Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

OT: Outdoor wood furnaces

Posts

OT: Outdoor wood furnaces

#1

OT: Outdoor wood furnaces

Rich Schneider

>I'm considering installing an outdoor wood furance system for my shop (about 2800 sq. ft, well insulated, 8ft walls, Southern Wisconsin). I've been researching and looking various manufacturers systems (Woodmaster, etc) and would like to hear others opinions on wood furance systems. I've heard/read some really bad things about potential smokiness, ashes coming out of the chimeny, amount of wood you need to burn, green vs. dry wood, etc...what are your thoughts? Currenlty I heat with LP and two 75000 but unit heaters, but am frustrated with my local LP suppliers.

Re: OT: Outdoor wood furnaces

#2

Re: OT: Outdoor wood furnaces

Bill Howatt

>Personally, I think they are best suited to the wide-open spaces and have no place in areas where they are near neighbours. I believe there has even been talk of banning them in our area. The reason is smoke. They tend to have relatively low chimneys.

While I'm on the soap-box, I have come to detest all wood-burning devices even though I used to burn wood in my fireplace. You live out of the big city where the air is fresh and then somebody fires up the wood-stove or the outdoor fireplace and puts an end to the fresh air requiring you to run around and close the doors and windows.

Bill

Re: OT: Outdoor wood furnaces

#3

Re: OT: Outdoor wood furnaces

Lee Ohmart

>Outdoor furnaces have become a very controversial issue here in Maine. The earlier models discharge a high level of particulate matter into the air which exacerbates any pulmonary diseases or syndromes from which the neighbors may be suffering. Many towns are outlawing new installations and putting restrictions on existing furnaces. There is a newer model being developed by a firm in Millinocket, Maine. It essentially cooks the wood and then burns the smoke leaving very little to be discharged into the air. There is also another firm in Bangor which claimed to have increased the efficiency of heat pumps so that it made them economical at northern lattitudes. I haven't seen anything in the newspaper about them since the announcement so I don't know if they have anything marketable yet. Our electricity rates are so high in Maine that a heat pump would have to be very efficient to pay off. One green alternative that seems to pay off in Maine is a system that uses solar collectors to heat water for domestic use or heating. The cost of the system is low enough so that the payback is reasonable.

Re: OT: Outdoor wood furnaces

#4

They are all bad!

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>There are two installed in my neighborhood and on cold winter days or days when the breeze is from them toward my yard or days with temperature inversion during the heating season you can hardly breathe outside due to the smoke from these things. If the wind isn't blowing the smoke builds up in the vicinity of the woodburners. I also find it difficult to believe that they are very economical if you consider your time consumed gathering wood, stoking the fire, hauling ash, cost of a chain saw, truck or trailer to haul wood, wood storage building worth very much.

Who tends the fire if you are away from home for a couple of days?

I sure hope my neighbors don't install any more in our area.

Lee

Re: OT: Outdoor wood furnaces

#5

Re: They are all bad!--agreed!

Geoff in Madison

>Heartily agreed. The particulate air pollution produced is amazing. There are also no regulations on efficiency or particulate emissions (although you can bet they are coming). Wood burning stoves have some rules, the outdoor smokers don't.

In urban areas, the public health departments have been trying to find ways to get them shut down because of the air pollution and nuisance factor. They can't be good for anyone's asthma.

Re: OT: Outdoor wood furnaces

#6

Re: They are all bad!

Lee Ohmart

>Actually, according to what I read about the furnaces being developed in Millinocket, they should be no worse than oil furnaces insofar a air pollution is concerned. I do agree, however, that working up all that wood and tending the furnace takes all of the attraction away for me. I've prepared wood for burning all the way from the stump to shoveling out the ashes and it's a lot of dirty work. If I ever get to build a house, I'm going to pile on all the insulation I can afford and take a long hard look at heat pumps and solar. Maine is the tailpipe of the nation and we have to reduce air pollution as much as possible because the air we get from everyone west of us is already polluted.

Re: OT: Outdoor wood furnaces

#7

Not all bad...

Randy Stukenberg

>I have heated my 2400 sq. ft shop with an outdoor wood fired boiler from Central Boiler for 5 years. I love it. I am out in the country which is a plus as far as smoke is concerned. I don't think they have a place in town with a lot of close neighbors. Yes, it is a lot of work cutting and splitting wood. But hey, your doctor tells you that you need more exercise anyway, right? If you have a plentiful supply of wood, you can't beat the cost of fuel - free! Once people find out you need firewood, you won't be able to go anywhere without someone asking if you want that dead tree in their yard/woods/fencerow, etc.

As for daily chores, if it is sized right, you only need to fill it once a day, stir the ashes before you fill it, throw in a little Ashtrol and you are good. I empty the ashes in mine about once a month or so. A lot depends on the type of wood you burn.

Not all burners are alike. I looked at a lot of them and found Cnetral Boiler had the best design. If you want, I send me an email and I can get you the number of my boiler guy. I am in N. IL near Rockford. Check centralboiler.com for info. They also have an LP add-on and now a corn add-on for those days you might be gone. They also have a corn-only burning furnace. I would reccommend using radiant floor heat in your shop. You can also hook it up to your house and get even more use out of the wood.

-Randy

Re: OT: Outdoor wood furnaces

#8

Also...

Randy Stukenberg

>I don't recall ever seeing ash coming out of the stack. Maybe once when I had a fire roaring and the door open. Normally there is a damper that lets in enough air to burn, but not excessive draft.

Of course, dry wood burns better and more efficiently than green wood. But, as long as it burns, you are getting some good. I burn about any species of wood available. A lot of people tell you you should only burn oak or maple because it has the highest btu's, but if it is free, who cares if it is the most "efficient"!?! I burn walnut, cherry, hackberry, elm, oak, maple, even pine occasionally. Yes, pine. The creosote burns up and is a negligible problem.

If you already have an existing heat system, you can convert it by installing a heat exchanger (basically a fancy radiator) and blowing air over it like a furnace. There are many ways you can set it up to get the heat.

Good Luck!