paper in a slider envelope. The one that you stick to your refrigerator and get's thrown out with the expired pizza coupons. The PIN that you can't even remember yourself when you want to unfreeze your account, so after the panick of not remembering you change to something that you and countless other people could figure out.

I think this legislation is fantastic, and although filled with problem of practicality, think it's a great step towards preventing identity theft. We do have to do something.

Which by the way, I wonder if is a whole farce to begin with.

A few years ago there were these unknown companies colleting "credit related information" about us. Next thing we know they are billion dollar companies that hold the fate of many people in their files. Who made them king, eh? So they collect information about you, and then charge $50-$100 to anyone who wants to know about you. And then charges YOU $149/year to monitor it.

Here's the deal... I'm going to set up a company, and take photographs of you every day. Then I'm going to sell those photos of you to others for profit. Then I'll get you to pay me to see what sort of photos I'm collecting about you, just so that you know that I'm not selling indecent photos of you.

I think this whole thing is a conspiracy invented by those THREE credit bureaus. I think they INVENTED a whole industry for themselves.

Just like AntiVirus vendors might be funding virus creation, and pharmaceutical companies could be inventing diseases, I think these these credit buraeus are inventing ways to get you to pay them money.

This world is absolutely nuts.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#8

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft

JKJ in East TN

>Excellent info, thanks. I have no need for loans, credit cards, or other credit so this should work well.

I see the TN law will be effective Jan 08.

JKJ

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#9

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft

Binen

>If you want to stop identity theft then make the reporting companies liable. Since they want to collect, hold and profit off our personal financial information they should also have a fiduciary responsibility. Make them responsible to pay for the credit repair and it would end overnight.

Binen

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#10

Re: Conspiracy theory

Barry Irby

>It does strike me as amazing that these companies can collect information about me without my knowledge or permission and profit from it, but have no obligation to check with me to see if it is accurate or even about me at all. They had to be forced to let me look at the information without charging me.

I'm not much on conspiracy theories, but this is enough to make you go Hmmm?

Some of the "rules" are amazing. Several years ago I was thinking of buying a car. During "holes" in my daily schedule I would stop in various car dealers to see what any of them might have that would work for me. (This used to be a lot easier because there were fewer brands.) I was in no big hurry and checked a bunch of them. Of course they all want you to drive their version and they copy your Driver's License. Eventually I realized they all ran a credit check on me while I was out driving. None of them asked permission. I was surprised to learn that all the inquiries could damage my credit. They are allowed to check me out, but when I am thorough and check them out I take a hit??? Somehow their interpretation of this is that I might be about to buy a dozen cars. The amazing part was I was going to pay cash for the car and did not need credit at all.

The whole industry is pretty nearly a criminal enterprise and should be judged under the RICO (whatever) laws on organized crime.

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#11

Re: Conspiracy theory

Kirk (KC) Constable

>They're not supposed to be able to just run a credit check unless you've signed something that says they can... at least that's what I've been lead to believe. I'm sure it happens, but it's not SUPPOSED to happen.

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#12

It gets worse

Pat Evans

>Check your insurance rates. Insurance companies use data from these credit reporting companies also. Someone did some statistical analysis and determined that there was a correlation between how many credit cards you have and how many wrecks you are likely to have. I found that I was being charged significantly higher rates because I had too many credit cards. I'm sure these credit companies sold their services to the insurance companies also, under the guise of being helpful. The insurance companies are only too ready to use any excuse to screw their customers. The correlation between credit cards and accidents cannot be anything but a pure statistical anomaly. It didn't even have anything to do with credit... mine is fine. I don't owe anything to any of the credit card companies, I just had a lot of cards.

By the way, when I complained to my agent, she had my rates changed and I saved a significant amount of money. The extra charges because of my credit report were not mandatory but were being charged because they thought they could get away with it.

