Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

OT-External Hard Drive Cases

Posts

OT-External Hard Drive Cases

#1

OT-External Hard Drive Cases

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>This is a long way from wood working but there is a lot of knowledge here at WC. I have a couple of 3.5" IDE hard drives that I would like to put in cases and be able to connect them to one of my computers using USB 2.0. When I look online at possible cases I see dozens of them. Any experience with particular models and makes of these cases? I am not going to be using these drives on a 24/7 basis so I don't think that I need to be a case with a fan. But who knows I have been wrong before.

Howard

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

#2

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

Chuck W

>Howard,

I recently bought a "Vantec Nexstar 3; model: NST-360SU-BL" which I find works very well.

It has a SATA to eSATA/USB 2.0 interface and supports up to a 750gig hard drive.

The unit has a very stylish look and comes with all cables and power adapters needed.

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

#3

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

Robert Henderson

>I currently have an eide and a sata external case. Both bought at Geeks.com. No complaints.

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

#4

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

David Yoho

>Howard, I've been using a Venus DS3 I purchased online last year. It was very inexpensive and allowed me to utilize an old IBM internal drive I had. It accommodates up to a 400 GB IDE drive and has a fan for cooling. Hard drives get hot during use and I think the fan is important.

I recently bought a new external 500 GB drive real cheap and have given the Venus DS3 to my son to use for extra storage.

David

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

#5

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

Tom

>Apricorn is a good name. It'll probably come with some good software too. Cypress chipsets used to be the one to watch for (and Apricorn uses them, or at least my version does). Not sure if anybody makes a better chipset now or not. You'll pay more for an Apricorn, at least more than the $10 or free-after-rebate versions.

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

#6

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

John McGaw

>I had a similar situation with four Seagate 200gB IDE drives sitting idle. I finally bought three ADS TECH enclosures model USBX-835 and they have worked out fine despite being quite cheap. No fans but I only use them for short periods for backups and rotate them through the bank's safety deposit box for secure storage. No complaints at all.

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

#7

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

Chicago Bob

>Target has an I/O Magic 320 gb external drive/ USB 2.0 connection with a nice case on sale for $88.00 during this week.

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

#8

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

Bill Howatt

>I also have that Vantec and it is excellent. However, the poster has spare IDE drives not SATA.

Bill

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

#9

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>Apricorn is the name that I was trying to remember. I found a unit at Newegg with USB 2.0 for $44 and a $10 mail in rebate. That is the one that I have decided to buy.

Thanks to everyone for their inputs. WC comes through again!

Howard

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

#10

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

Chuck W

>Bill,

They do make a model for IDE to USB 2.0.

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

#11

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases *LINK*

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>I have the chassis linked below that I got from CompUSA for $30. I mounted an old 3.5" IDE drive in it and use it for data backup only. It used USB 2.0 interface and comes with a wall-wart power supply. No fan, but I've had no heat issues. I don't leave this unit on for any length of time. Just long enough to do routine backups of important data that I would no want to lose. It's cheap data storage for me.

When finished backing up or archiving data, I unplug it from everything. Disconnect the USB cable and the power supply cable. At that point, it's just a paperweight on the desk, immune to power surges or lightning strikes. I already lost one computer and all the data to a lightning storm. Never again.

I like this unit and it's very inexpensive.


CompUSA External Drive Chassis

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

#12

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

Derek

>I have 2-3 of the Vantec USB 2.0 to IDE enclosures. They work really well.

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

#13

Well, it works

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I have that a couple of that model, as well as about a dozen others.

This one does work, and it was the least expensive, but it's also the cheapest (built) of all I have. Just flimsy feeling.

I keep several in the car with me. I keep them in soft foam padded lunch boxes for extra protection. This one, because it's all inexpensive plastic, really get's looking raggedly in a hurry. Even in it's case. My aluminum cased ones don't suffer the same cosmetic problems. I prefer the aluminum ones. I feel that the metal dissapates the heat better, and that the plastic tends to insulate it inside more. But I have no scientific proof of that.

If you leave it at home, then your biggest concern is the heat. But none of mine have fans, and they all are fine. IF you travel then the prtection of the drive is important. ALumin cased ones are usually better, but not always so. How the drive is suspending inside has alot to do with it. A metal case case transfer all the shock to the drive if it's not suspended inside well.

That's one good thing with this cheap CompUSA one. Because it's all plastic, and the plastic is realtivey soft, the case breaks before the drive is damaged. So like a car with crush/crumble zones, this case protects the drive inside. At least the first few falls.

I haev about a dozen cases plus another dozen or so of external drives. This one from CompUSA is a good price and has had a lot of use and hasn't failed so it's been good, but it's not my favorite.

Then again it's half the price of the other's I like.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT-External Hard Drive Cases

#14

OT-Apricorn

Howard Norman-Prescott, AZ

>The ex bus dt made by Apricorn came yesterday. I put a 120 gig IDE drive in it and it works as advertised. The case has a fan which is quiet. It seems to be a good case.

Howard