Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Argh...warped table tops

Posts

Argh...warped table tops

#1

Argh...warped table tops

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Bout a month ago I posted looking for a source of workbench tops. After many good suggestions I settled on the 1" thick laminated solid beech countertops available from Ikea.

I bought two of them - 96"x25" in length. Very reasonably priced, very good looking, and heavy. The individual 1" wide strips were laid in opposing grain structure as is appropriate.

Unpacked them and laid them horizontally on the plywood base to which they would eventually be affixed. Still had work to do on the backsplash which required the tablesaw to be wired up..etc..so it took a while. They sat there for about 2 weeks, and warped, horribly.

They went from dead flat to having about 2/3" of "air" underneath the centers. Both of them did the same thing. I was trying to figure out if I could fix the problem by pulling them down with through bolts and then screwing them tight from underneath. I had a couple of other ideas, too.

Then it occured to me to figure out why they warped so. It is very humid in my new shop space, much more so than wherever these things were undoubtedly stored, probably flat stacked on top of each other. I'm assuming that what happened is that the topsides were exposed to the humid air and the bottoms were not, and that as a result the topside swelled as a result, creating the nice and even warpage.

So I turned them over, and am anxious to see what happens to them. I expect that they'll return close to flat again in a few weeks as the newly exposed surface swells.

What do you think? Will they be usable? Should I just take them back and use something else? Should I have screwed them down immediately upon unpacking them? I'm thinking they'd have experienced the same stresses had I done so, and maybe cracked.

There were lots of other good ideas originally, but I want to stick with wood. I'm not searching for other ideas in this post, rather what you think will happen to and what I should do these. thanks!

Re: Argh...warped table tops

#2

Re: Argh...warped table tops

Barry Irby

>Mike, Do these things have a "top" and "bottom"? Are they finished on one side and not the other? Did you leave something like plastic wrap on the underside that would have stopped or reduced moisture flow? Something is unbalanced here, it seems.

Actually, you would think the top or better side would have the finish on it, if any, and that would retard moisture flow, causing the unfinished bottom side to pick up moisture faster and making it swell. The opposite of what you experienced. Perhaps you should ship them to someone in Australia.

I'd wait and see if they flatten out and then fasten them down so that they can float.

Re: Argh...warped table tops

#3

Re: Argh...warped table tops

Mike Schwing from Md.

>They have a "DOWN" marked on one side. That is the side that was down and they warped up from the center. No plastic wrap was left on them. I cannot however discern if there is a finish on either side. They look and feel identical.

Re: Argh...warped table tops

#4

Re: Argh...warped table tops

john lucas

>Mike I think you are accurate in your assumption that one side got more moisture but if the bottom was open I don't think it would have been that great. I have had that happen when laying wood on a concrete floor. I would call the company first so they would know what is happening and see what they have to say. Then I would flip the tops and watch them for a while and see if they flatten.

Re: Argh...warped table tops

#5

Re: Argh...warped table tops

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Well, at least they won't sag after you install them.

Re: Argh...warped table tops

#6

Ellis Walentine

What I would do...

Ellis Walentine

>... is to flip them over and put them on 1x1 sticks in a dry place with good air circulation. Put the sticks under, in-between and on top of the pieces, with a half sheet of plywood on top of that. Then weight down the stack with some cinder blocks or something and wait. Assuming they were at equilibrium when they left the factory, they should return to equilibrium once both sides have had a chance to adjust to your local environment.

The only thing that bothers me is that all the expansion was on the "down" side. That could mean that the top sides were finished with some kind of curtain coat but the bottoms weren't. Those sealers can be very thin and hard to discern. A couple shots with a scraper should tell the story. You might have to sand the top surfaces down to bare wood to allow things to stabilize.

As far as using the tops if they are slightly warped, that depends on whether you are able to keep them flat with some kind of mechanical means, such as dovetail beams or slot screws or z-blocks.

Whatever the method, make sure the beam structure is adequate to overcome the cupping force of the top itself. One way to figure that out empirically is to put the top on a bench with the convex side up. Lay a beam across the top and clamp it at both ends. If the beam bows somewhat, it isn't stiff enough and you need something of a stiffer species or a larger section modulus.

You should be okay, one way or the other. Sorry you had to go through all this trouble.

Ellis

Re: Argh...warped table tops

#7

Re: Argh...warped table tops

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Mike,

I believe they will go back and become flat when they both reach equilibrium. If it were me, I would use thru bolts and draw them nice and tight and get on with it. Life is too short.

George

Re: Argh...warped table tops

#8

Re: What I would do...

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Thanks Ellis. How about if I stand them on a long end? Same basic effect as all of those 1x1s (that I don't have)??

Re: Argh...warped table tops

#9

Ellis Walentine

Negative, Mike

Ellis Walentine

>The idea is to apply uniform flattening pressure to them as they come back to equilibrium. Standing them on end just invites a lot of twisting to add to your woes.

Surely you can rip some stickers from scrap. It's really the only good way to do this.

Ellis

Re: Argh...warped table tops

#10

Okie doke.

Mike Schwing from Md.

>

Re: Argh...warped table tops

#11

Rather than bring the back side MC up

Keith Newton

>I would prefer to bring the top side back down.

You can do this by laying them out in the Sun for an hour or two. The extra heat on that side will cause it to give up moisture on that side.

I had two table leaves in my car a while back. I forgot they were in there, and left them for a day or two in the heat. When I found them, they had bowed apart. I reversed their position, and put a spring clamp on them to hold them together, and they straightened back out by the next day.

Re: Argh...warped table tops

#12

Re: Rather than bring the back side MC up

Keith Newton

>I just noticed that I was not clear in the last sentence.

Since they were face to face, and bowed out at the ends, I reversed their position, clamped them together, and left them in the car for a while longer.

Re: Argh...warped table tops

#13

Re: Rather than bring the back side MC up

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Well, as stated previously, I turned them back up about 36 hours ago now. By yesterday afternoon they had nearly flattened back out. I stickered them as per Ellis' suggestion and this morning they were flatter still. If they don't return to flat they are now going to be easy to draw down with a couple of thru bolts then screws through the bottom.

Thanks men.