>What is it about woodworking that you enjoy so much? This is a sincere question. What inspires you and what makes you passionate about it? Also, how can you tell the difference between someone who is good at woodwork and someone who is a master of it?
>Gosh what a very simple question to answer....NOT! ;-)
I'm sure there are commonalities of motivations between woodworkers but in some small way I think there are unique motivations for each of us. Woodworking is a very tactile craft. There is a little something in it for just about anyone. There is art, engineering, and something that is an enjoyable way to use our hands and our minds.
For many, the tools are as much of the experience as the craft. Many folks are drawn to woodowrking both by hand tools (new and old) and many are equally drawn by power tools...again new or old.
I come to woodworking from the perspective of art. I find designing and making furniture to be a wonderful outlet for my design expressions. I tend to be a right sided brain person so it is my nature to constantly think about design...and in most cases I apply that to woodworking.
As far as the second part of your question, again that is a broad question. Perhaps in a way, "mastery" is in the eye of the beholder. I'm not convinced that one must be able to perform skills flawlessly to be considered a master. Proficient? Maybe yes. But generally I think mastery comes with experience, understanding and true vision of one's craft.
Tom
And one cannot overlook the beauty of the materials we use...namely wood. We are blessed by an infinite palette of wood. No two pieces are alike and as we cut and finish wood we see the beauty of it come alive. In some cases that can be downright exciting.
>I work in front of a computer all day, so for me, eoodworking provides me the balance of working virtually with working in a tactile environment and allows me to use my hands in ways other than typing and clicking a mouse. I enjoy the experience of working with rough sawn lumber and turning it into something of beauty. I love the feel of wood and the smell of wood when sawing and planing it. I love the pop of the grain when I apply my first coat of an oil finish that transforms the work. I especially like the appreciation from those who are lucky enough to be the recipient of my work.
As far as being a master is concerned, I am most definitely not one, but am still able to produce a quality product. I know good work when I see it, and have great respect for those who are most advanced at their craft.
>I am drawn to, perhaps, something more philosophical about woodworking. I am a techno type in my day job and I find myself more and more disinterested with the fast paced world of technology and the politics of the business world. But when I'm in the shop, everything slows down to my pace. My body can only move so quick (and still be accurate and safe) and tools only work so fast. I enjoy a challenge that I can solve with my mind, but complete with my hands. I like to reflect on a finished piece when it's sitting in the house and remember how I made it, the trials, the successes, what I learned, etc).
I also quite like the old ways that the world is steadily losing in it's rush to implement newer, faster and more efficient processes with no human interaction. I feel that we are losing something in the technological age. Many people now change furniture like they used to change the drapes. And why not, it was just factory made mostly by machines and there is no connection with the pieces. But, when something is made by you (or for you), mostly by hand and with the care and attention of a human being, a bond with the piece is formed. These are they things that are in families for generations and are loved and respected pieces.
In addition, many of the old ways are very sound techniques. Old timber frame houses are still standing, while factory made furniture starts to crumble in a few years. We rely heavily on mechanical fastening and strengthening now because no person actually looks to use the wood correctly (for grain, strength, look, etc). I enjoy finding ways to build pieces with as few mechanical fasteners as possible and also account for the natural movement of wood. I like learning how to use a particular piece of wood if I need strength, or look, or join-ability.
A little long, but that's some of why I like woodworking.
>Get with someone and make something and get the experience. If at the end of your project you feel a desire to make something else you will have all the answers.
>What appeals to me is being able to take a number of composite parts, work on them, massage them, and transform them into something looking entirely different. (This may be a major reason why I like cooking so much also.) You can devise something utilitarian or something that just appeals to your sense of aesthetics from a pile of lumber.
I believe that there is a fine line between competancy and mastering the art and since woodworking incorporates so many diffferent aspects, an expert woodworker can cross that line many times, in both directions.
>We could all be building things out of plastic of clay or something else if it was mearly just for the technical chalange and the tactile experiance of making something. I suspect that at the root of all of the attempts to give a solid reason, something that you can grab hold of, is something more etherial. Wood speaks to ones soul.
I think the title of Master woodworker is one that others bestow on you.
>If this is something you would like to pursue knowing more about then I would reccomend you read the book "The Soul of a Tree: A Master Woodworker's Reflections" By George Nakashima. I think you will find it a good read, meaningful and a good perspective on the answers you seek.
>With the modeling work its a question of how small will it get before the " structure " of wood gives out and I get, well, " POOF ", saw-dust. Why wood ? Lets face it, anything that grows is a miracle. Wood is a miracle that can be fashioned into, I've found, just about anything. This gives a sense that you are contributing to the beauty of this wonderfull thing.
