Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Insulation opinions wanted - OT

Posts

Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#1

Insulation opinions wanted - OT

Dan Manturi

>Ongoing saga of my kids home. He has rock wool, about 50 years old, which means useless insulation. The area is immense by my standards - probably 1000 square feet. i figure that fiberglass batts may be a little more effective than blown in stuff but for an area that size. It may also be a great deal more expensive, but I am not sure. I am going on the net to look for more info but of course will take advantage of the expertise and experience here. Someone said something about DIY blown in insulation - i though that was strictly a pro install.

Any advice would be appreciated and thanks again for this forum.

Dan M.

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#2

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

Dan Manturi

>Just to add - they do have an attic fan, ridge and eave vents. Fan my not be a huge issue with blown in stuff but I am not sure. Batts seem a lot of work and access up there is small space via a closet.

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#3

Long story

Neal in San Jose

>You can do blown-in DIY. Many years and a couple of houses ago, I did just that. I got the insulation at a local outlet where they would loan me a blower to install the stuff. Seemed easy enough; just put the blower at ground level with a helper to rip open the bags of insulation and keep the hopper filled, and I'd be in the attic with the business end of about 100 feet of flex hose that the insulation would come out of. Since the thing sounded a lot like a 747 winding up for take-off, we decided we'd need some sort of communication, so I ran the power cord for the blower up to the attic and plugged it into the trouble light I was using as my only light source. Thus, I could unplug the blower when I needed the insulation to stop coming.

All was working pretty well. I was gingerly walking doubled over on the ceiling joists, trying to keep from bashing my head against the rafters and blowing insulation in a fairly even layer. Until I backed into the trouble light hanging on one of the rafters. It fell. It broke. It got really dark. The insulation kept coming while I tried to find the stupid trouble light so I could unplug the blower without falling thru the sheetrock into the room below. Finally found a wire and followed it to the trouble light and unplugged the blower. It seemed like that took about 15 minutes, but it was probably more like one minute, but an amazing amount of insulation got blown against one end wall of the attic. I decided that area couldn't possibly be better insulated and I continued on. We did have to take about a 10 minute break while my helper rolled on the ground laughing.

So, yes it is a DIY project. Wear a good dust mask and have TWO light sources. Or think of some other way to let your helper know to STOP!

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#4

Lots of conflicting info out there...

John in New Mexico

>Hard to say whats best. Some guys (pros) will tell you that blown in FG is better than cellulose, some will tell you the opposite. I've heard some say batts are better, as blown in will settle, but then I've also read that the R values listed on blown in insulation are "post settling". I've been told that cellulose is a fire hazard, but I've also read that the boric acid its treated with acts both as an insect repellent and also a fire retardant (forms a glass as it melts, starving the budding embers of oxygen - same reason it works as a high temp soldering flux). I've heard that the retardants break down over time, though I know boric acid does not. Its a confusing industry.

Cellulose is certainly cheap and easy. Batts are neither, I think blown in FG is about the same as batts cost wise, and as easy as cellulose. Might have more trouble finding supplies/blower for fiberglass, our local Home Depot & Lowes both sell cellulose and rent/loan the blower.

IIRC, for say, R-40, batting should cost you around $1000 for cheap stuff, 10-20% more for pink. Cellulose from the home center would run about $750, including the machine time. Those figures though are just guesses based on local markets, prices when I was insulating our house, etc, and are not hard and fast guides.

Good luck with it,

John

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#5

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I blew cellulose insulation in my (115+ year old) house walls and attic. I used batt insulation in my new shop walls but did blow cellulose in the attic area. In the last two years we insulated my youngest sons house (batts in the wall - cellulose in the attic. It is not a real complicated job. I do have a question - why do you think the rock wool is no longer good? As it is an inert material I would think it would be fine unless it is wet. It may have settled and require the addition of more insulation but I can't see it not being "good" insulation.

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#6

Re: My neighbor just did his house

Glenn Madsen near San Francisco

>about 1800 sq ft, single story. For $1000, the fellow came in, did the place to r30 something, cleaned up, and was gone before 10 am.

There is no way that DIY makes much sense to me, based on the prices I've seen around here. The pros get such a better deal on materials, in a competitive market, that it makes sense.

Now, if one were to wait until say, November, ...

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#7

Re: My neighbor just did his house

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>I blew in the insulation for my shop, about 850 square feet.

In researching the best approach I found one website that was run by a building inspector. He said that in a very high percentage of the homes he inspected the R value of blown insulation in the attic was not what the homeowner thought it was. Why? Because the contractor shorted the homeowner on the ammount that was blown in. Supporting this is my own experience.

