Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Which sander - Drum or Belt?

Posts

Which sander - Drum or Belt?

#1

Which sander - Drum or Belt?

Joe Doker

>I will soon be completing a cabinet job and my pay will be a sanding machine. I just need to decide which type to get. Any advice would be appreciated. The two types I am considering are:

6x80 Horizontal belt sander. I'm looking at the Shop Fox W1688. Uses: sanding inside and outside curves,edge sanding. I already have these capabilities via sanding drums for my drill press and a disc for my table saw.

18x36 Drum sander. I'm looking at the Delta 31-255X. Uses: Sanding wide panels, particularly veneers which I am just starting to get into. I currently use a hand belt sander.

Thanks

Re: Which sander - Drum or Belt?

#2

Re: Which sander - Drum or Belt?

Dennis Yoder

>Look at other brands of drum sander before you make up your mind. I have the Delta and have experienced excessive quality problems. Dennis Y

Re: Which sander - Drum or Belt?

#3

Rick L

Re:Stroke sander...

Rick L

>of course. Drum sanders are toys and leave ripples from the drum which need to be random orbit sanded out. A stroke sander will allow you to go right to finishing and they are much cheaper than widebelts. I've seen them used for as little as $200. A great tool only known by pro's and old timers. Still available new from Minimax, Grizzly, etc. Excellent for veneers.

Re: Which sander - Drum or Belt?

#4

Re: Which sander - Drum or Belt?

Bobby

>I wouldn't recommend sanding veneer with a drum sander having done it myself several times. One pass can be too many even with 220 grit on the drum, modern veneer is just to thin to power sand this way. Substrates are rarely perfectly flat after pressing and the drum sander unlike a planer will not push them flat it will just sand extra off the high areas. I would agree though that you should look at the Performax rather than the Delta if you really want one. I have not experienced ridges or marks after drum sanding but I do hand sand pieces after they go through the drum sander.

Bob