Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Biscuits or not? Help!

Posts

Biscuits or not? Help!

#1

Biscuits or not? Help!

Steve Yakoban

>I'm putting together a 41" tall little book cabinet for my wife, made of s4s poplar I purchased and had the panel grooves cut for me. I have a limited shop (no router table) so these wood projects are done with what tools I have.

I was going to join the front and side leg with 3 biscuits per pair (see image) but have been reading that biscuits are more of an alignment mechanism rather than a means to add strength. Is that true? I think I can do the alignment without biscuits and would skip them if they don't add strength. Will the 41" long joints stay together over time just with yellow glue? Should I skip the biscuits?

Thanks guys!


img

Re: Biscuits or not? Help!

#2

Ellis Walentine

Not

Ellis Walentine

>As long as the grain is going in the same direction (up/down, long grain), the glue alone will be stronger than the wood itself. Skip the biscuits in this case.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Biscuits or not? Help!

#3

Another option

Jim in N. Va.

>I agree with Ellis, no biscuits. If you are concerned about maintaining alighnment during glue-up, there is another (easier) way. In the area that is to be glued on one leg drive in a couple of small brads. Leave them proud and clip the heads off, leaving very small points exposed. When you glue the two pieces together the points will prevent any slippage between the pieces.

Re: Biscuits or not? Help!

#4

Re: Another option: A few grains of sand

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: Biscuits or not? Help!

#5

Lee Grindinger

Do you remember

Lee Grindinger

>Graham Blackburn did an article for FWW (I believe) on dining chairs joined with butts and biscuits. It was right before one of his trips to England. I wanted to discuss that with him but never had the chance.

Lee

Re: Biscuits or not? Help!

#6

Re: Do you remember

Thomas S Stockton

>Lee

I want to know how the chairs are holding up over time. I think they have probably been rebuilt or are pretty wobbly. All the tests FWW have done on joinery strength miss a really important one and that's how many stress cycles they can go through. They need to get one of those chair stress machines from Ikea and see what happens. theres just not a whole lot of surface area in a biscut. I knew someone who made a really nice dining table and joined the legs and apron with biscuts and after about a year you could tell they were starting to give way, they had't failed but the joint was starting to lose rigidity.

Tom

Re: Biscuits or not? Help!

#7

Ellis Walentine

I don't recall that...

Ellis Walentine

>...but, personally, I would always prefer a double loose tenon joint for a dining chair. Biscuits add glueing surface area, which holds shoulders tight, but they are still quite small relative to a well-designed loose tenon joint. Plus, they are thin, so if twisting forces on a small-shouldered joint like a leg-rail joint come into play, they will not offer as much mechanical strength as a pair of solid, long-grain tenons.

Only a controlled experiment will shed more light on the subject.

Ellis

Re: Biscuits or not? Help!

#8

Lee Grindinger

Between you and me and the fly on the wall

Lee Grindinger

>I was quite surprised it was published. I figured Graham was just trying to raise a few bucks for his trip. This article appeared quite a few years ago. They were sturdy chairs with a good stretcher assembly below but the critical joints were all biscuits.

But, E-Man, isn't a biscuit nothing more than a loose tenon joint?

Heh, heh, he...,

Lee

Re: Biscuits or not? Help!

#9

Ellis Walentine

Biscuits and loose tenons

Ellis Walentine

>You're absolutely right about biscuits being a subset of loose tenon joints. But the tenacity of the joint depends on the glue area. When I make loose tenons for cabinet doors or leg-rail joints, the tenon(s) are as big as the space allows, meaning they go deeper into the wood than a biscuit. Also, with a reasonable fit, a loose tenon also supplies mechanical strength against racking vertically or laterally. Double the tenons and you further double the glueline area and mechanical advantage.

A chair joint is a particularly vulnerable one, because the end of the shoulder becomes a fulcrum, and the length of the leg becomes a quite lengthy lever arm. Glue surface and glueline strength are finite and variable; the more the merrier. As old screwball Archimedes said, "Give me a place to stand and a lever long enough and I will move the world."

:-)

Re: Biscuits or not? Help!

#10

Lee Grindinger

Yup,

Lee Grindinger

>I agree with you actually. I was just yanking your chain. Back in my days in a production shop we used Lamellos. They fit the slot so poorly, much poorer than your worst loose tenon I'd guess, that they were not terribly effective in lining up edges. The rationale was that the biscuits were compressed and as soon as the moisture from the glue hit them they'd swell and fit the slots better. I always had my doubts but I'm sure Lamello preferred to err on the side of being too skinny over being too fat.

Lee