As to the " Master " part, this is the abillity to communicate the skills to another person so that they might perform the skills in a proficient manner. No matter the discipline ( woodworking, leadership, stone mason, etc )The Master is the techer / communicator / Mentor. Short of that is Journeyman. While we may have mastered the skills this does'nt, necesarily make us a " Master ". I think Ol' Norm is considered a " Master Woodworker " because He DOES / CAN communicate and teach the skills effectivly.
>I believe that within every human being, there is a deep and fundamental desire and need to create. We sometimes call that "being creative" but I believe it's deeper than that. If you believe in spiritual matters, well, I think it's tied to that.
This need to create and be creative varies in all of us. Some plant gardens, some paint paintings, some build buildings, some build software, some build cities, some build empires. Us woodworkers have a love for wood, and so our creative outlet involves wood.
How can you find or distinguish a Master? Well, you won't if you look at me, that's for sure ;)
>I've always said that I work in wood because clay is too soft and steel is too hard!! Seriously, I think that the satisfaction one gains from looking at a pile of lumber and visualizing a piece of furniture and then taking that lumber to the finished product is the mark of a skilled woodworker. We all start somewhere- look for progress, rather than perfection.
I enjoy woodworking because its one of the few things I can do acceptably well. I am basically self-taught and a south paw. It took awhile before I realized I had to make that big mental and physical adjustment. Now I can use both hands equally well. Woodworking allowed me to be my own critic and establish my own zone of satisfaction and comfort. In the Air Force and later in civilian life, I had plenty of critics while serving frequently to maintain the organizations' zones of satisfaction and comfort. I figured I could leave that behind in woodworking where the customer and me could meet in a simple and more direct relationship. Pleasing the customer and repeat business brought all the satisfaction and fun I could ever hope for. So there you have it: satisfaction and fun. How do you tell a master??? He doesn't put a cold glass of beer down on my cast iron tool surface.
>What is it about woodworking that you enjoy so much? This is a sincere question. What inspires you and what makes you passionate about it? Also, how can you tell the difference between someone who is good at woodwork and someone who is a master of it?
I've had a number of technical jobs in chemistry almost all of my working career. Woodworking gives me a chance to make something and be creative - even if I'm only making sawdust. I get the chance to read about things, explore alternatives and create something that will last. I like wood - it is warm, "organic" and once was living.
Wood inspires me.
To me, a master has the ability to conceptualize a design and execute it. It may be the simplest of forms, but it has a cleanness and purity of line that may you notice it.
>James Krenov would probably be a good source to look at to help you arrive at an answer yourself. He's authored several well written books on the topic. Most notably, "A Cabinetmakers Notebook".
>is that one often cannot tell that one is on the journey, until one is a ways down the path. And understanding Jim, at least in my limited experience, requires some experience in the craft. Or at least in some craft.
Had I started earlier in building furniture, I suspect I would have missed a lot. The 'getting older' part of life contributes a lot to the joy therein, I think.
>It's that I have a thing for my effort. It doesn't matter that I will give it to someone or if I'll use it myself, I want to have something at the end of it. I'm a psychologist and I sit around all day listening and when people leave I don't have anything that I can point to and say "I did that." As opposed to "See that well adjusted guy? That's my work."
Along the same line, I know how much I value the things that I have that my father and grandfather's made or used. I want to leave things for my boys and their families.
>Woodworking has it all. Tools of all kinds are toys. Wood is interesting and natural, in most cases nice to look at, and it smells good most of the time. The endeavor in most cases creates a product, sometimes utilitarian and sometimes an object of art. It has risk and reward. It can be done in any weather. You can pick and choose the tools you like to work with, the methods, the woods, the products, the finishes. You can be as accurate or inaccurate as you like. You can have a spotless great looking shop that produces crap or a shop that is an unsafe mess that produces the greatest looking products. In post cases, you will not meet better people across the board (no pun) in almost any endeavor as can be noted by teh general civility of this and other woodworking forums.
I echo many of the previous comments. I'm still currently in the hi-tech field, I don't know for how much longer though. I get tired of constant updating and change after a while, technology is a moving target, much of what is learned is not cumulative, but instead obosolete after a number of years.
Which takes me to woodworking. Sure there is some technology here if someone wants to embrace it, but on the other hand one can completely go the hand tool route with minimal power tools and next to no technology. Ok, maybe a digital caliper :)
Nothing much has really changed over the decades.
I realized the creative side of myself late in life and often have regrets that I should have chosen the woodworking or furniture making path early on in my career instead of the career with mass appeal.
