Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Steel City vs Delta

Posts

Steel City vs Delta

#1

Steel City vs Delta

Bill- Evansville, IN

>I'm finally ready to trade up from my contractor's TS and the decision is more difficult that I'd thought it would be. I've had my heart set on a Unisaw for quite some time, but I learned about Steel City's saws on a trip to Redmond's in Atlanta. They have their 5 hp Industrial Saw (35626) for ~$300 more (after shipping and the mobile base that WW supply throws in) than a 3 hp Unisaw (the non X5 that woodworker's supply sells). I don't think I need this much saw (I'm just a weekend woodworker), but I like the more substantial trunions and 5 yr warranty. Does anybody have any advice? I haven't found anything bad about Steel City, does anybody have any feelings about their products, especially this saw?

Thanks in advance your input and opinions,

Bill

Re: Steel City vs Delta

#2

It really wont matter much IMHO........

Scott in Eastern Iowa

>.....the Steel City boys are all ex Delta guys and their own make and quality of their product reflects it.

I was in the same boat as you in that I upgraded from a Crapsman contractor to a cabinet saw. Believe me, 3 hp is plenty for anyone hovering just under pro caliber to weekend warrior. I've cut 2" thick oak and the saw will not stall using a 3 horse motor.

BTW...I use a Delta Unisaw...Steel City wasn't around when I pulled the trigger.

Either one will likely please your pants off !!!

Re: Steel City vs Delta

#3

Re: Steel City vs Delta

Barry Irby

>I have a Rockwell/Delta Contractor saw. Most of my major tools are either Rockwell/Delta or Delta. I have always wanted a Unisaw. I have never seen a Steel City saw. Today if I had the money and the room, I would strongly consider a Sawstop Saw. I like my fingers and hands and now realize they stay healthy at the cost of eternal vigilance. I have to be safe 100% of the time. I cut my thumb badly on my RAS when I was about 17. 40 years later I can still show you the damage and I was lucky. How much luck does a person have?

Re: Steel City vs Delta

#4

Ellis Walentine

My advice...

Ellis Walentine

>...from what you've told us, is to get yourself a nice 3HP cabinet saw with a wide fence and either left or right tilt, whichever suits you. You will not need the 5hp saw unless you're a lot more ambitious than you let on. And Unisaw trunnions rarely are an issue. All the big name manufacturers use plenty beefy and accurate trunnions, from what I've seen.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Steel City vs Delta

#5

Re: Steel City vs Delta

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have a Unisaw, but it was made in USA. While at the Indianapolis tool show, I looked at the new Delta equipment. None of it was marked "Made in USA". The quality of their 20" band saw was far below the Grizzly, Jet and Steel City. I did look at the Powermatic equipment, if you have the extra cash, I would definitely buy their saw. Other than that I don't believe the 5 hp will buy you much. I have a 3 on mine, and have cut full depth in White oak using a sharp WW2 blade - didn't even slow down. But quality wise, I really think the Steel City, Jet or Grizzly are equal too or better than the new Delta. Personally, I would never buy a SawStop. Probably my opinion is heavily weighted due to the lawyer shenanigans they tried to pull when they sought to have laws passed requiring their design. But the basic reason is that I don't "fear" my table saw. I believe it is as safe as my Jointer, planer, band saw etc. when properly used. I do use the GrrRippers and swear by them as I can prevent kickback with the down force provided and never get my fingers close to the blade even if I slip. I am 66 years old, worked as an engineer in manufacturing for almost 40 years - set up, debugged many huge automatic machines and can still count to 10 without taking my shoes off. If I was scared enough that I had to have a SawStop, I would quit woodworking.

Re: Steel City vs Delta

#6

JL

Re: Steel City vs Delta

JL

>I've got their jointer. IMO, it is as good or better than the equivalent (Delta's DJ-20). I've seen their cabinet saws, they are worth considering.

Re: Steel City vs Delta

#7

Re: Steel City vs Delta

Ted Wong

>Larry, I don't think owning a Sawstop has anything to do with being "scared". I own insurance for my car, house and my life but I'm not afraid of anything catastrophic. Just prepared in the case anything does happen.

Re: Steel City vs Delta

#8

Re: Steel City vs Delta

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I've used a 3hp Unisaw for years and have no complaints. I routinely run thick hardwoods through it with no problems. When you have a quality sharp blade the horsepower is not an issue. Nor have I had a problems with the trunnions either. If that is the saw you have longed for then I believe you will not be disappointed.

Tom

Re: Steel City vs Delta

#9

Re: Steel City vs Delta

Jim Dillon

>Bill,

Can't add much to the variety of good opinions you've gotten. Based on my experience with a 3 HP cabinet saw, I would say you do not need 5 HP. Regarding saws, if I were shopping today, I would seriously look at the Sawstop; it was not available when I bought my saw. My 2 cents. Good luck and have fun shopping.

Jim

Re: Steel City vs Delta

#10

I traded my Subaru

Neal in San Jose

>in on an Audi at about the same time I sold my Jet cabinet saw and bought a Sawstop. The Subaru and Jet had a lot in common; both capable machines, maybe a little noisy with limited fit and finish. The Audi and the Sawstop have a lot in common as well. The Audi has anti-lock breaks, electronic stability control and air bags. The Subaru had none of these. The Sawstop has a brake. The Jet did not. The Audi and the Sawstop are both very well made, quiet and very user friendly. Does this mean I am afraid when I drive the Audi? Of course not. Am I glad it has those extra safety features? I am. Do I drive it differently than I did the Subaru? I don't think so. Some people drive an Audi or a Lexus or a Cadillac, others drive a Subaru or a Honda or a Chevy. Some people saw on a Sawstop, others on a Jet or a Delta. I haven't second-guessed either decision, but safety was definitely part of both of them.

Re: Steel City vs Delta

#11

Re: Steel City vs Delta

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Ted, I wasn't trying to be contentious - I do realize that you and many others are just trying to buy the safest equipment available. What I was trying to get across is that the additional cost of the saw and danger of ruining a $100 blade and expensive cartridge (if you hit a piece of metal) does not, IMHO make up for the difference in safety. Woodworking is inherently "dangerous" - working with high powered equipment and very sharp cutting blades. I just don't personally believe the table saw is any more dangerous than much of the other equipment in my shop. I still feel the Unisaw, Powermatic, Jet etc. saw designs are perfectly safe if a woodworker uses his head and takes proper precautions. A careless operator can get kickback even on the Sawstop and or the Powermatic with the riving knives. Even handtools are not safe - I have had some pretty good gashes and puncture wounds in my life from chisels and screwdrivers.

Re: Steel City vs Delta

#12

Re: Steel City vs Delta

Pierce Butler

>How long do you expect the saw to last? If the answer is something like "A long long time." So which mfgr has been around longest and still has parts for machines they made 60 years ago?

"What is the availability of used parts?" is another good question.

There is an awful lot of hype and misleading facts surrounding the Saw-Stop. I wish SawStop had more ethics when it comes to hawking their product. I might be able to trust them if they were more truthful. As it stands now I cannot trust SawStop to make any truthful statement.

Re: Steel City vs Delta

#13

Re: Steel City vs Delta

knotscott

>I agree with those who suggest you won't need 5hp and that there won't be much difference in construction, but from what I've read, many ownwers are raving over the better Steel City fence....might be a consideration worth checking into.