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#13

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Statistical anomaly...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>I know quite a few people at widely different socio-economics levels in society. In my experience (and this is based on impressions, not empirical data), those who have real wealth and good credit tend to engage in fewer risky behaviors (speeding, DUIs, etc.), perhaps because they wish to protect their well-being physically and financially. Those I know who have very poor credit and little to no net worth tend to "live it up" a little more on the road, whether it's speeding or not wearing a seat belt or they go to the bars on Fridays and Saturdays.

I can see the correlation between the risky behaviors on the road, and the risky behavior of using one's credit. Having many credit cards is one of those risky behaviors (intentional or not--think about how quick you COULD max those out if you wanted to). I don't like it, but I can see how the insurance companies could make that connection. Remember, they have legions of actuaries researching statistics to squeeze every last dollar out of us, plus teams of lobbyists to sway the laws in their favor to require us to have various forms of insurance. I pay the state $20/yr. for the "privilege" of NOT carrying workman's comp insurance on myself (self-employed). Most clients never care one rip about that, but I do have one apartment complex that keeps a copy of that exemption certificate on file.

Jason

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#14

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft

wayne

>A few years ago someone tried to get a credit card in my name. The credit bureau called me to see if it was me and I told them no. They said I could put a hold on my account and that they would contact me anytime anyone tried to get a card or credit someone else to see if it was me. It has worked very well, and didn't cost me anything. I had to call all three bureaus though.

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#15

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft

Joe Pack

>The hold is also a good idea. The problem, as I understand it, is that the credit agency has to recognize an attempt at opening an account as a fraud. Glad the one that contacted you was on the ball.

The other problem with a "hold" or "flag" is that, again as I understand it, the "hold" expires after a short amount of time.

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#16

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft, another idea

Kevin French, Antrim, NH

>I haven't done this yet but, instead of signing your credit cards put: " Photo ID Required" in the signture block.

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#17

Follow-up from a legislator in Ohio

Joe Pack

>I didn't just contact WC friends about this issue, I wrote e-mails to my own Ohio representatives and senators, plus sent e-mails to every member of the appropriate House and Senate committees.

I just received a call from a staff member of the Chair of the committee handling this legislation in Ohio thanking me for my input and for supporting their efforts. It seems that their committee is receiving tremendous resistance from retailers and credit agencies saying that the proposed legislation is too onerous, cannot be made to work right away, blah...blah...blah.

Anyhow, the purpose of this post is to encourage everyone to write their legislators when an issue concerns them. They really do read letters, and are influenced by them. I believe that most legislators, at least on the local level, really are in business to serve their communities. I also believe, though, that they are most likely to serve those who make the most noise.

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#18

Or make the biggest campaign contribution.

Don henthorn

>

Re: OT-Preventing Identity Theft *LINK*

#19

They don't even look most of the time.

Joe Pack

>I have had "Photo ID Required" on the back of my credit cards for a couple of years now. I use my cards at least 25 times each month, about half of those times at places that don't know me from anyone. I have been asked for photo ID fewer than 10 times in all that time, half of those during a recent trip to Branson, MO. Most clerks don't even look at the back, and those that do look either only pretend to or ignore what is written there.

Retailers such as WallyWorld, Home Depot, Sears, etc. that have the electronic self-swipe credit card terminals don't ever ask to see the card, only for a signature. And they rarely look at the signature. I have signed my slip as George Bush, Bill Dance, Barry Bonds and Mickey Mouse and nobody has ever questioned me. I have even written "I won't sign" and it was passed through. When I object and question them about not checking my card, they just shrug and say something dumb like "Oh, I didn't notice."

Some time ago someone got hold of my debit card number and used it to make purchases at Victoria's Secret and Hot Dog Heaven in California. On the same day the number was used to make purchases in Greenville, South Carolina. The card was in my wallet the whole time. Those vendors allowed someone to make face-to-face purchases using only the number, with no PIN, and with no proof of ID. Fortunately, my bank figured that I could not be in South Carolina and California on the same day and contacted me. Plus, they knew that Victoria's Secret didn't carry my size.