Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Another novice question...

Posts

Another novice question...

#1

Another novice question...

Steve Yakoban

>Working on this little cabinet for my wife in my limited shop I've encountered a new problem.

She wants adjustable shelves so I got a shelf pin jig/drill bit and started drilling the 1/4" holes into the poplar and had troubles. Some are sloppy and some are OK. Was shelf pins in a soft wood a bad idea or am I just doing something completely wrong?

Is there a better way to make adjustable shelves in a poplar cabinet without putting in rows of cleats?

Thanks guys!

Re: Another novice question...

#2

What kind of drill bit?

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Did you use plain old twist bits or brad point bits? With brad points and a fairly fast drill (cordlesses are often too slow), I would think you shouldn't have had a problem. Twist drills, on the other hand, can be a little rough on the edges.

Also, but not germane to what you asked—in a small cabinet I would think you would only have needed three or four sets of the holes. Not that much room for adjustment in a small cabinet.

Rod

Re: Another novice question...

#3

possible save.....

R. Lance in GR, Michigan

>since you've reached out, we'll be there cause you're in danger of being left in the shadows of love and living in seven rooms of gloom if this project doesn't please Bernadett....err SWMBO....there is a little brass sleave that can be fitted into each hole you've drilled and it remains there...then pins can be placed in that sleeve and there is no wear and tear on that soft poplar....look for this product at Rockler or Woodcraft (or maybe here)....so remember when you think you are big enough to go it alone....do what you did and ask....hope this helps.

Re: Another novice question...

#4

Re: Another novice question... *LINK*

Jim Dillon

>Morning Steve,

There was a thread on this topic a few months ago. If I remember right, the general conclusion was to use a good quality bradpoint bit and a drill press to get the speed you need. If you don't have a drill press, try to use an electric drill (rather than a battery powered one) as others have said. In my clumsy hands, I have found it difficult to hold a handheld drill very steady which might increase the chance for tearout. At least with a drill press, I have found that going more slowly during the initial penetration into the wood helps to minimize tearout. Here is a link to various shelf supports including the brass liners previous mentioned. The slight lip on these liners might cover up any tearout you are getting. But then you may need a different size bit, which then means you need a different size hole template etc etc. It is kind of a catch-22. You might also try putting a piece of masking tape right where the hole will be to minimize tearout. And Rod's suggestion to think out exactly how many holes you really need is valid. Having just a few hole strategically placed will save you a lot of effort. Lee Valley's brad point bits are quite good IMOH. Good luck.

Jim


Lee Valley Shelf Supports

Re: Another novice question...

#5

Also, middle is fixed

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>In small cabinets, sometimes the middle shelf is fixed, and the others are adjustable.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Another novice question...

#6

Re: Another novice question...

Barry Irby

>An alternative is ratchet strip. The strips that are 5/8" wide and about 1/8" thick. They have a row of slots that engage clips that allow you to adjust shelves in about half inch increments. Knapp Voight (sp? aka KV) and others make it. You can use a router to let it into the side. I usually let them in slightly less than their thickness so that they are just "proud" of the surface so that the ends of the shelves do not touch the sides. I see these as less "elegant" than the way you are doing it, but they are very functional and would allow you to run the strips over you row of holes and hide them if they are unsightly.

Re: Another novice question...

#7

Re: What kind of drill bit?

Steve Yakoban

>Thanks a lot guys. Number one issue: I did use a cordless drill. The jig came with the centering bit which is a brad point. I think I have enough extra material to replace the messed up piece, but I'm nervous... My wife has a faux painter scheduled to paint it and another piece I'm reassembling in a week!

I think I'm in a little over my head because I have 3 other issues:

1. The plywood top is designed to sit on the legs (stiles) which I was going to glue down to the top ends. Is that strong enough or should there be a better mechanical attachment?

2. The door (in blue) was originally intended to be inset, but I realized that's asking for trouble, so I want it to be a part overlay door. I know I can router a back cut on the outer edge but is that totally dependent on what hinges are used?

3. I'm planning on using 3/4" MDF for the back since I have it. Is that overkill or is it OK? I don't have any more finished plywood so would something else be more appropriate?


img

Re: Another novice question...

#8

Re: What kind of drill bit?

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Overlay doors are dependent on the hinges used. The dimensions are 3/8" x 3/8". It's standard.

But here is a rule that will help keep you on the straight and narrow in future projects. Get the hardware first. That way design issues, milling issues, assembly issues, finishing issues, etc. can all be worked out in advance. Not to mention having the customer, err..LOYL from being unhappy that the hardware picked out is no longer manufactured or on indefinite backorder. Also tends to preclude mind changing as the expenditure is already made. hehehe...

Re: Another novice question...

#9

Re: Another novice question...

DizD

>I just finished a set of holes using a 1/4" forstner bit using a cordless drill. Holes look great, but I haven't put a shelf up yet.