When I first started the renovation of the building I had no idea how much of a money pit the project was going to turn into and asked a local contractor what it would cost to blow the insulation (attic only) to R 30 in a building that size. He gave me a price of $200. When the time came to do the job I did some checking and made an interesting discovery. Doing it myself was going to cost over $200 just for the insulation. The only way the contractor could have done it for his price and made any money on the deal was to give me a lower R value than I wanted.

I wound up with more than R 30 in several places because it's really hard to get the stuff even. As it has already been noted, visibility ain't that great when the stuff starts flying out the hose. Nonetheless, it's still a reasonably simple job that anyone in average physical conditon can do themselves.

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#8

Rock wool thin - backing shot

Dan manturi

>The rock wool may have been 3 inches when new, seems to have settled way low. paper is brittle and cracking. It will be left in place, however, no matter what is done, but it was not much in the first place.

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#9

Re: Rock wool thin - backing shot

Barry Irby

>I have dealt with insulation for thirty some years as a Builder and Home Inspector. My experience has been that this is something you can get done by the pro's almost as cheap as doing it yourself. The big installers buy insulation by the carload, quantities larger than the Borgs and get it cheaper than they do. The builder/new home market is very competitive. So, they will install it and charge you about what you pay at the Borg.

Just had this confirmed. Working on rehabbing a rental house, decided to upgrade the ceiling and insulate under the floor. (1100 SF) Took a quick look at the Borg and found the bats were going to cost me about a buck a foot for the combined total. Called the insulator that used to do my work when I was building and he bid $1129. I told him to go ahead. No way I am doing that much work for 25 or 50 bucks. When I confirmed the order, he asked if I used to be a builder and dint he used to do my work and knocked off $200. Now I am really happy. Saved money and work.

One thing in your favor is that the building industry is really slow and you have a chance to shop this.

All the things mentioned in other posts are true. Batts are more effective per inch, but more expensive. Usually its a wash on "R" value. 6" batts cost X and 9" blown also costs X, but both are about the same "R".

As a Home Inspector I see a lot of houses that thought they had R-19 or R-30 and I can tell it settled. (That's why I added to the ceiling in the rental house I was working on. I should have had R-19, but it had settled to about half that.)

It's easy for insulators to cheat. They over-fluff the blown stuff and it appears to be 10" or whatever and later it settles more than it should. Also, on floors I have seen them "peel" the batts. They put a few full thickness ones near the door and then take the rest and peel off about half the fiberglass and use it to insulate the adjacent space.

I personally like cellulose, but it is more controversial. On the plus side it is a recycled product. It is denser than fiberglass and less subject to air currents wafting through robbing the R value. Its less itchy. OTOH, unless properly treated it will burn and is subject to termites and rotting.

This is a nasty itchy job I would hire done if I could. Will they scant you or cheat you? Maybe, but they also know how to get it in in a nice even layer and you don't. You are in the steep part of the learning curve. You could scant yourself and not even know it.

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#10

A few other things to consider

Keith Newton

>I agree that having others do it is a good idea, however there are a few more things to think about and watch out for.

Last year when we built our camp, we used trusses, which were all 2 x 4 material, and we had 12" of blown-in.

Above each eve vent, I tacked on some scrap paneling to the bottom of the rafter to keep the air path open, otherwise the insulation may just blow in and close that off, or the man on the hose may need to leave it thin near each of those vents.

I got up there with some used lumber to build a cat-walk down most of the length of the house for moving around without packing it down for the inevitable alterations like pulling extra wires like speakers etc.

While they were blowing it in, I got up there with the guy, and measured the depth several places while the guy was working, and made him add more when I found the depth didn't meet our agreed depth. As Barry or someone else said, it is hard to tell once the space starts getting filled.

I think in the future, I will even get in there ahead of time with a crayon and a gauge stick, and put a mark on everything that I could reach, for a reference.

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#11

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

Lee Ohmart

>In my present home, the former owner blew in some insulation over the existing standard fiberglass. The combination was not doing the job so I installed 8 in batts over the mess. This really warmed things up in winter and kept things a lot cooler in summer. I don't know what the blown in stuff is but I wish I could get rid of it. Every time I go up there to do wiring, I have to wear a respirator or I can feel the stuff in my throat and lungs. A parent in the Boy Scout troop I am associated with is a foam insulation installer. He built a house using 2x4 construction and pumped his walls full of his product. The result is an R value equal to 2x6 construction with fiberglass insulation. Not only is the R-value good but his walls are sealed to drafts.

