>I've not heard good reports about three wheeled bandsaw blade life. Also, it would seem to have pretty limited use except maybe to an avid wood turner for roughing bowl blank. At least with the circle cutting jig on my 14" bandsaw, I can remove it and use the saw for other cuts.
Lee
Re: Cutting circles with a bandsaw - interesting.... *LINK*
>...back in the late '70s when he was manufacturing wooden hot tubs. He used a 14" Delta bandsaw on about a 5' beam. The boards for the bottom of the tub were arranged on a stationary platter and the saw rotated around the platter to make the cut. It was the darndest thing to see him cut a perfect 6' or 8' circular tub bottom in about a minute flat.
Ellis
Re: Cutting circles with a bandsaw - interesting.... *LINK*
>"I've not heard good reports about three wheeled bandsaw blade life. Also, it would seem to have pretty limited use except maybe to an avid wood turner for roughing bowl blank. At least with the circle cutting jig on my 14" bandsaw, I can remove it and use the saw for other cuts. Lee "
There is no difference between the blade life of a two-wheeled and a three-wheeled bandsaw.
There! You just heard a good report on three-wheeled bandsaw blade life.
Do you personnally know anyone else who has a three-wheeler? If he's having a problem you should tell him to contact me off-line. There's no reason, nor is there any empirical data to support that myth. In fact almost all the blade life problems posted on this forum have been from guys using two-wheeled saws. Does that mean folks who use WC forum and own a two-wheeled bandsaw are more likely to break a blade?
Re: Cutting circles with a bandsaw - interesting.... *LINK*
>It would seem to be simpler, but Bob didn't come up with machine designs lightly. I'm sure there was a good reason to do it the way he did. I'll get in touch with him and see what he has to say.
Good question.
Ellis
Re: Cutting circles with a bandsaw - interesting.... *LINK*
>My brother had one and had serious problems with wheel alignment/blade tracking. Pretty sure that this would affect blade life though we got fed up with screwing with it long before any blade wore out. From an engineering standpoint, the more planes you have to make perfectly parallel the more problems you are going to have and the more money it's going to take to achive the solution. Really expensive three wheels are fine, I'm sure. For the average & even not so average woodworkers) the two wheeled ones provide far more bang (and ease of use) for the buck. Comparably priced three wheels SUCK.
Re: Cutting circles with a bandsaw - interesting.... *LINK*
>I have accepted the efficacy of the myth for many years, albeit without empirical data to support my position. Intuitively, however, it always seemed reasonable to me that bending a piece of steel 50% more times in a cycle over wheels substantially smaller than a comparable (14" for the sake of this discussion) two wheeler ought to introduce fatigue components at a measurable margin greater than on that two wheeler.
However, I could be completely wrong.
Rod
Re: Cutting circles with a bandsaw - interesting.... *LINK*
>"it always seemed reasonable to me that bending a piece of steel 50% more times in a cycle over wheels substantially smaller than a comparable (14" for the sake of this discussion) two wheeler ought to introduce fatigue components at a measurable margin greater than on that two wheeler."
No Rod, you're not completely wrong. If you were to run identical blades simultaneously on a two-wheeler and a three-wheeler without cutting anything, just idling, the weld on the three-wheeler would break first for the reason stated. In the real world, however, the blades will dull and get changed long before the weld fatigues and fails. The wheel radius is therefore marginal and inconsequential. And that seems to hold true for the carbide-tipped blades as well. My customers report the same 5x and 10x blade life for them as do the two-wheel owners.
What WILL break a blade prematurely is "leaning" against the blade guide's pinch rollers. You can run a standard blade weld for hours around wheels with a 5" radius and not break it, but when you "tweak" it around a 3/8" radius (1/2 of the guide rollers diameter) twice every second the blade won't last long. It's important that the blade run STRAIGHT between the top and bottom wheels. If your blade starts to drift and the blade guides are trying to hold the blade in place you've got a condition where the blade is going through a 3/8" radius every revolution of the saw. This could be even more severe when the stress is applied to the sharp corner of a guide block. You can actually see the oblique angle I'm talking about if you push your workpiece sideways against the blade. THAT's what breaks blades.
