Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Domino or Leigh M&T

Posts

Domino or Leigh M&T

#1

Domino or Leigh M&T

Herb Yost

>Decisions, decisions! Have a large commission ahead of me, involving a lot of mortise and tenon work on chairs, tables of various sizes, and a lecturn. Arches and U-shaped pillars (for lack of a better word) are a major design factor, so there will be a lot of end-grain to end-grain work involving angles. The chairs, of course, need to have strong joinery.

I was leaning towards the Domino, but the Leigh jig has a big price drop. Any feedback or suggestions, especially from those who have used both?

Re: Domino or Leigh M&T

#2

Re: Domino or Leigh M&T

Chad Pearson

>I have both and I don't have anything bad to say about either one. They do have their respective advantages however.

Festool Advantages

1. The Domino is really quick to pull out to do a couple mortises. I find myself doing the mortises on an as needed basis during the course of the project. The FMT takes a little bit of setup time and thus I would batch cut everything at once. This is especially true if you don't have a dedicated router set up for the FMT.

2. Portability - The Festool can be brought to the work.

3. Mortises can easily be made in a field (e.g. in the middle of a bookshelf panel)

4. The Domino collects 99% of the dust. The FMT always makes a mess, even with the vac hooked up.

Leigh FMT Advantages

1. Using the fence I can batch cut a bunch of M&T's while only measuring once. The Festool has some of this feature through the stop pins but it really isn't the same.

2. The Leigh is really nice for doing multiple angles (e.g. chairs). I haven't yet tried multiple angles on the Domino...I think it will work well but I can't really say as yet.

3. You don't have to buy the tenon stock and it is a true M&T rather than floating. There's just something cool about that.

4. The leigh allows you to make a very wide selection of tenon sizes. If I want to make a 1/2 inch wide tenon I can. The Domino would require lots of little mortises for the same strength. The FMT also allows you to go very small (I have seen matchsticks with M&T joints on display at a woodworking show).

These are my impressions so far. Keep in mind I am just a hobbiest and so my tool usage has not been heavy. I have had the FMT since just after it came out and the Domino for about 3 months. I have no intention of selling the FMT but at the same time I don't expect to use it nearly as much as I did before.

I would be interested in the opinions of others as well.

Chad

Re: Domino or Leigh M&T

#3

Re: Domino or Leigh M&T

Dick Coers

>I own the Leigh MT and tested and demonstrated the Domino for the Peoria Woodcraft Store. Here's my thoughts;

The Domino is a hand-held machine. This makes it nearly impossible to make 100 percent of your joints accurately. Every once and a while your wrists will flex, something will bobble, something will move........If I had bought the Domino I would have also made some fixturing that would allow the duplicate work to be held against fences and stops. The splines are not consistant in thickness (like biscuits) and very tight from side to side. It is a remarkable hand-held tool and would be tough to beat in some applications.

The Leigh MT is also a remarkable machine and I own one. The fine adjustment for the fit is very good. It's the only way I have done mortise and tenons that has the controlled fit all the way around the tenon. In the past I would use loose tenons and would chamfer the tenon to clear the radius cut be the router bit. There is no bench top machine around that can cut multiple mortise and tenons with that accuracy. You can cut a 4 way m/t on a table stretcher that will pop air when you pull them apart. Very good dust control on it as well. It has a fantastic hold down system and has high repeatability. It also has compound angle ability as well for the chairs.

For my production work I still go to my Multi-router that I bought 20(?) years ago. With the router mounted, stops set, fast table movement, it is tough to beat for speed. I think it's close to $4000 now though. For me the good side is that I can probably sell it for more than I paid for it and it's cut a mile of mortises.

Bottom line, for furniture I would buy the Leigh M/T, and for case goods I would buy the Domino. I buy tools with the "best of them" having been woodworking for 35 years now, but I was not impressed enough with the Domino to buy it. That statement should get the Festool faithful stirred up! I hope one of the cult members doesn't show up at my door some night................... I do own the Festool saw and fence system guys, no lynchings please!

Re: Domino or Leigh M&T

#4

Re: Domino or Leigh M&T

Herb Yost

>Great comparison, Chad.....exactly what I was looking for. Not that you made the decision any easier!!!!! The coments about batch cutting were good...each piece will be unique (it's furniture for a hospital chapel)so there won't be that much batch cutting for me.

Re: Domino or Leigh M&T

#5

Question on Leigh M&T.........

R. Lance in GR, Michigan

>Herb, what is this big price drop on this jig? Seems like it has always sold for about $800. Always wanted one but at that price I've been ear-marking plywood jigs in magazines that try to do the same thing.

Re: Domino or Leigh M&T

#6

Re: Domino or Leigh M&T

Jesse in New Mexico

>I think Chad pretty well nailed the comparison. A few additional odds and ends...

Setup on the Domino is trivial, I can be productive in about 2 minutes, where the FMT took a lot longer.

Personally, I found the FMT a little tricky sometimes. The clamps are often in the wrong place and would work loose at the worst times.

Taking the tool to the work is really great for chairs, sometimes getting a chair leg at just the right angle on an FMT involves serious acrobatics.

The biggest limitation on the Domino for me is depth of cut (28mm in each direction). But on the other hand, routing a deep mortise or tenon is no fun either.

As Chad said, both are great tools. You can't really go wrong with either choice.

For what its I sold my FMT after I bought the Domino.

Re: Domino or Leigh M&T

#7

Re: Domino or Leigh M&T

Paul Dwight

>I'm a little embarrassed to admit this, but I own both the FMT and the Domino. I find myself grabbing the Domino when I have a few joints to cut -- say, for a single cabinet door -- because setup time is almost zero. If I know I'm going to be cutting more than a few joints, I usually take the time to set up the FMT. I really like the fact that the FMT gives me a wide range of mortise/tenon sizes to better match the design of whatever I'm working on.

I occassionally need to cut an oddball joint that's essentially impossible on the FMT, but which the Domino can knock out in 2 or 3 minutes. Having the Domino always makes that a fun day.

If I could only have one, I think it would be the FMT. This may be partly because I've owned the FMT for years and trust what it can do. Maybe I'll feel different about the Domino after I've used it more. In any event, it's really nice having both. -- Paul

Re: Domino or Leigh M&T

#8

Re: Question on Leigh M&T.........

Herb Yost

>It's "down" to $599.00 now -- probably to compete with the Domino. I saw it first in one of th wodoworking mags, and a check of the Woodcraft site confirms it. That's a lot less expensive than the Doimino plus attachments plus the box of various tenons.

Re: Domino or Leigh M&T

#9

Rick L

Re: Grizzly 0540...

Rick L

>There's a review in the review section. A viable alternative for less than either tool mentioned. Been using horizotal slot mortisers for 25 years and it the best of the bunch. It's actually the father of the Domino and goes back to over 50 years of history but few really know that much about it.

Re: Domino or Leigh M&T

#10

Re: If you have the Leigh, get the sidestop fence *LINK*

Peter Gregory

>Leigh has been bring out new accessories for the FMT of late. The side stop fence is a big improvement over the original. I was making a shop built version of this before, but this is better.

I was looking for this link and found the square templates are out now too. Wonder if I need them.

Just completed 80 M&T joints in less than a day with mine and I don't use it very often.


http://www.highlandwoodworking.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=8008