Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

DC questions

Posts

DC questions

#1

DC questions

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi all,

I'm getting ready to install my dust collector system, based on an older model TotalShop 2HP, 2 bag, dust collector. Since it has a 6" intake port, is this unit capable of pulling vacuum on a 40' X 6" main plenum? The branches to each machine will be 4" pipe. The tool list includes: tablesaw, bandsaw, planer, compound miter saw, radial arm saw, shaper, router table, routers and sanders. I don't anticipate needing dust collection on any more than 2 tools at a time.

Since I have a full basement under the shop, I'm looking at putting the DC down there so we don't have to listen to it. Anyone know of any issues from that type of arrangement? Looks like the whole system, regardless of how poorly designed, would be more efficient with the addition of gravitational force. Of course, then somebody has to haul the sawdust out of the basement.

Gary

Re: DC questions

#2

Re: DC questions

Paul Dwight

>It seems like your basement install would work fine. I would love to have a basement I could move my system into!

I'm not familiar with the DC you're planning to use. Assuming you don't have a fan curve for the unit, probably the best indicator of how well it will perform is the size of the impeller. If you disassemble the impeller housing, you can measure the diameter of the impeller. In general, anything under 12" diameter is viewed as not well suited for a central DC installation. Given the amount of duct work you're thinking about, my first reaction is that even a 12" impeller might be marginal. A 13" impeller (or even larger) would be more likely to perform well.

You can maximize the performance of the DC unit with good-quality oversized filter bags. American Fabric Filter makes good filter bags and will work with you to properly size a new set of bags.

Good luck! -- Paul

Re: DC questions

#3

Re: DC questions *LINK*

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Gary,

Until recently I had a 1.5HP Grizzly that I was using for my central system. It worked well, within some limitations. I had 4" ducting.

I now have a Clear-Vue Cyclone and am converting to 6" all the way to the tools.

Here are my thoughts, your milage may very: On that size DC, and that long of a run, and assuming that your big CFM machines like a planer are not at the end of the run, I would go ahead and try the 6" ducting unless you have a 12" Fan. However, read the link below, and you will see that when you step down to 4" branches, you are choking the the airflow - almost negating the fact that you have a 6" main. Super big industrial systems can step down, and that is where many of us get the idea that we should do the same in our shop.

Read this.

Mark


http://billpentz.com/woodworking/cyclone/Ducting.cfm#DuctingIntroduction

Re: DC questions

#4

DC here :-)

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>You are looking at a marginal setup here. And Mark is right regarding the duct reducing issue, doing this will likely result in 1. reduced airflow at the tool ports, and 2. reduced air velocity in the main line than can cause dust and particles to settle.

Pentz' site is a gold mine of information, albeit difficult to navigate at times. Still well worth reading.

DC

Re: DC questions

#5

Re: DC questions

Mike Fitterling

>I have a Grizzly 2 hp with a 12" impeller with about that long a run of main piping. I ran 6" pipe over 3/4" of the way, then reduced to 5" for the remainder of the run. My bigest dust/chip producers (12" jointer and 15" planer) are at the very beginning of the run where there are two blast gates, one 5" for the jointer and one 4" for the planer. My main ducting runs along the floor which I believe helps as nothing has to be sucked "up" before heading to the DC, but simply "falls" into the ducting system. I had to do a perimeter run, which is not very efficient, but with the floor placement of the duct and using VERY wide turns, one at the six inch corner and one at the 5" corner, it has been working pretty well. The low dust producers are at the end of the line (my bandsaws) with a RAS in about the middle. All the pipe is snap-lock metal, except for the short flex from the gates to the machines. I also have a couple other blast gates located about 1/4 of the way from the DC where I can floor sweep and hook up mobile machines, like my router table. This has worked out well for me, but would be a killer system with a 3 hp DC at the end. I never use more than one gate at a time. My tablesaw has a small one bag 1 hp DC tucked under the extension table dedicated to just that machine.

Cheers,

Mike

Re: DC questions

#6

Re: DC questions - other Points

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>A couple of other points.

1) Put your blast gates at where the arms come off the main run - that way they do not cause as much drag on the system. Yes, it may require and extra step or two, but performance will be much better.

2) I should have mentioned, that Bill's articles are centered around capturing the smallest, most dangerous to your health, dust. Chips are pretty easy to capture and move.

3) Any way that you can shorten runs will help. For instance if you can move your DC so that you have two 20' runs, with the ability to make one active when you need it, and switch to the other when you need it, will really help

Mark

Re: DC questions

#7

Re: DC questions

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Thanks guys,

I appreciate the info. Thanks also for the link, Mark. Looks like I'm going to be doing some research.

Putting this guy in the center of two runs is easy enough. I was going to use 4" drops because I got several pieces of 4" tubing from the guy who gave me the DC. One thing I won't have to worry about is vertical transport of dust and chips, so my needed CFM should be somewhere around the value needed for horizontal transport. That should help.

I'll let you guys know how this turns out. If I had an extra $1000, I know where I can get a 7.5HP 3PH unit. I would think that might be sufficient to the task. 8^]

Gary