I think you're asking for trouble
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>Beyond cutting the pieces to get a tight joint, there's the issue of wood movement. You can see mitered mouldings open up on the outside or the inside of the joint, depending on the season, and these are not nearly as wide as a counter top... Think for a moment that a 45 degree miter will be about 34 inches long on a 24" deep counter top, and a 22.5 degree one will be 26"... Even if you use cherry, which is a relatively stable species, you will end up with gaps over time as the seasons fluctuate. At that scale there's no escaping that fact...
In the first house I bought 15 years ago, the counter tops were made of red oak (not my choice...). At the time I knew little about woodworking, and thought that the installers were lazy in butting the different parts instead of making nice miters. Over time I realized that this is the only way to keep reasonably tight joints, by butting the different sections together, with some kind of flexible sealing compound that can withstand wood movement.
The only way I can see to keep tight mitered corners over time is to attach the two mitered parts in a manner that lets both parts move with the seasons, like a number of biscuits, a bunch of pocket hole screws or a spline (warning, it needs to be cut across the grain, not a long grain one). Since we're talking end grain here (or close to), there's not much point in gluing anything other than the biscuits or splines, depending on your joinery choice (pocket screws will gain next to nothing from glue).
Now you have a tight joint. But this joint will still want to move, which means that one of the two parts requires freedom of movement, otherwise your joint will open up. That requires that some of the counter top parts be left free to move, which creates problems with the back splash and all, unless you're doing an island. Not very practical... I have a hard time making out the geometry here, but with two 4' long sections (for example)mitered at 45 degrees, I wouldn't be surprised if the "loose" section moves by more than 1/2" (in or out relative to the cabinet it stands on) over a year... That could look silly...
If someone has managed to make solid wood counter tops with mitered corners that have remained tight over the years, I sure would like to know about it...
DC