To further confuse the issue: I destropy worn out blades with two pairs of needle-nose pliers by "working" the weld. Some will snap right at the weld joint after three or four bends but others will take ten or twenty. More often than you'd expect - the break will occur diagonal to the weld joint. I've even had them break NEXT to the weld (yes, sometimes the weld is actually stronger than the blade itself). Even the best blade suppliers have variances in the quality of their welds. Blade welding at that level is still more art than science and even the average weld is a miracle, given the tension and wear we subject them to.
As to cheap tools: you get what you pay for.
Re: Cutting circles with a bandsaw - interesting.... *LINK*
From a Delta Machinery product information bulletin:
We occasionally receive inquiries concerning short blade life on the 10" and 16", 3-Wheel Band Saws. Below are some thoughts and observations we have put together on the subject that may help you in resolving this type of problem:
...
- Most three wheel band saws utilize smaller diameter wheels than comparable capacity two wheel machines. Therefore, the blade must bend around very small radii three times for each band revolution, as posed to larger radii, two times on a comparable capacity two wheel machine. This condition results in increased blade fatigue which shortens blade life.
- To minimize the impact of the fatigue factor on three wheel machines, we use much thinner (more flexible) blade stock. Delta's 16" model uses blades that are either .018" or .020" thick. The 10" machine uses blades that are only .014" thick.
In addition, I've read information on the sawmill forums indicating a distinct blade life advantage the larger the wheels primarily due to decreased fatigue and work hardening of the blade.
JKJ
Re: Cutting circles with a bandsaw - interesting.... *LINK*
>I have a delta 16" three wheel band saw. I ve had it since the early 1990's. Without going into the technical stuff in the last 10 years of recreational woodworking I've only broken 2 blades on this saw. I feel blade breakage is a non issue. They get dull and rusty long before they break. Regards Edd
Re: Cutting circles with a bandsaw - interesting.... *LINK*
>>Delta is so wrong on so many levels that I don't know
>where to begin so I won't. Good luck with your .014" blade.
>Once again: You get what you pay for.
I personally don't use .014" blades or a three-wheeled bandsaw. You stated "There is no difference between the blade life of a two-wheeled and a three-wheeled bandsaw.". If the contrary opinion is a myth, it is widely shared. For example:
The blade as it travels around the wheel is compressed on the inside of the body, which is closest to the wheel and stretched on the outside of the body. Blades are designed to absorb repeated compression and expansion of the body as long as the compression and expansion does not exceed the steel�s capabilities. Small band saw wheels exceed the steel�s capabilities. Two wheel machines, with smaller than 14" wheels, using 1/8" to 3/4" blades will encounter 20% to 50% less blade life. With machines 14" and larger, you will see blade life increase proportionally. You will encounter decreased blade life with any three-wheel band saw even if the wheels are larger than 14".
...
Everything we sell has an unlimited time and performance guarantee. We guarantee all of our welds except on blades shorter than 65" in length or any blade that has been improperly sharpened. We do not, however, guarantee blades that are run on any three-wheel machine.
http://www.supercutbandsaw.com/how_to_choose.html
SMALL 2 AND 3 WHEEL TABLETOP WOODCUTTING BANDSAWS: Use "The Three Wheeler" Blades
Small tabletop saws with 2 or 3 wheels need a very thin blade, such as our "Three Wheeler" bandsaw blades. The challenge with these saws is that the wheels are so small that a standard thickness blade flexes beyond proper tolerances when it travels around these small wheels, thereby shortening blade life. 'The Three Wheeler' bandsaw blades are designed to withstand this extreme flexing and will give you the longest life on these saws.
