Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

Posts

OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

#1

OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>This is a shameless hijack of Ellis's wine bag thread below. I need the input of perhaps a chemist for this one about the makeup of plastic milk jugs.

Last weekend, I changed the oil in two of our cars and as usual, I put the used oil in a couple plastic milk jugs for delivery to our hazardous household waste recycle center. The first jug I used had about an inch of oil in it from around last March when I did some mechanical work on my Harley. It was sitting on the concrete garage floor. I moved it to the workbench and when I started to fill it up the rest of the way with the new used oil, it started leaking from somewhere on the bottom. I just grabbed another clean jug and transferred the oil to that. I thought it was funny that it just started leaking. There was no trace of oil on the floor where it had been sitting.

So the next day, I go to the recycle center to drop off the oil, along with some used batteries and fluorescent tubes. One guy at the center said I might want to reconsider using milk jugs for this. He said they're fine for milk but not for petroleum products. He warned that if you store oil in them for any length of time, the whole bottom might just fall out when you pick it up. He suggested laundry soap bottles or windshield washer fluid jugs would be better.

I thought about the leaky jug from the day before and considered the guy might be on to something. But then I dug around and it seems that milk jugs, quart oil containers and such are all made from #2 HDPE. So what's magical about oil in milk jugs? I fugure this guy was speaking from experience, but I can't confirm any of this anywhere. Any chemical experts out there have an idea?

Looking for answers here, West of Chicago.

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

#2

Didn't think anyone changed their own oil anymore

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I didn't think that there was anyone who still changed their own oil anymore... besides me of course.

After taking our brand new car to a dealer, years and years ago, and discovering that they drained the oil but forgot to refill the oil..... well I've always done all oil changes myself. The dealers do the leased cars, but I've always done the oild/filter changes to everythign else myself.

My wife complains I'm the only left on the planet that does it themselves. Nice to see I'm not.

I drain from the vehicle to a catch pan underneath and then transfer the dirty oil to a 10-gallon blue plastic Kerosene container. If I don't want to lug that when it's full to the recycling center, I transfer right back into the Castrol 4-quart containers that I bought the new oil in.

And yes, I've had a few plastic containers get soft and leak with oil stored in it too long. Never with a properly rated Kerosene or Gasoline can and never with a plastic jug that they sell oil in, but things like Yogourt and Margarine containers don't do as well.

Ever stored a paint brush in plain paint thinner *temporarily* in a yogourt container? Darn container melted into nothing but a stain on the garage floor with a paint brush mysteriously laying on the ground ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

#3

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jug

john lucas

>Tim I've had endgrain sealer and even paint that was stored in milk cartons, leak. I no longer use them. As a photographer I have gallon chemistry bottles at my disposal so I use them.

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

#4

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jug

Joel Wilson

>Tim,

Polyethylene (HDPE) milk jugs do not have pigment added to them. In addition to color, pigment protects the HDPE from UV radiation catalyzed oxidation. -Joel

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

#5

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Even quicker...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>...is lacquer thinner in a styrofoam cup. Gone before your very eyes.

Oh, and I change my own oil most of the time, too. Except when I'm busy right before a long road trip and the family minivan needs its oil changed, then I let my wife take it to Wally World with specific instructions...

I've stored oil in plastic 5-gallon paint buckets that didn't leak for a long time (1-2 years), and I've had them leak inside of a few months. It may depend on the time they spent outside prior to having oil in them.

Jason

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

#6

JL

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jug

JL

>A couple of things. Thickness is everything. The HDPE in milk jugs is way thin. It will break down over time with exposure to UV light. Pigmented milk jugs do last a bit longer (both of the local grocery stores use pigmented milk jugs). The HDPE in oil containers is much thicker and will resist the migration of oil through the containers.

HDPE consists of long chains of polyethylene. As such, they do not present any substantial barrier to the long chain aliphatic hydrocarbons found in oil. Yes, they do hold it. Yes, eventually the oil will slowly migrate through the structure. Like dissolves like - even if it takes a while. There are also other hydrocarbons present in your oil which may do a better job of dissolving the HDPE. I used to dissolve other polyethylenes (LDPE, LLDPE) in solutions of toluene. I'd have to heat it to about 50-60 C.

Polypropylene (the # 5 in the recycling logo) resists oil much better in my opinion.

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

#7

Hey Jason

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>Did you know that if dissolve lots of styrofoam in lacquer thinner it makes a really tough weather resistant sealant for wood? It isn't terribly pretty as a wood finish but it lasts outdoors for years. You can dissolve several large ice chests into about a half a pint of lacquer thinner.

