Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Tabletop thickness

Posts

Tabletop thickness

#1

Tabletop thickness

Steven Pollack in Chicago

>I bought this piece of mahogany stump for a back of the couch tabletop. It measures 51" wide and 12" deep in the middle. It is 2 1/8" thick and I am thinking about sawing it into two slices. The pieces would probably be less than 1" thick when I am done, right?

In my minds eye, 1" to 1 1/2" seems like the right thickness for a top. 2" and above seems too slabby to me but I am concerned that 7/8" will seem too thin.

What are your thoughts about tabletop thickness?

Thanks,

Steve


img

Re: Tabletop thickness

#2

Re: Tabletop thickness

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I suspect by resawing in half you are correct that each piece would be under 1" by the time you flatten them.

But who says you have to resaw it in half? It's a gorgeous piece of wood. If you want the table top to be over 1" then resaw for the thickness you desire. The remainder will be thinner but there are lot's of uses for that wood in a thinner thickness.

Tom

Re: Tabletop thickness

#3

Agree

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Steven,

I'd treat that slab like a pickle. Thin sliced. Make up whatever thickness with secondary wood and face/profile edge with mahogany. Beauty is truely skin deep.

George

Re: Tabletop thickness

#4

uh, Colonel

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>Sir,

I always click on a Colonel post hoping for my smile of the day, so imagine my surprise to find an illogical muttering instead! The way I read Tommy's post ("make the top thick and use the leftover for whatever") and then your post ("I like pickles") made me wonder why you titled yours "agree".

Sir Thomas does have the correct answer: wide table tops should be at least 1" thick so resawing in HALF does not make sense. Your idea (I think) of treating this slab as a source for veneer-type treatment loses a lot at the edges.

Make the top from this piece as thick as is aesthetically correct and use whatever is leftover for making pickle slices.

Tom

wondering if lunch includes, well, you know

Re: Tabletop thickness

#5

Re: uh, Colonel

Steven Pollack in Chicago

>Alright, lets say I go for 1 1/5" thick table and get a 3/8" pickle slice as a leftover. What suggestions do you have for using the pickle slice? I mean besides sending it to you.

Steve

Re: Tabletop thickness

#6

Re: uh, Colonel

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>You could use the pickle slice for panels in cabinet door frames. And nobody says that veneer has to be super thin. Save it for a project where you can hide the edges and use it as a thick veneer.

Plenty of other uses for 3/8" material. Save it...the right project will come along.

Tom

Re: Tabletop thickness

#7

Re: uh, Colonel

Robert Henderson

>3/8" is good for scales on a knife or other tool handle

Re: Tabletop thickness

#8

Pickle Slices

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Tom,

I still agree with Tommy. My incoherent mumblings may have seemed illogical, but were written before lunch, and while I was thinking about Bill Grumbine's wife and daughters. They make the finest pickles in the entire world. They,(ie., the pickles) like beautifukl wood, should be sliced thin to last longer. :<) Ah, if I were where you are, I'd have lunch on "the Hill", albeit w/o condiments.

George

Re: Tabletop thickness

#9

Darn You Colonel!

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Good Afternoon Colonel,

Thanks to you I am hungry! Mr. Sontag knows I am originally from St. Louis. I have enjoyed many fine dining experiences on "The Hill". As fine of Italian dining as one would ever need.

And as for me...right now, thanks to YOU, I am craving a plate of Toasted Ravioli!!

Tommy

Re: Tabletop thickness

#10

Nice To Be Influential

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Well Tommy,

I've had Italian Food all over the world including Italy. My vote still goes to "The Hill". They really are not that good on pickles, however. Hope you enjoyed your lunch.

George

Re: Tabletop thickness

#11

Come to 'bama and have some fried pickles- Yum!

Mark in B'ham

>

Re: Tabletop thickness

#12

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Take 2 slices off

Jim in Burlington On

>Take 2 1/4" slices off and keep the rest for the table. It would make a nice pair of door panel's.

Re: Tabletop thickness

#13

Steve: You're clearly troubled, let me help

Brian in Brighton

>I can help you out of your dilemma. Please ship me the piece of wood and I will happily exchange it for a nice rectangular piece of plywood to help you out. :-)

Brian in Brighton, admiring that nice slab.