Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

cherry countertop

Posts

cherry countertop

#1

cherry countertop

stew

>Hello, I am making a solid cherry counter top. I am exploring the best way to cut and join a 45 miter and 22.5 miter. The counter top will be 8ft long joined to a 4ft piece etc... Any ideas on the best way to cut this and join them? I am thinking Kreg jig but would like to get a very tight fit. Use template? etc...

Thanks,

Stew

Re: cherry countertop

#2

I think you're asking for trouble

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>Beyond cutting the pieces to get a tight joint, there's the issue of wood movement. You can see mitered mouldings open up on the outside or the inside of the joint, depending on the season, and these are not nearly as wide as a counter top... Think for a moment that a 45 degree miter will be about 34 inches long on a 24" deep counter top, and a 22.5 degree one will be 26"... Even if you use cherry, which is a relatively stable species, you will end up with gaps over time as the seasons fluctuate. At that scale there's no escaping that fact...

In the first house I bought 15 years ago, the counter tops were made of red oak (not my choice...). At the time I knew little about woodworking, and thought that the installers were lazy in butting the different parts instead of making nice miters. Over time I realized that this is the only way to keep reasonably tight joints, by butting the different sections together, with some kind of flexible sealing compound that can withstand wood movement.

The only way I can see to keep tight mitered corners over time is to attach the two mitered parts in a manner that lets both parts move with the seasons, like a number of biscuits, a bunch of pocket hole screws or a spline (warning, it needs to be cut across the grain, not a long grain one). Since we're talking end grain here (or close to), there's not much point in gluing anything other than the biscuits or splines, depending on your joinery choice (pocket screws will gain next to nothing from glue).

Now you have a tight joint. But this joint will still want to move, which means that one of the two parts requires freedom of movement, otherwise your joint will open up. That requires that some of the counter top parts be left free to move, which creates problems with the back splash and all, unless you're doing an island. Not very practical... I have a hard time making out the geometry here, but with two 4' long sections (for example)mitered at 45 degrees, I wouldn't be surprised if the "loose" section moves by more than 1/2" (in or out relative to the cabinet it stands on) over a year... That could look silly...

If someone has managed to make solid wood counter tops with mitered corners that have remained tight over the years, I sure would like to know about it...

DC

Re: cherry countertop

#3

Re: what I did

Dave Mount

>I made a cherry bar top that was on a diagonal island, so it had a main run of about 6 feet then turned 45 degrees on both ends for another run of about 2 feet. I stewed about the construction for quite a while, because I was concerned about all the miter issues Denis discusses. In the end, I made it all out of planks glued up parallel -- I just edge glued on some triangular pieces to fill out the "ears" rather than miter a big plank. Because of this, there's no miter to open up seasonally. You still have to allow for expansion, but it's all in one direction, not several. I put slotted holes in the support brackets to accommodate this movement.

Best,

Dave

Re: cherry countertop

#4

Re: cherry countertop

GregR

>Here's one way to connect the miters together and should hold pretty good.

http://www.rockler.com/product.cfm?page=10770

Re: cherry countertop

#5

Re: I think you're asking for trouble

Randy Stukenberg

>I put cherry countertops in my house about two years ago. The island top is about 36" wide with a cap on the ends. So far. the most seasonal movement I have seen is about 1/16" over the width. I glued the cap in the middle only. and in the summer humisity, I it expands about 1/32" past the end of the cap.

Maybe I'm lucky, or just find good kiln dried wood, but in 17 years of working with wood, I have never seen wood move near as much as the magazines and books say it will.

I have one corner that ended up with a short "ear" next to the stove. I decided to keep the grain consistent with the rest of the counter on the other side of the stove. As a result, the grain runs perpendicular to the top it joins with. I glued it at the front, and used biscuits to keep it level, and pocket screws to hold it together. So far no problems.

Re: cherry countertop

#6

Re: cherry countertop

Paul Dwight

>I made an L-shaped kitchen table 8 or 9 years ago. The two legs of the L are joined with what is effectively a breadboard "end." This is going to be hard to describe without a picture, but here goes: The two legs of the L-shaped table top form a 90-degree angle. Where the two sections of the top meet, I cut each section to 45-degrees and milled a tongue on the ends. Then I took another piece of stock about 4" wide and milled a matching groove on each side. The tongues fit into the grooves and are pinned at each end and in the middle, using elongated holes on the ends to allow for wood movement. The grain of the 4" breadboard "end" runs parallel to the joint, and at 45-degrees to the grain of each section of the top.

The breadboard joint has held up fine. As with any breadboard detail, the field of the top is sometimes wider than the end cap and is sometimes narrower than the end cap. If you can't live with the change in appearance as the top expands and contracts, you should avoid breadboard ends.

This has worked fine for our kitchen table, but for a countertop I would be concerned about the long-term effect of water getting into the joint. Would the tongue swell enough to crack the end cap? Would you have to worry about rot? I just don't know.

Good luck! -- Paul

Re: cherry countertop

#7

Ellis Walentine

Here's how to do it...

Ellis Walentine

>Denis' caveat is correct, provided you anchor both legs of the counter to the cabinets below. If, however, you join the miter together with a continuous cross-grain spline and boatbuilder's epoxy, along with a couple K-V Tite-Joint fasteners or their Hafele equivalent, *AND* you let the whole system float, it will never have the tiniest gap anywhere along the joint line.

It's easy to design for this, too. All you have to do is have the back edges and the ends of your slabs hidden under backsplash moldings or housed in dados in your adjacent cabinet sides, with enough headroom to allow for the corner to fluctuate between, say 89� and 91�, and you're home free. Use figure-8 connectors to join the top to the cabinets and allow for the seasonal movement.

The kitchen shown below has a mahogany countertop built exactly as I've described.

Ellis Walentine, Host


img

Re: cherry countertop

#8

Re: Here's how to do it...

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>No question that the pictured kitchen is an eye-catcher. However, the engineering and construction demands of producing the mitered counter joint leads one to wonder if the effort, compounded by the long term maintenance of the finish, is really worth it. Given the variety of more impervious and stable counter top alternatives, does the choice of wood become an affectation?

That said, I admit to recently pre-fabbing a bathroom vanity counter top from white ash, albeit sans miters.

Clint

Re: cherry countertop

#9

Re: Here's how to do it...

stew

>thanks for the information.

Re: cherry countertop

#10

Ellis Walentine

Wood countertops

Ellis Walentine

>There's no doubt that other countertop materials have some advantages over wood, but a lot of people just like the soft resiliency of wood as opposed to the hardness of granite, concrete, solid surface materials ... even Formica. Whatever the customer wants is fine with me.

It isn't too difficult to make and finish a wooden countertop, but you have to treat it like any other engineering problem. Allowing for miter movement is only one aspect. You also have to seal the piece well on both sides and particularly around the sink opening. I use boatbuilder's epoxy for that, too.

Maintenance depends on the kind of use/abuse you subject the countertop to. Some people treat their counters like actual butcher blocks, to the point of actually cutting on them with knives. Used this way, a counter gets pretty funky in a hurry. I'd use mineral oil on raw wood for this kind of application. Replenish it when necessary. (You still need to seal the edge grain around any openings with epoxy.)

Most folks, though, opt for a varnish finish, and they do their cutting on a cutting board. Softer varnishes like Waterlox give the wood a less formal feel, because they are not as resistant to abrasion as are polyurethanes and conversion varnishes.

Ironically, I'm about to replace the countertop in my own kitchen, and I'm seriously considering a fake granite. Costwise and maintenance-wise, I think I'll come out on top. It'll take some getting used to, though.

Ellis