Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Finnishes " Old " & " New " . . .

Posts

Finnishes " Old " & " New " . . .

#1

Finnishes " Old " & " New " . . .

SteveM

>Pondering to much is like thinking too much, yes ? After years of trying to explain clear finnishes to others it seems each generation has its own term for these. Much like skillet & frying pan, britches & pants, etc. My Grandpa always said shelac (sp?), Dad always said varnish, as do I. Urathane just sounds to modern. The best I've come up with for SIMPLE terms is this : shelac is animal based, varnish is petroleum based, urathane is "plastic" based. Ignoring whatever carrier is used and in-depth chemistry how far off would this explanation be for the un-initiated ?

( let 'er rip ! )

Re: Finnishes " Old " & " New " . . .

#2

Jesper, Denmark

There is nothing new..........

Jesper, Denmark

>I believe there are basically only two types: One, where the resin is dissolved in a solvent, which evaporates and leaves the resin film behind. This is like Shellac and a few others.

The other, which is most common, has a chemical change, where some long chain molecules cross-link and form the resin. This is like urethane, where a polyol and an isocyanate recat to form the polyurethane molecule. The drying oils, like tung and linseed are really also in this category, as they do crosslink under the influence of oxygen in the air and form a new substance.

The first category is reversible - you can re-dissolve the shellac in alcohol again. The second is not reversible.

They are all "plastic" mixtures of Hydrogen and carbon with sometimes a few other molecules included for fun.

Not quite what you asked for, but.............

Re: Finnishes " Old " & " New " . . .

#3

better way to catagorize

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>To elaborate some on what Jesper reported, which is a nice summary of the situation. A finish is typically a mixture of some film forming material and a solvent.

Shellac- a bug secretion dissolved in solvent. Solvent evaporates and leaves behind the film. No chemical reaction involved.

lacquer- a synthetic polymer(plastic) dissolved in solvent. Solvent evaporates and leaves behind the film. No chemical reaction involved. Nitrocellulose lacquer, perhaps the most common kind, is a reaction product of nitric acid and cellulose from trees. Modern lacquers , for example acrylic, are petroleum based.

varnish- solution of some resin and solvent. Upon exposure to air the resin undergoes a chemical reaction to make an insoluble polymer(plastic) film. This reaction will occur whether the solvent evaporates or not, but the solvent must evaporate for the film to get hard. (note that varnish will set up in the can after exposure to air even in the presence of solvent) The resin historically was derived mostly from combinations of plant oils and resins. But again, the modern resins, like urethane, are derived from petroleum.

Re: Finnishes " Old " & " New " . . .

#4

Re: better way to catagorize

Howard Acheson

>>> varnish- solution of some resin and solvent.

Just a clerification, varnish is a mixture of resin (alkyd, phenolic, urethane) and a drying oil (linseed, tung, soya) which are mixed as they are heated together until they form a new compound called varnish. As it comes out the pot, the newly made varnish is very thick so a thinner (mineral spirits, naphtha and/or other petroleum products) is added to make it thin enough to be brushed.

Alkyd, phenolic and urethane are all "plastics" so all varnishes can be called "plastic".

Urethane resin and linseed oil are the least cost raw materials so that is why most of the varnishes are made with those two components.

As to how it dries/cures, the thinner first evaporates at which time the finish becomes tack free. It then goes through an oxidation process using the oxygen in the air to completely cure and develop its strength, hardness and adhesion.

Re: Finnishes " Old " & " New " . . .

#5

not quite

Michael Dresdner

>>> the modern resins, like urethane, are derived from petroleum

Oil based urethanes are made from natural plant oils, usually either linseed or soya, not from petroleum.

Re: Finnishes " Old " & " New " . . .

#6

Naming gestalt (long)

Michael Dresdner

>Sadly, we do not use a consistent naming gestalt. We usually categorize finishes in three ways: by how they cure (go from liquid to solid), by what they contain, and by their intended use. Three approaches causes a lot of confusing overlap. The first makes the most sense. Here's a breakdown.

By How They Cure

Lacquer cures by solvent evaporation only. Some waterbased finishes that coalesce also do so only by losing solvents. By this definition, shellac is a lacquer.

Varnish, which includes conversion varnish and the misnamed catalyzed lacquer, cures by polymerization, which means forming larger molecules from smaller ones through chemical linking. That can be done by taking oxygen or moisture from the air or by combining two or more reactive chemicals. Some waterbased coatings polymerize after some or all of the solvents or additives have evaporated.

High tech energy cured coatings cure by polymerization but unlike varnish, require outside energy sources above and beyond STP to initiate the cure. They may use infrared or convection heat, electron beam or ultraviolet light, or other. Coatings cured by natural sunlight can be considered a subset of this group, or a subset of the previous group -- your choice.

Naming by ingredient

What is really confusing is when we start talking about finishes by what is in them, often without really understanding that we are talking about only one of many components. For example, polyurethane means the finish contains polyurethane resin or creates it during cure. Shellac contains shellac resin. Acrylic lacquer contains acrylic resin. Alkyd varnish contains alkyd resin. Paint, though, is a general term for any coating that is opaque no matter how it cures and no matter what it contains other than opaque pigments. The worst is waterbased finishes, which do contain water but can also contain virtually any resin from epoxy resins to polymethylmethacrylate and anything in between, and can be any of the three curing types as well.

Some terms imply almost nothing at all. Danish oil does not contain either oil pressed from unwilling Danes, nor oil that came from Denmark. At the moment, common usage defines it as a wipe on oil based varnish. Teak Oil means exterior finish to some manufacturers and furniture polish to others, but in any case contains nothing from the tree that gives us teak wood.

Naming by usage

Spar varnish or spar urethane implies only that it is an exterior varnish. Originally it meant tung oil and phenolic boat varnish, but today the term is used simply to mean 'outdoor finish.' Wipe on finish tells you nothing about it but how it is applied.

As for the term 'plastic,' it has a very particular meaning in the finishing world. It means 'flexible.' Using it as a noun is very ambiguous since so many plastics (flexible solids) are formed from chemical reactions, and their appearances and properties vary tremendously. Curiously, the term first became popular in association with early cellulose nitrate solid objects made from the same materials nitrocellulose lacquer is formed from today, which, ironically, is not what today's finishers refer to as 'a plastic finish.'