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#12

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

Dan Manturi

>Thanks for all this input. i think the next step is to look at some local contractors. Get some sticks, mark them, nail them up to ensure we are getting what we want. Will also price DIY methods, but frankly it seems that having a pro blow in the insulation is the best way all around. Cellulose sounds interesting if fire retardant is used. Fiberglass is also always an option but it is lighter and you'd need a deeper blanket as well as potential flying around from the whole house fan.

Dan M.

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#13

Rock Wool may contain asbestos

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>You don't want to disturb it (which will happen with either blown-in or batts) or remove it yourself. Perhaps someone has suggestions on dealing with it?

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#14

Re: Rock Wool may contain asbestos

Dan Manturi

>Well, we sure do not want to move it. Will put new stuff right over it. Were not planning to mess with it in any case.

Thanks for the info.

Dan

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#15

Why do you think so?

John in New Mexico

>Most industry sources I've seen don't even address this, and there isn't concensus on whether rock wool or slag wool are carcinogenic themselves.

Just wondering if you've got some further info.

John

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#16

Re: Rock Wool may contain asbestos

Dan Manturi

>Well, I do not know one way or the other what may have been in rock wool back in 1957, but the stuff is so old an dry, I do not want to move it cause of the mess. perhaps the gentleman who suggested it may have asbestos may have insight. I guess back in 1957, there were a lot of things in stuff that is prohibited now.

On the other hand, I smoked for many years and still drink a lot of diet soda. Like well marbled beef and pork products.

Heck, I am probably a time bomb anyhow, but my kid and his fiance are a different metric altogether..

Dan M

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#17

I'd leave it in place...

John in New Mexico

>Both rock wool and slag wool are manufactured products that have been produced since the late 1800's. Both are spun "glass" fibers, and I would speculate that slag wool would be the more dangerous of the two as slags tend to have all sorts of metal oxides in them. Thats not to say, however, that it should greatly concern you. Rock wool does indeed sound like another name for asbestiform minerals, but it is instead a product manufactured by melting basalts and other low temperature igneous rocks (chosen for their low melting temps), and using the melt to make a fiberglass.

No reason I can see to remove the stuff, just adds a bit more insulation.

John

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#18

Jesper, Denmark

Nonsense......

Jesper, Denmark

>There is no asbestos in Rockwool.

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#19

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT *LINK*

Mark Nowicki

>You don't need to that yourself. Any reputable insulation contractor will have his own depth gauges.

Mark


Example of depth gauges

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#20

Re: Nonsense......

Mark Harrison - Brisbane, Australia

>That's a pretty definitive response!

I don't know whether it is or it isn't. However, given the crazy places that asbestos was used in Australia (and I imagine that the USA was no different) I would not be taking any chances unless I knew for certain. For instance, it was used in linoleum floor tiles in Australia until at least the 1970's. I have no idea how this could have improved the product but that's what they did.

Asbestos wasn't even banned until the late 1980's in this country even though Pliny the Elder described how slaves in Roman asbestos mines had shorter lives. We incredibly ignored this problem despite the evidence for a very very long time.

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#21

Might be Nonsense

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>I have always been under the impression the mineral stuff used as insulation was called rock wool. I checked, and what was produced was actually called "vermiculite". It was used as insulation and a soil amender and it did contain asbestos. Sorry if my terminology may have been off, but I'm not sure it was:

A google search for "asbestos rock wool" produced www.doh.wa.gov/ehp/ts/IAQ/AsbestosVermiculiteInsulation.html

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#22

Vermiculite is a different mineral... *LINK*

John in New Mexico

>Though in some deposits, like the one in Montana, it is associated with asbestos - both can be found in a specific grade of metamorphic rock. There's no confusing vermiculite with rock wool, as vermiculite is not fiberous or scratchy feeling. If it'd help, I'll take a picture of some vermiculite I have here and post it.

I looked around for a quick reference on rock wool, and this one appears to cover it pretty well (diabase is another rock similar to basalt, but with less silica).


Rock wool

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#23

Re: My neighbor just did his house

Bart Castleberry

>Most insluation contractors buy in bulk and can install it for less than you can buy it for from HD or lowes. I have had them install batts R38 in a 14' ceiling from scaffolding for $1/sqaure foot which was less than the material would have cost me. and yes the batts were brand name labeled and instlaled very well. You might do as good or close to a contractor renting by the blower, but I bet a insualtion contractor would be cheaper than the material.

Re: Insulation opinions wanted - OT

#24

Re: Might be Nonsense

Mark Nowicki

>I think Jesper might be referring to the modern mineral wool insulation which is sold under the brand name ROXUL in Canada. It is also known as ROCKWOOL. It believe it is manufactured by a Danish company.

The stuff from 50 years ago could contain anything.

Mark