Home-Shop Bandsaws, by Jim Cummins, Fine Woodworking Mar. 87
A three-wheeler's small wheels also mean shorter blade life, because the blade must bend abruptly with every revolution. If you want a three-wheel saw, stick to blades under 0.020-in. thick. Your best bet for respectable blade life are the 0.014-in to 0.018-in. thick blades pioneered by Olson (Box 262, Bethel, Conn. 06801).
http://www.woodworking.com/ww101et-band.cfm
Stay away from the three wheel [bandsaw] bench top models. They are notorious for breaking blades due to the small diameter of their wheels.
The New Complete Guide to the Band Saw by Mark Duginske
The three-wheel design has a number of drawbacks: ...and some users report premature blade wear, perhaps due to the fact that the blade must flex more tightly over smaller wheels.
The Bandsaw Book by Lonnie Bird
pg 38: ...Another problem with three-wheel saws is they tend to break blades. This is because the blade is severely stressed as it's flexed around the saw's small-diameter wheels. Manufaturers sidestep this problem by using a thinner 0018-in blade on their three-wheel saws.
>Yes. They they are ALL guilty of perpetuating that myth.
The references you cite are all based on theory and supposition. Nowhere did I see evidence that any scientific testing was performed to prove their statements. You can say "this three-wheeler does this" and "that three-wheeler does that" because "this" and "that" three-wheeler have basic design problems, but you can't condemn them simply because they have three wheels.
If that were so, I'd have been out of business eight years ago instead of steadily growing as I have. Bear in mind that three wheeled saws are out there performing what you would call impossible cuts every day by professional woodworkers who don't care what the "experts" say. They only see massive timbers that need to be cut in intricate detail by whatever tool can get the job done. Occasionally I get a call from a new customer stating that they're having a problem with breaking blades. When I explain the situation in terms of bend radius around the blade guides and how to correctly operate the saw without "leaning" on the pinch rollers, the problem is solved. The blades wear out now before they break. Problem solved.
You can prove this to yourself in your own shop by forcing a blade through blade guides while the blade is trying to drift. Go ahead, put your blade in a little bind. See for yourself how long that weld lasts. I could then come up behind you and say" HA HA The blade broke because you got a two-wheeler!" It makes about as much sense.
I, too, am an "expert". I not only invent, design, and manufacture bandsaws; I test, improve, and answer the phone when a customer is having a problem. I don't base my statements on theory and old wives tales; I test everything for myself and analyze the results first hand. The "experts" you refer to never made the sort of cuts my saws do every day so their expertise is limited, at best, to their experience with two-wheeled name brand saws on relatively simple cuts; and, at worst, by what they read on the factory spec sheets.
My sole purpose here is to educate the broader woodworking community about subjects that seem to confound bandsaw operators of every stripe, not to argue the merits of any one saw or blade. Use this information as you will but don't shoot the messenger. I only report what I see.
Re: Cutting circles with a bandsaw - interesting.... *LINK*
>Bill, I just took a look at your website. Very interesting. I can see that you have accumulated quite a bit of experience in three wheelers, although I would submit that your three wheeler and the usual desk top version most others think of in the discussion are at least a part of a light year apart in concept and implementation. Actually, I suspect yours are subject to more wear and abuse than the average hobbyist's. By that I mean yours clearly are designed to be used on big timber, and probably in quite some quantity. Since we agree on the principle which was the basis of my “Thought Problem” post, I am prepared to concede that the foundation of the myth of inherent three wheeler abuse of blades is most probably, as you say, a function of how they are used rather than a fundamental mechanical/design problem.
I also defer to you as an expert (no italics) as it's clear to me you've spent some time on this. I postulated to John Jordan in a private email that, “I can't rule out…that he [you, Bill] may actually be in a position to know for sure, while some of the sources you [John] cited could conceivably be parroting legendary theories (Byrd, Cummings, Duginske, anonymous at woodworking.com, for example)…”
By the way, I particularly liked the understated point you make on your site about the progression of two wheel design in the last 100 years. Very informative and entertaining site.