Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Pine floor, sleeper thickness and spacing

Posts

Pine floor, sleeper thickness and spacing

#1

Pine floor, sleeper thickness and spacing

Nathan

>Thanks to Barry, Keith, and Andy for the replies and advice. The structure I'm installing the floor on is about 6 years old. It consists of two inches thick steel-mesh-reinforced concrete sitting on steel I-beams. This is the upstairs floor, so moisture is not an issue.

I'm making the sleepers myself, it's no problem to make a few more of any thickness. So I will reduce the spacing down to 16" or so as you suggest.

The fastener type commonly used here for the sleepers is a plastic screw anchor with a screw already partway into it (scroll down for picture of it). I will pre-drill holes in the sleepers for the fasteners. I will then liquid nail the sleeper onto the concrete subfloor and hammer-drill through it down into the concrete. Then I'll drop a fastener into each hole and tap the screw down into the plastic anchor with a hammer. These are specially-threaded screws that you can drive in with a hammer, but have to rotate to get them out (you can kinda see in the picture how the threads are angled).

To get the fasteners all the way in I'll have to drill a little further into the concrete so there's room to accommodate the concrete dust that, having nowhere else for it to go, will accumulate at the bottom of the hole.

The reason I was going to use screws was I was afraid the 1" sleepers would not hold regular nails tightly enough. What I hear you saying is I could use ring-shanked nails, in which case I could get away with 0.85" sleeper thickness. Thanks for this idea - ring-shanked nails would never have occurred to me.

One thing does worry me about the nail idea - If I don't get the angle right I'm concerned I could bottom out against the concrete with part of the nail sticking out. If that happened with a ring-shanked nail, wouldn't that pose a teeny-weeny problem? I suppose I could fashion a jig to get the nail started at the correct angle...


img

Re: Pine floor, sleeper thickness and spacing

#2

Levelling the subfloor

Nathan

>I forgot to mention how the subfloor is being levelled. I'm having a contractor do it because I tried it myself once and failed. So this is the second time it's being levelled. First we will apply a "deep-penetration" coat (some stuff you apply to the substrate and let it dry for 24 hours) over the old.

Then the contractor will come out with bags of this "levelling mix". I don't know what it's called in the U.S. It's basically a very fine mortar mix. If it's applied correctly, it spreads out like water (up to a certain thickness - about 3 mm) and ideally makes a perfectly level surface for installing the floor on.

You have to really know what you're doing to get it to spread out like a pool of water and form a perfectly flat surface. When I did it, my main objective was to seal the concrete so we could sweep and mop it. It worked for that, but to take advantage of its levelling properties, you have to have the right person (not me).

Re: Pine floor, sleeper thickness and spacing

#3

Re: Pine floor, sleeper thickness and spacing

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I think your plan to mechanically fasten the sleepers to the concrete is overkill. I overlaid my concrete shop floor with 3/4 T&G Advantech on 5/4 x 6 PT SYP decking sleepers, on the flat, 24 OC, floating over a poly vapor barrier. I laid 1 inch styrofoam between the sleepers for insulation and additional support. Because the finish floor and sleepers become an integral unit when complete, there is really no need to attach the sleepers to the sub-floor. Attaching the sleepers for any reason can be sufficiently accomplished with polyurethane construction adhesive.

Clint

Re: Pine floor, sleeper thickness and spacing

#4

Re: Pine floor, sleeper thickness and spacing

Nathan

>Thanks for responding, Clint. The reason I'm mechanically fastening the sleepers, I guess, is to prevent the floor from "curling up" or otherwise buckling due to the wood twisting or warping. Of course all the wood is supposed to be dry and all, but you never know what it's going to do. Still, you're right that even if one of the pine finish boards were to display a tendency to twist, the surrounding board-and-sleeper meshwork should probably hold it in place. I imagine the sleepers themselves won't twist or buckle much - too thin.

You know how it is... this is a big project for me so I'm a bit jumpy and want to have all my bases covered before I start.

Re: Pine floor, sleeper thickness and spacing

#5

Re: Pine floor, sleeper thickness and spacing

Barry Irby

>This is interesting. I would have been in the "fasten it down tightly and then fasten it some more camp." My thought would have been to glue and screw the nailers or sleepers to the floor. Or even to drill all the way through the slab and bolt it through the floor. (Kidding, sort of)

Clint's idea of floating it would be something I would like to try, on somebody else. I think it would work, but I am a little sceptical.

The problem I see with gluing it is that you don't know how tight the topping leveling coat is really adhered tot eh the original slab. If the glue sticks the sleepers tot he topping coat, but the topping coat just pulls loos then the glue has been worse than useless. If the topping coat is thick enough to interfere with the plastic screw anchors getting a grip on the original slab, then they won't work well at all and will be worse than nothing. So, if that topping?leveling slab appears to be the weak link, I would go with Clint's idea of floating the floor. Lay a sheet of polyethylene on the floor to suppress the dampness in the topping slab (it fresh and still contains moisture) and lay out the sleepers and screw down the flooring. After all, they install laminate or Pergo type flooring over an 1/8" thick layer of foam and just snap the joints together. Works fine.

I would choose screws that penetrate into the sleepers about one inch at a 45 degree angle. That way they won't come out the bottom and lift the sleepers off the slab unless you are WAY off.

Re: Pine floor, sleeper thickness and spacing

#6

Re: Pine floor, sleeper thickness and spacing

Nathan

>Thanks, Barry. I, too, was/am in the "fasten 'em down" camp. The contractor who layed the teak parquet floor was originally going to just glue the parquets to the concrete slab, but then I told him I needed to raise the floor level by 2", so he layed two 3/4" layers of particle board as a substrate. He didn't just let it float, either - he drilled and fastened it to the concrete slab. But of course the particle board + parquet combination doesn't have any structural integrity to speak of. The teak parquets are just thin strips of wood, not tongue and groove, and they're just glued to the particle board. On the other hand, I would have thought there's nothing to twist or warp.

I hear what you're saying about the levelling coat containing some residual moisture. It's really really thin, though - like 1/16" or 1/8" at the deepest and it changes color when it dries. I was thinking I'd just wait a couple days so it dries out thoroughly. I suppose putting down PE foil wouldn't be that difficult, though, and would provide good insurance.

I admit it's tempting to dispense with the hammer-drilling and the plastic screw anchors and just let the whole thing float.