Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Question for Howard Acheson or Michael Dresdner *LINK*

Posts

Question for Howard Acheson or Michael Dresdner *LINK*

#1

Question for Howard Acheson or Michael Dresdner *LINK*

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>I have a question about alkyd finishes, specifically alkyd or oil base paint. Not technically wood related, but I gotta think the same principles apply to alkyd varnish and alkyd paint. Is there any difference in the makeup of the film throughout its thickness? In other words, fully cured, is the surface of the film harder than the film interior, or does the surface offer more UV protaction?

The reason for the question relates to being able to sand and rub out the finish. Years ago, someone told me that you really can't rub out an alkyd paint because once you sand off the surface film, the remainder of the finish isn't hard enough to hold a shine - it will dull due to oxidation once the protective outer film is gone. I'd like to know if that's true or if the guy was just giving incorrect advice.

I came across the link below where this young man from Canada has painted a number of cars with Tremclad, which is the trade name for Rustoleum in Canada. And he did this with a roller. He put on thin coats, color sanded between coats and rubbed out just like you'd do with a lacquer job. He claims he's able to paint a car for $50. Now the pictures in the link below indicate you can indeed achieve some pretty impressive results.

You need to scroll down in the message thread link to the response by "69chargeryeehaa". What I'm wondering is, what are these cars going to look like a year or two later? Is there something about removing the outer film skin that will make these finishes more susceptible to dulling by oxidation?


Message thread about budget painting a car

Re: Question for Howard Acheson or Michael Dresdner *LINK*

#2

the lowdown

Michael Dresdner

>>> Years ago, someone told me that you really can't rub out an alkyd paint because once you sand off the surface film, the remainder of the finish isn't hard enough to hold a shine. Is there something about removing the outer film skin that will make these finishes more susceptible to dulling by oxidation?

If you are a particularly inept formulator and don't understand the difference between top driers and through driers, you can in theory create a paint that will top cure way before it cures throughout, but it will eventually cure throughout. That would, for a time at least, mean that sanding the top skin might reveal less cured film beneath, and yes, a less cured or softer film is much more difficult to rub to gloss than a hard one.

Fortunately, though, most of the formulators at work in the field are not inept, and most paints are designed to cure through rather than having only the outer skin cure. Rustoleum formulators are, IMO, particularly good, so it certainly would not be a problem with Rustoleum paints.

Re: Question for Howard Acheson or Michael Dresdner *LINK*

#3

to answer the underlying question

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>What will the car look like after XX years?. What does a porch railing or lawn chair look like after 3 years painted with Rustoleum? A $4 can of paint is not going to have the stabilizers and resins that will last for 20 years like a quality automotive paint and primer. If inexpensive paint worked for automotive application it would not cost $100/gallon or more to buy automotive paint.

As far as rubbing alkyd varnish- whether it is practical or not will depend on the resins used in the formulation (whether they are hard or not).