In my case, hi-tech computer related field. When I finally walk away from hi-tech work permanently, it's kind of sad that I have nothing tangible to show for my decades of work in that field. I'm realizing it is increasingly important for me to have tangible results in my work.
Often I can't wait to quit the day job and go into the peaceful shop
with only a radio on. The process of creating furniture from rough boards is nothing short of wonderful and never ceases to amaze me.
The learning curve for woodowrking is infinite and there are so many aspects of it to explore that I am constantly challenged.
The whole tactile thing with wood, rough and finished along with design, joinery, finishing all come together to create a wonderful outlet for my creativity.
This all serves to lure me into my shop studio and maintain my keen interest in this.
>Katie, That is a great question, which I have given some thought. I wish I knew the answer, so take this response with a grain of salt.
I have been amused when someone like a young woman a while back walked into my shop. She threw her arms out as if to hug the air, and said something like, "I just love wood. I love the way it looks and feels, I love the way it smells, don't you?" Duh, well I guess I do.
While I thought it might be easy for the manufacturing side to fool her by selling her a particle-board facsimile of a nice antique with a photo finish. Yet I am sure that she had some exposure to some great wood pieces also, it was just a good indication of something deeper.
I think there is some intrinsic, maybe even genetic attraction between mankind and wood. Probably from the time the first man stood up on his hind-legs and grasp a weapon or tool, I am sure that he or she noticed the difference in the feel between a stone, and wood, especially when it was freezing, or extremely hot, not to mention the weight. Then there is the fuel factor when you add in the quest for fire.
Having earned my living by working with wood for about forty years now, I find that I can still learn things about wood. Most of the early years of that time, the wood came from the lumber-yard. However, since I now harvest much of my wood, the process starts with the tree, which may be one that I am familiar with.
I like to joke that I think most people just don't pay very much attention to trees. They are just something that is brown on the bottom and green on top, which connects the Earth and Sky. I have to admit that I see them as a potential future projects when they come to the end of their connection to the sky. I like George Nakashima's suggestion that if the soul is what is left after the life is gone, then........
I always count the rings, so I know how old they were, and have been at it and lived long enough myself and also have knowledge of our local weather history. I like being able to read some of the history recorded in the rings. When I find evidence of extreme events, which is not unusual for the oldest trees, I try to find out what I can about the event that caused this, not blemish, but character mark. Rather than eliminate an injury, I have started incorporating some of these things into my work.
I think in this day in time, a true "Master Woodworker" is a title, or claim that is best given by ones peers, but should be held in suspect if someone claims the title, while trying to sell the job. Not that the second could not be true.
Wow, what a straight-forward question(s), yet so difficult to answer - at least for me. I love working with my hands, planning a project and then trying to build what I had envisioned. I HATE sanding, but I love that moment when the first coat of finish goes on and I can see what the project will really look like. And I love saving a great deal of money building something that will last beyond my lifetime and hopefully bring enjoyment to others (as well as myself).
Regarding the difference between a good woodworker and a master, I read somewhere that a master can hide his mistakes better! 8-)
>What d I like about WW. I love wood. I like going into the woods in winter cutting logs hauling them home cutting them on my bandmill, drying in my homebuilt kiln and then taking that wood and building something for my children that will be around long after I,m gone. Every peice I build from a strip canoe to a morris chair brings new challenges. I like thinking back to my first pieces and realize how far I've come and how far I have yet to go.
Started working wood with my uncle ,hes gone now but I like to think what he would have to say about my latest pieces. Looking foward to the fall and getting into more again when my day job slows down
>I like the designing process, but not so much that I draw detailed plans. I probably should.
I like the necessity to treat the wood with respect and to accommodate it's idiosyncrasies.
I especially like the order out of chaos aspect. Trees and chainsaws. Sawmills, Stacking and drying. Selecting the pieces and prepping them.
Seeing the beauty through the rough outer layers and finding it. Trying again until I find what I want.
Its also and endless hobby or profession. Some of have mastered small parts of it, but none of us have mastered it all. There are always new directions and new skills and tools.
The master executes his designs and does not let his tools get in the way.
>For me, it is one of several interests I somehow developed as a child with some parental encouragement and have pursued at various levels of intensity over a lifetime. Earlier replies have hit many of the highlights - working with mind and hands, the nature of wood, the tools as toys and tools, the artsy side of original designs and finished modifications, pride of accomplishment, a better cheaper way to have stuff, and now a days even some desire to retreat from the complexity and problems of the world as it has recently evolved. Essentially, most woodworking (hobby at least) is very low tech and labor intensive.