Lee

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

#8

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jug

JKJ in East TN

>Same here. I've had milk jugs (and plastic cat litter containers) leak with oils and anchorseal. I've never had a wiper fluid jug leak and I use them a lot. (I buy the cheap stuff on sale for sawmill lubricant in the winter)

Very good plastic containers for used oil are hydraulic fluid jugs, 2+ gal I think. I get these when I service my tractor. They are very sturdy, impervious to damage from oils, and not much good for anything else. You might find empties at a small place that services equipment. (The large shops buy it by the 55 gal drum.)

Another nice thing for automobile oil is the oil catch pan thats molded from a plastic container. You can carry it to and empty it at the recycle center.

JKJ

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

#9

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

LOL

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>That's hilarious, Lee! No, I had not tried that. My only knowledge of the phenomenon was when my partner was looking for something in which to pour a little lacquer thinner to clean a spray tip or brush or something. He saw a styrofoam coffee cup in the trash pile of his van and grabbed it. Before I realized what he had, he had poured some lacquer thinner in it. By the time I opened my mouth to say something, there was lacquer thinner everywhere. SuperGlue (I assume the cyanoacrylate) also quickly dissolves styrofoam--that I had figured out as a pre-teen. One of my less hazardous "experiments" from that period in my life...

I may have to demonstrate the ice chest one to my kids sometime.

Jason

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

#10

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jug

Jay St. Peter - Southern, MD

>I still use milk jugs. I have a large tub that I store them in my garage with a piece of black plastic over the top. I'm convinced that UV is at least 3/4 of the problem. They still feel weaker than new when I take them to the recycling center, but I haven't had any leaky ones since I started keeping them this way ... around 10 years now. It is usually around a year and a half between visits to the recycling center and I have them piled 2 high by then.

Jay St. Peter

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

#11

In a time long ago and place far away

Gary Camp Bend, Oregon

>I was in the brown water navy, fixing river boats. On special occasions (like Christmas) a bottle of "Dumb Syrup" might appear in the shop office, along with paper cups and sodas. We quickly learned that glue that held in the bottoms of the cups in was alcohol soluble. That meant pour the mixer in first. It's a pretty sad look a guy gets on his face when the bottom falls out of the cup that holding his Christmas toddy.

glc

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

#12

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jug

Jim Dillon

>Tim,

Keep in mind that thin-walled plastic milk bottles are designed to degrade with time. JL mentioned the UV aspect and its role in degradation which is very important both for the determining the life of the plastic, as well as the milk inside the bottle (the milk proteins break down). Plus, I wouldn't be surprised if a very tiny amount of starch (or similar material) is encorporated into the plastic to assist in the biodegradation of the bottle when it is buried in the landfill. The starch dissolves increasing the porosity (larger surface area) where anaerobic bacterial can do their thing and break down the plastic even further. Why doesn't the starch dissolve out in normal use? Well, "normal use" is measured in days (in a dark refrigerator), not weeks or months, so the bottle stays intact - for awhile. Anyway, I sure wouldn't use a plastic milk jug for long-term storage of anything, especially if the jug is exposed to sunlight or even fluorescent lighting. Hey, remember those walls of water-filled plastic milk jugs inside passive solar homes during the '70s. I bet they had to replace those jugs on a weekly basis 8-).

Jim

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

#13

At least twice a year....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>At least twice a year, in July and in November, usually at 11pm the night before we drive up to Canada in the summer or Florida for Thanksgiving, you'll find me covered in oil under the Honda Odyssey changing out the oil. Every, single, darn time.

Don't know about you but it seems every time, just before I drive 24 hours, I seem to to a 80 hour week and then stay up really late the night before >:(

Then when we arrive in Canada, I sleep for about 48 hours straight and everyone thinks I'm being anti-social.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

#14

Thanks guys.....

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>Sounds like the general consensus is that the UV is the culprit. I'll only use these jugs when I don't have to store for any length of time. Friend of mine uses them with water in them to tie down his pool cover. He says they always start leaking after a while. Sunlight exposed, UV damage.

And yes Mark, I'm one of the few that still changes his own oil. Always have.

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

#15

Dale Lenz

Re: Didn't think anyone changed their own oil anym

Dale Lenz

>An ounce or two of used motor oil on some kindling gets the fire going quickly in the shop during the winter. My oldest son has been changing my oil for me for several years now. Funny though, used oil kept in 5 gallon buckets, metal or plastic makes water during the year. Often wondered if setting the bucket on the ground has anything to do with making water, as in condensation.

Re: OT speaking of plastic containers....(milk jugs)

#16

Re: Didn't think anyone changed their own oil anym

Mike King, Sherwood Park, AB

>Yeah. I have to on some stuff too- I'd look a little silly wheelin' my Generac and rear-bagger up to the door at Lubexx.. ;-)

It's a used Oil catch and store thingie from Canajin Tire for me.